Not all potato salads in the grocery aisle are created equal. Some hit that creamy, tangy sweet spot just right, while others fall flat with bland dressing or mushy potatoes.
Whether you’re hosting a barbecue or just need a quick side for weeknight dinner, picking the right tub matters.
This ranking takes you from the forgettable to the downright craveable—15 store-bought potato salad brands, tasted and ranked.
1. Great Value Original Potato Salad
Gritty texture and overly sweet dressing knock this one to the bottom of the list. The flavor lacks balance and brightness.
The potatoes feel oddly firm and under-seasoned. It’s affordable, but you get what you pay for here.
2. Aldi Park Street Deli Mustard Potato Salad
The mustard tang comes through, but the overall blend tastes one-note. It’s more sour than satisfying.
Some bites feel watery and unevenly mixed. Good price, but the flavor doesn’t go the distance.
3. Safeway Signature Select Deviled Egg Potato Salad
Hints of paprika and egg are there, but the overall result is heavy and clunky. It leans too hard into mayo.
It tries to mimic deviled eggs, but lacks sharpness and punch. Fine in a pinch, not first-choice material.
4. Reser’s Deviled Egg Potato Salad
Creamy with a touch of mustard and sweet pickle, but the egg flavor feels overly processed. The texture veers on gummy.
There’s effort in the concept, but it needs more brightness and contrast. Better than some, but not quite standout.
5. Publix Southern Style Potato Salad
Sweet relish and soft potatoes give this one a homey feel, but it leans too sugary. The mayo dominates the palate.
Fans of sweeter Southern-style salads may enjoy it. Others might find it cloying after a few bites.
6. Trader Joe’s Old-Fashioned Potato Salad
Well-sized potato chunks and visible herbs set it apart visually, but it tastes a little flat. Needs more salt and acid.
The creamy base is mild and clean. Good for mixing into other dishes, but bland on its own.
7. Hormel Side Dishes Homestyle Potato Salad
This one is heavy on the mayo, with soft potatoes and a slightly vinegary tang. The texture is smooth, almost whipped.
It’s decent in small servings, but feels dense and unbalanced overall. Not bad, just a bit overwhelming.
8. Market Pantry Classic Potato Salad
Surprisingly well-seasoned for a store brand, with balanced mayo and just enough crunch from celery. The texture is nicely chunked.
It’s not flashy, but it’s reliable and affordable. A solid pick when you need something simple that works.
9. Sam’s Club Member’s Mark Southern Style Potato Salad
At first glance, Sam’s Club Member’s Mark Southern Style Potato Salad captivates with its generous portion and creamy texture. The Southern-inspired flavors offer a delectable mix of sweet and savory.
The potatoes hold up nicely, providing just the right amount of bite in each mouthful. However, some might find the sweetness a bit overpowering for their taste.
Perfect for large gatherings or parties, this potato salad is a delightful addition that embodies Southern charm. A great choice if you’re hosting a crowd and want a reliable, tasty option.
10. Freshness Guaranteed Original Potato Salad
Bright, eggy, and well-balanced with tangy dressing and soft potatoes. A pleasant surprise from Walmart’s deli case.
The flavor holds up bite after bite. Not too rich, not too bland—just a classic done right.
11. Whole Foods Market Classic Potato Salad
Clean ingredients and light seasoning let the potatoes shine. The herbs and Dijon kick bring brightness.
A fresh, elevated take with fewer additives. Slightly pricier, but you taste the quality in each forkful.
12. Boar’s Head Homestyle Potato Salad
Smooth, balanced, and gently seasoned with a homemade feel. The potatoes are tender but not mushy.
The dressing is rich but not heavy, with hints of mustard and celery seed. Tastes like your favorite deli made it that morning.
13. Costco’s Stonemill Kitchens Red Potato Salad
Tender red potatoes in a creamy dressing with fresh chives and a tangy finish. The flavor feels layered and thoughtful.
The potato skins add texture and depth. A top-tier option that feels elevated without losing comfort.
14. Walmart Deli Red Skin Potato Salad
Perfectly cooked potatoes with skins intact, tossed in a smooth dressing that hits the ideal balance of sweet and savory.
A creamy texture without being heavy. Tastes like picnic food made by someone who really cares.
15. Reser’s Original Potato Salad
This one nails the classic profile—soft but structured potatoes, mildly sweet dressing, and gentle seasoning. Everything is in harmony.
It’s creamy, nostalgic, and widely available for a reason. An easy winner that tastes like tradition.