Skip to Content

13 Maple Syrup Substitutes That Are Still Good For You

13 Maple Syrup Substitutes That Are Still Good For You

Sharing is caring!

Cooking at home is a great way to save money and have control over what goes into your food. But sometimes you might find yourself in a situation where you have no idea what to cook, or worse, out of the ingredients you need.

The same happens when you are out of maple syrup at home. In fact, this is a food staple, not just used for pancakes. No, there are numerous maple syrup substitute ideas out there.

The production of maple syrup is a long process that starts with tapping trees and collecting sap, boiling it down to concentrate the sugar, and then filtering it to remove impurities. This is why it might be hard to find a perfect substitute, but it’s possible.

The Best Healthy Maple Syrup Substitute For You

Now let’s tap into the best maple syrup substitute ideas that are healthy:

1. Honey

jar of honey

Honey contains less sugar than maple syrup and also has more nutritional benefits, such as antioxidants and vitamin C. In fact, if you ask me, the best maple syrup substitute is when you use honey!

It has a lower glycemic index, which makes it more suitable for diabetics and people who are on weight-loss diets. Honey also contains antioxidants and antibacterial properties that are good for the immune system.

Maple syrup is not as healthy as honey because it contains high levels of sugar. It can also cause inflammation in the body, which can lead to obesity, diabetes, and heart disease. In fact, you can even use crystalized honey after you gently heat it.

2. Vanilla extract

This extract is made by soaking vanilla beans in alcohol and water, creating a liquid that smells and tastes like vanilla. The extract can then be used as a flavoring agent in many different dishes or drinks.

Maple syrup is used as an ingredient in many dishes or drinks, but it’s often used to top pancakes and waffles instead of sweetening them with sugar or honey.

Vanilla extract is a popular substitute for maple syrup because of its rich flavor. Maple syrup, on the other hand, is much thicker and has a more intense flavor. Due to the similar texture, you can use this ingredient in place of maple extract and syrup.

3. Agave nectar

agave syrup

This nectar has a low glycemic index and contains more minerals than other sweeteners. Agave nectar can be used the same way as pure maple syrup, and it is an excellent substitute for those who are allergic to tree-based syrups.

You can substitute a cup of maple syrup or another serving with the same amount of agave nectar, which is much healthier and just a simple syrup with no sugar added. Agave nectar contains more fructose than maple syrup, which means it can be consumed in larger quantities.

That is, without having to worry about the adverse effects of sugar consumption like weight gain and tooth decay. This makes agave nectar an attractive substitute for maple syrup on your breakfast table.

4. Brown sugar syrup

Use it on baked goods and dessert recipes, and simmer it at medium heat for a total time of 15 minutes to get the best maple syrup alternatives.

Brown sugar syrup is a perfect replacement for maple syrup because it tastes similar to maple syrup. It also has more health benefits, such as having fewer calories and being less processed than maple syrup.

The aftertaste is the same as the sap of maple trees. You can even make enough to substitute a gallon of maple syrup.

5. White sugar

This is not the healthiest option, be warned! White sugar syrup is less expensive than maple syrup and can be used to make many different types of dishes. It can be added to drinks such as coffee or tea, and it’s perfect for making sauces for desserts or other dishes that call for sugar.

The popularity of white sugar syrup has increased in recent years because it is cheaper than maple syrup and can be used to make many different types of dishes. If you ask me, it’s better to look for a maple syrup recipe and make it at home than use this option.

6. Corn syrup

corn syrup

Some people like maple syrup, while others prefer corn syrup. Suppose you ask me, its a good healthy alternative to maple syrup. Corn syrup is made from cornstarch that has been broken down into glucose molecules.

In fact, I love it because it’s good with French toast, packed with potassium, and will not harden below room temperature, making it perfect for home cooks.

7. Rice malt syrup

The use of rice malt syrup has increased in recent years. This is because it offers a healthier alternative to traditional maple syrup. This is due to the fact that rice malt syrup contains no added sugar and has a lower glycemic index than maple syrup.

Moreover, rice malt syrup is cheaper and easier to make than traditional maple syrup, which makes it an appealing option for people who do not have the time or resources to create their own syrups at home.

8. Molasses

Molasses is used as a sweetener and in some medicines. It is cheaper and more available than maple syrup, so it might be a better choice for people who are looking for an affordable option. 

This healthy maple syrup substitute also has an easy recipe, so it’s quick to make at home and add some maple flavoring.

