Skip to Content

Sirloin Vs Filet: The Ultimate Battle Of The Steaks

Sirloin Vs Filet: The Ultimate Battle Of The Steaks

Sharing is caring!

With the rising popularity of steak cuts, many people are looking for a way to get the best out of their steaks. There are different kinds of steak cuts, and each one has its own distinct flavor and texture.

Steak cuts are the different parts of a cow that have been cut into steaks. The most common cuts of steak are ribeye, strip, and sirloin.

We’ve all seen them in the grocery store, but do you know what each steak cut is? Read on to learn more about the different cuts of steak!

This is why I am preparing a guide on sirloin vs filet and their pros and cons.

Sirloin Vs Fillet: The Basics

The most popular steak cut is the ribeye – it is tender and has good fat content. It is also one of the most expensive cuts, so if you are on a budget, you might want to consider getting a cheaper cut, like one of these:


Raw beef meat cap sirloin steak on a cutting board

The sirloin steak cut is a cut of beef from the back of the animal. It is a lean, tender, flavorful cut that is often grilled or pan-fried.

There are two types of sirloin steak cuts: the inside and outside. The inside cut is closer to the spine and has more fat than the outside. The outside cut has less fat and is closer to the hip bone.

A sirloin steak is a cut of beef that comes from the back of the cow. It is a lean, tender, and juicy cut. The two cuts are not interchangeable because they have different textures and flavor profiles.

It is best known for its tenderness and flavor. A sirloin steak cut has a lot to offer in terms of flavor and taste, but it can be a little bit tough if not cooked correctly. They are often served with sauces or as part of a vegetable dish.


Raw beef fillet steaks with spices on wooden background

A fillet steak is a cut of beef that is obtained by slicing the meat from the rib cage and then trimming it of excess fat. It can be cooked in many different ways but is often grilled. In addition to the rib eye, a fillet steak is the most tender cut of meat.

A fillet steak is a cut of beef that is taken from the tenderloin. It is a long, thin strip of meat that has been trimmed of all fat and sinew.

The tenderloin is the most tender part of the animal, so it makes sense that this cut would be one of the most popular in restaurants. The fillet steak can be cooked in many ways, but it’s best when it’s grilled or pan-fried.

Sure, there are different types of fillets made from beef tenderloin steak, T-bone steak, New York strip steak, ribeye steak, short loin, porterhouse steak, top sirloin steak, skirt steak, flank steak, Kansas City strip, but tenderloin filet is the best and most common option.

Is Top Sirloin The Same As Filet Mignon? 6 Differences

What are the differences between sirloin and filet? Here are some of them:

1. Location

Different cuts of beef come from different areas of the cow. The location of the cut is what determines how tender or tough the meat will be.

The filet cut of steak is located in the middle of the back of the cow, while the sirloin is cut from its rear. The sirloin is a larger cut of meat than the filet. The sirloin is typically used for roasts or grilling, while the filet is usually used for steaks.

The location of the cut on the cow and how it is cooked will also affect its flavor. The two main cuts of beef are sirloin and filet. The difference between them is where they come from on the cow and how they are cooked.

2. Taste

Juicy Fillet Steak with Fresh Herbs

Taste is the most obvious difference between these two steaks. Filets are a more tender cut of meat and are usually considered to be a bit more expensive than sirloin. Filets are often served without sauces, whereas sirloin is usually served with sauce or gravy.

Taste is the main difference between sirloin and filet steak. Sirloin is more flavorful than filet, but it has a tendency to be tougher and drier.

Filet is less delicious than sirloin, but it’s tender and juicy.

If you want a steak that’s soft and juicy, filet might be your best option. If you want to chew on a piece of beef with a lot of flavors, sirloin might be your best bet.

3. Cooking temperature

The difference in cooking temperature is dictated by the thickness of the steak. Filet steaks are thinner than sirloin steaks. The thicker the steak, the lower the cooking temperature. Still, due to their marbling, these two steaks have their own cooking temps.

Sirloin is cooked at temps between 130 and 145 degrees Fahrenheit, while filet steak is cooked up to 140 degrees. Sirloin is cooked at a higher temperature than filet steak because it is a tougher cut of meat and requires more cooking to break down the fibers.

4. Firmness

Grilled top sirloin cap or picanha steak on a stone chopping Board

Firmness is the difference between sirloin and filet steak. It is the most critical factor for determining whether meat is considered to be a steak or not. The firmer the meat, the more tender it will be, and vice versa.

Still, sirloin is extra firm when prepared, and filet will be a soft and lean cut. You will be able to cut it with a fork.

5. Seasoning

Another difference between sirloin and filet steak is the seasoning. It is what makes the meat taste delicious.

For a filet steak, you can use garlic powder, salt, and pepper to season it. You can also top it with some kind of sauce.

For beef sirloin, you can use pepper, Italian seasoning, and salt to season it. You can also add a sauce in order to make the taste more appetizing.

6. Serving

Serving size is another difference between sirloin and filet steak. This is because the serving size of a filet steak is smaller than that of a sirloin steak.

One can see that the serving size for a sirloin steak is 3 ounces, while the serving size for a filet steak is 4 ounces. The difference between these two types of steak is that sirloin steak has more connective tissue and fat, which means it needs to be cooked longer to make it tender.

Which Is Better Filet Or Sirloin?

BBQ dinner with top sirloin beef steak and salad on a plate

This depends on a number of factors, like the steakhouse, preparation method, fat content, and whether your steak is bone-in or boneless.

Steak lovers generally choose sirloin, and those who are still not accustomed to the beefy flavor choose a more tender steak, like a filet.

Filet is the cut of beef that comes from the tenderloin, which is the most tender part of the beef. Sirloin is a cut of beef that comes from the back, and it is less tender than a filet. Still, the filet has less fat or marbling on it, so it might overcook and get chewy.

Fillet is rare and pricey, but due to no signs of intramuscular fat and connective tissue in it, its internal temperature is sure to rise, and it might be subject to overcooking. It’s best if you marinade it and sear it lightly in a cast-iron pan.

Sirloin, on the other hand, is a brisket for your bbq. It is a type of steak that gives flavor but is still economical; it’s perfectly done medium rare or by broiling due to a lot of marbling. Sure, it’s not the best steak cut, but this piece of meat is pretty close.

Still, I need to say that fillet is still the best option if you wish for a buttery and almost melting consistency, while sirloin is more rugged and packed with flavor.

Understand Steak

The conclusion of the article is that steak cuts are not as simple as they seem. It takes a lot of knowledge and experience to understand the different cuts and how they should be cooked.

Still, don’t let this discourage you since you now know the differences between sirloin and filet and which one is more suitable for your type of barbecue cooking. Enjoy your feast!

11 Most Delicious Skirt Steak Substitute Cuts

Monday 28th of November 2022

[…] When comparing sirloin and filet cuts, you will see that sirloin is more flavorful than filet. When comparing to skirt steak, you will see that the sirloin tip, bottom sirloin, and all other sirloin cuts have the same amount of flavor as skirt steak. […]