Get ready for the ultimate cheesesteak battle! I took on 20 chain sandwiches, each boasting the perfect blend of meat, cheese, and bread. Some were mouthwatering masterpieces, while others—well, let’s just say they didn’t quite hit the mark.
After devouring them all, one sandwich reigned supreme. Want to know which one stole the crown? Buckle up for a flavor-packed journey through the best (and not-so-best) cheesesteaks out there!
1. Original Philly Cheesesteak – Charleys Philly Steaks
Charleys Philly Steaks is synonymous with a hearty treat. Their Original Philly Cheesesteak is brimming with onions, green peppers, and mushrooms.
Where else can you find such a generous helping of cheese that complements the seasoned steak so perfectly? Charleys knows the secret.
Hence, it’s become a staple for many, earning the number one spot with its perfectly balanced combination of flavors and textures—satisfying, bold, and undeniably delicious.
2. Big Kahuna Cheesesteak – Jersey Mike’s Subs
Spice lovers, meet your new favorite! The Big Kahuna from Jersey Mike’s is not just a sandwich; it’s an experience. Jalapeños add an unexpected kick.
How does Jersey Mike’s achieve such perfection? By layering tender steak with extra cheese, all nestled within a delightful roll.
However, it’s the blend of flavors that truly sets it apart, creating a unique and unforgettable eating adventure perfect for those who enjoy a bit of spice.
3. Cheesesteak Classic – Philly’s Best
Every cheesesteak aficionado knows Philly’s Best for its authentic taste. The sandwich features perfectly cooked thin slices of beef, generously smothered in gooey cheese.
If you’re craving that genuine Philly flavor, this sandwich is a must-try. The roll is soft yet sturdy, holding the delicious contents without falling apart.
Though located outside of Philadelphia, Philly’s Best brings the soul of the city to every bite, making it an irresistible choice for cheesesteak lovers.
4. Firehouse Cheesesteak – Firehouse Subs
Firehouse Subs offers a cheesesteak that stands out with its bold flavors. Juicy steak mingles with sautéed onions and bell peppers.
If you’re seeking a sandwich with a hint of spice, this is the one for you. It offers a delightful kick without being overpowering.
Moreover, the warm, toasted roll provides the perfect vessel for this savory mix, making it a favorite among many patrons.
5. Steak & Cheese – Subway
Subway’s Steak & Cheese is a classic choice for those on the go. With melt-in-your-mouth steak and American cheese, it’s a straightforward favorite.
How can you resist the option to customize with fresh vegetables? The freshly baked bread makes it even more appealing. Though simple, it offers a satisfying and tasty meal, ideal for lunch or dinner, and quick enough for any busy schedule.
6. Wit Whiz Cheesesteak – Pat’s King of Steaks
Pat’s King of Steaks offers the iconic Wit Whiz Cheesesteak, a true Philadelphia original. Cheese Whiz and sautéed onions make it a must-try. How does it capture the essence of the city? By combining tender steak with a unique cheesy delight.
What truly sets it apart is its authenticity, which has earned it a dedicated following. It’s this genuine quality that draws crowds, making it a beloved choice for both locals who cherish its tradition and tourists eager to experience an authentic taste of the area.
7. Ultimate Cheesesteak – Quiznos
Quiznos’ Ultimate Cheesesteak is a true masterpiece. A blend of steak and cheese, complemented by zesty sauces, defines this sandwich.
Toasting to perfection, it stands out from ordinary sandwiches. The flavors meld beautifully, creating a rich culinary experience.
Additionally, the choice of toppings allows personalization, making it a versatile option for those who crave something special.
8. Sirloin Steak & Cheese – Panera Bread
Panera Bread redefines the cheesesteak with its Sirloin Steak & Cheese. Tender sirloin paired with Vermont white cheddar creates a luxurious taste.
If elegance is what you seek, the addition of pickled onions on a toasted baguette sets this sandwich apart.
While it has a more refined touch, it still offers a comforting experience, making it ideal for those who appreciate dining in a cozy, elegant café setting.
9. Philadelphia Cheesesteak – Penn Station
Penn Station East Coast Subs delivers a delightful twist with its Philadelphia Cheesesteak. Tender steak meets creamy ranch dressing.
If you enjoy a fresh crunch, the addition of vegetables provides that satisfying texture.
Furthermore, the blend of flavors offers a refreshing take on a classic, making it a popular option for those seeking something different.
10. Chipotle Cheesesteak – Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill presents the Chipotle Cheesesteak with a fiery twist. Spicy steak and chipotle sauce create a bold flavor profile.
Whether you’re in the mood for something different or simply love a spicy kick, Moe’s has you covered.
Moreover, the lively atmosphere enhances the dining experience, making this sandwich a fun and flavorful choice.
11. Cheese Steak Hoagie – Wawa
Wawa’s Cheese Steak Hoagie is a convenient and tasty option. Tender beef, crisp lettuce, tomatoes, and onions offer a fresh, balanced bite.