9. Coconut nectar


Coconut nectar is a natural sweetener that can be used instead of maple syrup. It is a healthier alternative because it does not have any added sugar or artificial sweeteners.

The popularity of coconut nectar has been increasing over the years, and it is now being used in many different recipes as a substitute for maple syrup. Coconut nectar can be used in the same way as maple syrup.

10. Brown rice syrup

The process of producing brown rice syrup starts with cooking brown rice in water until it reaches a soft, porridge-like consistency. Sugar is then added to this mixture and boiled until it becomes thick and syrupy.

Brown rice syrup is also vegan and gluten-free, and even though it might not sound like it, it makes it a healthier alternative to many other sweeteners on the market. Brown rice syrup has a low glycemic index which will not cause any post-eating fatigue.

11. Healthy pancake syrup

Pancake syrup is an important part of the pancake experience. It adds sweetness and flavor to the pancakes, and it also helps them stay moist. 

Surely you know that there are many different types of pancake syrups available on the market today, but not all of them are healthy.

Some syrups contain high levels of sugar or artificial sweeteners that can cause health problems over time. Pancake syrup can be made with healthier ingredients, such as agave nectar or honey. These healthy syrup options are great replacements for maple syrup.

12. Date syrup

Natural date syrup in a bowl with whole dates in the background

Date syrup is a product that is made from dates that are boiled down to form a thick, rich syrup. It has been gaining popularity in recent years as an alternative to maple syrup.

Make the golden syrup by combining 1 cup of water and 1 cup of sugar, and then simmer it. Date trees, on the other hand, grow in abundance and produce more sap than maple trees, making them a sustainable option for food producers.

13. Nut butter

Some nut butter are made from just one type of nut, while others are made from a blend of nuts. Peanut butter, coconut butter, almond butter, and cashew butter are the most popular options.

The reason why nut butter is replacing maple syrup is that it is more nutritious, healthier, and cheaper. Nut butter is a popular substitute for maple syrup. It has more nutrients, which is why it has so many fans. Plus, it’s cheaper and healthier than maple syrup.

Can I Replace Maple Syrup With Honey?

honey being poured into a white bowl

Yes, you can use honey as a healthy alternative to maple syrup because of their consistency. Of course, it depends on what you’re using it for and what you prefer.

Maple syrup is sweeter than honey, so if you’re looking for something to use as a sweetener in your coffee or tea, then honey would be better because it will give you less of intense sweetness.

Maple syrup is more expensive than other types of syrup, but it has a more distinctive flavor which gives it a number of applications for certain dishes like pancakes, waffles, and desserts are good examples.

Honey has been a popular sweetener for centuries, and it’s still just as important today. It’s cheaper than maple syrup but doesn’t taste the same.

Honey is a type of sweetener and unlike maple syrup, it has its own distinct flavor. You can use honey to add depth to dishes or desserts.

Many people have asked the question, “can I replace maple syrup with honey?” The answer to this question depends on what you are looking for in your dish. If you are looking for a sweeter taste that will not overpower other flavors, then honey would be the better choice than maple syrup.

Can Brown Sugar Be Substituted For Maple Syrup?

Brown sugar in wooden bowl and spoon

Yes, you can use brown sugar syrup as a maple syrup substitute, but you should not use plain brown sugar.

Brown sugar has chemically different properties than maple syrup. It’s less sweet and has a more grainy texture. These factors will alter the final product.

Brown sugar is often used as an alternative sweetener to maple syrup, but they have different tastes and textures. Maple syrup is more viscous and has a definite taste, whereas brown sugar can be substituted in nearly any recipe.

This sugar is often a substitute for maple syrup in many recipes but has its own unique flavor, which will vary the amount that needs to be used depending on what recipe it is being added to.

If a recipe calls for one cup of maple syrup, and you cannot find it at the store but do happen to have brown sugar in your kitchen, you can substitute it for about 3/4 to 1 cup of brown sugar.

Know Your Maple Syrup Replacements

Maple syrup is used as a sweetener and to add flavor to dishes. However, it can be expensive and hard to find in some areas.

There are many substitutes for maple syrup you can try at home and even make yourself. These substitutes are often cheaper and easier to find than maple syrup.

 Some of the most popular substitutes for maple syrup include honey, agave nectar, brown sugar, molasses, corn syrup, and rice malt syrup.This is why you should choose your favorite maple syrup substitute and get ready for an enjoyable moment of cooking since this will surely be something special.

13 Maple Syrup Substitutes That Are Still Good For You