Peanut butter is more than a snack—it’s a kitchen essential. Whether spread on toast or stirred into sauce, the right jar makes a difference.
Chefs know which brands bring the best flavor, texture, and ingredients. These 15 picks are their top choices for every peanut butter craving.
1. Jif Creamy
Smooth and perfectly spreadable, this classic delivers consistent flavor with just enough salt and sweetness. It’s a go-to for comfort food.
Great in cookies, sandwiches, or straight from the spoon. Many chefs still reach for it when nostalgia meets flavor.
2. Skippy Natural
With a slightly looser texture and no high fructose corn syrup, this jar keeps things familiar while leaning more natural.
Peanut flavor still shines through, with just the right touch of oil for smooth blending. A reliable pick for sauces and toast.
3. Trader Joe’s Creamy Salted
Made with only peanuts and salt, it’s dense, bold, and a bit grainy in the best way. Rich flavor feels close to homemade.
Chefs love the natural taste and balanced saltiness. Stir before using—this one separates naturally.
4. Smucker’s Natural
Minimal ingredients and a roasted, deep peanut flavor make this a pantry must for chefs who value purity and punch.
The texture is thick and satisfying, especially in savory dishes. A few stirs turn it from rustic to silky.
5. 365 Organic Peanut Butter
Whole Foods’ store brand offers a smooth, no-frills peanut butter that works in both sweet and savory recipes.
It’s simple, clean, and affordable. Great when you want the nut to do all the talking.
6. Teddie All Natural
Made in Massachusetts, this old-school brand keeps things straightforward with bold roast flavor and no added sugar.
Crunchy and creamy varieties both deliver a hearty bite. Chefs love its consistency and reliability in baking.
7. Peter Pan Honey Roast
Slightly sweet and ultra-smooth, this version blends peanut richness with a mellow honey finish. It melts beautifully on warm bread.
Though not as natural as others, the flavor has a fan base for a reason. It’s comfort in a jar.
8. Justin’s Classic
Crafted with just peanuts and palm oil, this spread leans luxurious and lightly roasted, with a dense, nutty profile.
Spoon it into smoothies, spread it on waffles, or pair it with dark chocolate. A chef favorite for modern dishes.
9. Crazy Richard’s 100% Peanuts
For those who appreciate pure peanut butter, Crazy Richard’s 100% Peanuts is a top pick. Made with only peanuts, it offers a straightforward and robust flavor. Chefs enjoy using it in recipes where the true essence of peanuts can shine. Its simple ingredients list and rich taste make it a favorite for both cooking and snacking.
10. Adams Natural Creamy
A West Coast staple, this jar offers a rustic texture and strong roasted notes that hold up in cooking.
No added sugar, just peanuts and salt. Ideal for chefs who want control over sweetness and seasoning.
11. MaraNatha Organic
Creamy and mild, this organic spread brings a smooth, buttery finish perfect for breakfast or baking.
The texture is ultra-silky, with a mellow roast. Chefs appreciate its clean label and subtle flavor.
12. Kirkland Signature Organic
Costco’s offering is a bulk favorite with solid quality. It’s smooth, lightly salted, and made from roasted organic peanuts.
Great for households or restaurant kitchens alike. You get more than value—you get consistency.
13. Santa Cruz Organic
This California-based jar brings a nutty aroma and creamy flow, with an organic pedigree chefs can trust.
Perfect for banana pairings or energy bites. It’s balanced and beautifully simple.
14. Peanut Butter & Co. Crunch Time
Big peanut chunks meet sweet-savory flavor in this bold, crunchy version. The texture adds character to every bite.
Chefs reach for it when they want a little extra bite and a touch of indulgence.
15. Wild Friends Classic Creamy
This women-founded brand makes clean-label peanut butter that’s rich, thick, and full of roasted flavor.
Smooth enough for swirling into oatmeal, yet bold enough for sauces. A modern favorite among health-focused chefs.