Skip to Content

The 22 Greatest American Pizzas – How Many Have You Tried?

The 22 Greatest American Pizzas – How Many Have You Tried?

Sharing is caring!

Welcome to the ultimate guide on American pizzas that will take your taste buds on a whirlwind adventure!

From the cheesy dreams of New York to the deep-dish wonders of Chicago, we’ve uncovered 22 incredible pizzas that stand as icons in the culinary world. Buckle up and get ready to explore the most mouth-watering creations across the United States.

1. New York Style Pizza

New York Style Pizza
© scottspizzatours

The stuff of legends. Foldable, cheesy, and slightly charred, it’s a slice that speaks to your soul.

You can almost hear the city hustle in every bite. This pie’s thin crust and generous cheese topping create an irresistible combination that demands to be devoured.

2. Chicago Deep Dish Pizza

Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
© topsecretrecipes

Imagine cheese, sauce, and toppings stacked like a culinary skyscraper! Each bite is a rich, gooey exploration.

This pizza flips tradition on its head, with a crust that’s more pie than bread. It’s a fork-and-knife affair, a slow dance with flavors that leaves you delightfully stuffed.

3. St. Louis Style Pizza

St. Louis Style Pizza
© tonyspizza415

This pizza defies expectations. Crunchy and square-cut, it’s the rebellious teenager of the pizza world.

Topped with Provel cheese, a gooey blend of provolone, Swiss, and cheddar, it’s an experience like no other. It’s a quirky twist that makes it stand out in the pizza crowd.

4. California Pizza

California Pizza
© notapizzeria

A fresh breeze in the pizza scene. Loaded with veggies and unexpected toppings like goat cheese or arugula, it’s the culinary embodiment of the Golden State.

It’s a health-conscious choice that doesn’t skimp on flavor. This pizza is for those who want a taste of sunshine on a plate.

5. Detroit Style Pizza

Detroit Style Pizza
© powpizzawindermere

Detroit’s take on pizza is an unsung hero. With its thick, airy crust and caramelized cheese edges, it’s a slice of heaven.

This pizza is all about the edges! Toppings like pepperoni sit cozily under a drizzle of tomato sauce, creating a unique flavor profile. It’s like discovering a hidden gem in the Motor City.

6. New Haven Style Apizza

New Haven Style Apizza
© scottspizzatours

New Haven apizza, a gem of the East Coast, breaks the mold with its coal-fired crust. Charred and chewy, it offers a delightful texture that sets it apart.

Famous for its clam topping, it’s a seafood lover’s dream. Pecorino cheese adds a sharp, savory note, transforming each bite into a coastal escape.

7. Philadelphia Tomato Pie

Philadelphia Tomato Pie
© mushypeaz

Simplicity at its best. No cheese? No problem. A thick, square crust is blanketed in sweet, tangy tomato sauce, letting the rich flavor shine.

Parmesan cheese is the final touch, adding a hint of nuttiness. This pie is an ode to tradition, a nod to the past with every bite.

8. Barbecue Chicken Pizza

Barbecue Chicken Pizza
© recipes_inspired

Barbecue chicken pizza brings a backyard cookout to your plate. Sweet, smoky barbecue sauce mingles with tender grilled chicken.

Red onions add a crisp bite, while cilantro keeps things fresh. It’s a fusion of flavors that refuses to play by the rules.

9. Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
© rinaldoshfx

A game-changer. Tangy buffalo sauce drenches diced chicken, creating a fiery flavor explosion.

Blue cheese crumbles add a smooth, tangy twist, while celery slices provide a refreshing crunch. This spicy number is not for the faint-hearted!

10. White Pizza

White Pizza
© sonofcaffrey

White pizza takes elegance to another level. Ricotta and mozzarella create a creamy, dreamy duo that’s subtly enhanced by garlic’s aromatic touch.

Spinach adds a pop of color and a hint of freshness. It’s a pizza that whispers rather than shouts, appealing to those who prefer sophistication over boldness.