How does Wawa keep it so delicious? By maintaining quality and freshness in every sandwich. Perfect for those on the move, it’s a quick and satisfying meal, ensuring you never compromise on taste or quality.
12. Prime Rib Cheesesteak – Arby’s
Arby’s brings indulgence to the table with its Prime Rib Cheesesteak. Succulent prime rib and Swiss cheese create a rich, satisfying flavor. Why settle for ordinary when you can enjoy crispy onions that add a delightful crunch?
Moreover, this sandwich is perfect for those who want to indulge in something special, making it a standout choice in the fast-food world.
13. French Dip Cheesesteak – Potbelly Sandwich Shop
Potbelly Sandwich Shop’s French Dip Cheesesteak brings an exciting fusion of flavors with a perfect marriage of roast beef and provolone cheese. The addition of savory au jus for dipping takes this sandwich to another level, adding a rich, flavorful layer that you won’t find in a traditional cheesesteak.
While the combination of roast beef and steak might seem unconventional, it surprisingly works, creating a balanced and satisfying dish. For anyone looking to try something unique, this sandwich offers a delicious twist on the classic while still delivering a comforting and flavorful experience.
14. Rocky Mountain Cheesesteak – Which Wich
Which Wich’s Rocky Mountain Cheesesteak pleasantly surprises with its hearty combination of steak, mushrooms, onions, and melted cheese. The blend of ingredients offers more depth and flavor than you might expect, making it a standout choice for those craving variety.
The vibrant atmosphere of the shop only enhances the experience, turning a simple meal into a satisfying outing. It’s definitely a delightful option that exceeds expectations for anyone looking for a delicious twist on the classic cheesesteak.
15. California Cheesesteak – Ike’s Love & Sandwiches
Ike’s Love & Sandwiches offers a California Cheesesteak with steak, avocado, and melted cheese, but it doesn’t quite live up to the hype. While the fresh ingredients give it a nice twist, the combination feels a bit underwhelming and doesn’t fully capture the essence of California.
It’s a solid option for those looking to try something different, but it doesn’t stand out as a must-try. Perfect for a casual bite in a trendy setting, but it might leave you craving a more traditional or bold cheesesteak experience.
16. Teriyaki Cheesesteak – Steak Escape
Steak Escape’s Teriyaki Cheesesteak offers an intriguing flavor combination, but the sweetness of the teriyaki marinade overwhelms the steak. While the mushrooms and onions add some texture, they don’t quite balance out the dish.
For those looking to try something new, it may feel like a missed opportunity, lacking the bold flavors that make a cheesesteak truly stand out. While it might attract some curiosity in a busy food court, it doesn’t quite deliver the memorable, satisfying experience you might hope for.
17. Barbecue Cheesesteak – Lenny’s Grill & Subs
Lenny’s Grill & Subs’ Barbecue Cheesesteak attempts to combine sweet and savory, but the overpowering barbecue sauce masks the taste of the steak. While the concept of merging these two favorites is intriguing, the sandwich doesn’t quite deliver the satisfying balance you’d expect.
For those craving a barbecue twist, it doesn’t quite measure up to a true cheesesteak experience. Though it may seem like a fun alternative, it doesn’t fully impress or provide the delicious combination fans are looking for.
18. Mushroom Swiss Cheesesteak – D’Angelo Grilled Sandwiches
D’Angelo Grilled Sandwiches’ Mushroom Swiss Cheesesteak promises a sophisticated twist, but it doesn’t quite deliver the richness you’d expect. While the mushrooms and Swiss cheese are a classic combination, the flavors feel bland and fail to elevate the sandwich.
Even for newcomers to cheesesteaks, this option lacks the excitement and depth that would make it a memorable choice. For those seeking a more refined dining experience, this falls short of offering anything truly distinctive or satisfying. It’s a miss for cheese lovers looking for a bold, flavorful bite.
19. Hawaiian Cheesesteak – Togo’s
Togo’s Hawaiian Cheesesteak promises an exotic twist with its teriyaki-glazed steak and grilled pineapple, but it falls short of expectations. While the combination of Swiss cheese and sautéed onions adds some creaminess, the sweet and savory balance feels off, and the tropical flavors don’t come together as expected.
The sandwich’s potential for a refreshing take on a classic just doesn’t hit the mark, leaving you wishing for a more harmonious blend of ingredients. For those seeking a true island-inspired flavor, this one might miss the boat.
20. Italian Cheesesteak – Capriotti’s Sandwich Shop
Capriotti’s Sandwich Shop attempts to add an Italian twist with its Italian Cheesesteak, but the provolone cheese and Italian herbs fail to create the promised harmony. While it may sound appealing, it doesn’t quite deliver the flavorful kick you’d expect from an Italian-inspired dish.
For those seeking a true Mediterranean experience, this sandwich may leave you wanting more. It’s a miss for cheese and herb lovers who were hoping for a bolder, more satisfying flavor.