11. Greek Pizza

Greek Pizza
© patis_bakery

A Mediterranean escape. Feta cheese, olives, and red onions create a vibrant, tangy masterpiece. Oregano sprinkles add an aromatic flair.

The thick crust serves as a hearty base for these bold flavors. It’s a taste journey that transports you to sun-drenched shores with every bite.

12. Hawaiian Pizza

Hawaiian Pizza
© wildflourpizzaco

Ultimate love-it-or-hate-it dish. Pineapple and ham create a sweet-savory dance that defies culinary boundaries.

This pizza is a tropical escape, each bite a sun-kissed memory. Mozzarella cheese ties it all together, providing a creamy base. It’s controversial yet captivating.

13. Margherita Pizza

Margherita Pizza
© sidewallpizza

Simplicity redefined! Fresh mozzarella, vibrant tomato sauce, and fragrant basil leaves create a trio of perfection.

The thin crust is a delicate canvas for these classic flavors. It’s a pizza rooted in tradition, embodying the essence of Italian cuisine.

14. Meat Lover’s Pizza

Meat Lover's Pizza
© basil_elnidopizza

A carnivore’s dream. Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and ham unite in a savory symphony. The thick crust supports this meaty medley with ease.

Each bite is a robust, hearty celebration of all things meaty. It’s a pizza that makes no apologies, unapologetically bold and satisfying.

15. Vegan Pizza

Vegan Pizza
© jiahealthyeating

Plant-based paradise. Dairy-free cheese melts over roasted vegetables, creating a colorful, flavorful feast.

Fresh herbs add an aromatic touch. It’s a compassionate choice that doesn’t compromise on taste. Perfect for those embracing a greener lifestyle.

16. Breakfast Pizza

Breakfast Pizza
© kikkomanusa

This is morning revelation. Scrambled eggs, bacon, and cheese create a savory sunrise on your plate.

Chives add a fresh, oniony zing. It’s a pizza that turns breakfast into an adventure. A delicious wake-up call.

17. Trenton Tomato Pie

Trenton Tomato Pie
© tonyspizza415

New Jersey classic. This pie flips the script, with cheese beneath a rich tomato sauce. A drizzle of olive oil adds a silky finish.

The thin crust offers a gentle crunch that complements the vibrant flavors. It’s a pizza that pays homage to the past.

18. Neapolitan Pizza

Neapolitan Pizza
© fratelloitalian

An Italian masterpiece! With a soft, airy crust and fresh, authentic toppings like mozzarella and tomatoes, it’s pure culinary poetry.

Basil adds a fragrant touch, enhancing this timeless creation. A true classic that never goes out of style.

19. Sicilian Pizza

Sicilian Pizza
© valentinaspizzeria

Sicilian pizza is a hearty delight. With its thick, rectangular crust, it stands tall among its peers. Topped with tomato sauce, mozzarella, and onions, it’s a robust, flavorful feast.

This pizza is all about the bread, offering a satisfying chew with every bite. It’s a comforting choice!

20. BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza
© pizzasundays

A mouthful of joy. Ground beef, bacon, and cheddar cheese combine with smoky barbecue sauce for a flavor explosion.

It’s a pizza that borrows from the backyard grill, a hearty, indulgent choice. The thick crust holds up to the robust toppings, ensuring a satisfying bite every time.

21. Pesto Pizza

Pesto Pizza
© loveandlemons

Pesto pizza is a green dream. Pesto sauce provides a vibrant, herbaceous base for cherry tomatoes, mozzarella, and arugula.

It’s a fresh, flavorful feast that’s as visually appealing as it is delicious. The thin crust allows the toppings to shine, creating a harmonious balance.

22. Supreme Pizza

Supreme Pizza
© the.practical.kitchen

The king of toppings. Pepperoni, sausage, bell peppers, onions, and olives create a magnificent medley of flavors.

The thick crust provides a sturdy base for this topping extravaganza. It’s a pizza for those who want it all, a celebration of variety and abundance.