Skip to Content

15 Favorite Foods You’re Unknowingly Ruining By Storing In The Fridge

15 Favorite Foods You’re Unknowingly Ruining By Storing In The Fridge

Sharing is caring!

Think the fridge is the magic solution for keeping all your food fresh? Well, for many foods it is, but for some the refrigerator can do more harm than good. 

It can dull their flavor, mess with their texture, and shorten their shelf life, leaving them in a horrible state, or even totally unpalatable after a certain period of time. 

That is why today we are going to explore 15 everyday foods that absolutely hate the fridge, and find out what is the best way to store them. 

1. Tomatoes

Ripe tomatoes
Source: Chef Standards

Ever noticed how store-bought tomatoes taste bland? That’s because refrigeration zaps their flavor and turns their juicy flesh into a mealy mess. 

Tomatoes thrive at room temperature, where they can ripen naturally. Keep them on the counter, away from direct sunlight, to enjoy their full, vibrant taste.

2. Potatoes

Potatoes
Source: Chef Standards

Potatoes are all about starch, and cold temperatures convert that starch into sugar. The result? Sweet, gritty potatoes that cook unevenly. 

That’s why it is best to store this kitchen staple in a cool, dry place like a pantry or basement and use a breathable bag or basket to prevent moisture buildup.

3. Onions

Onions
Source: Chef Standards

Moisture is an onion’s worst enemy, so the fridge is also not its friend. The fridge creates a damp environment that can lead to mold, mushiness, and sprouting. 

Because of that, keep onions in a ventilated container in a dry, dark spot. Just don’t store them near potatoes as they’ll make each other spoil faster.

4. Garlic

Garlic
Source: Chef Standards

Refrigeration is the process that speeds up sprouting and makes garlic cloves rubbery. To avoid that and keep garlic fresh and full of flavor, store bulbs in a cool, dark place with good ventilation. 

It is best to use a ceramic or mesh garlic keeper to extend their shelf life.

5. Bread

Bread and knife on a cutting board
Source: Chef Standards

Many people think the fridge prevents bread from going stale. However, it actually does the opposite. Cold air dries out bread quickly, leaving it crumbly and lifeless. 

Instead in the fridge, store bread at room temperature in a breadbox or freeze it if you need to keep it longer.

6. Avocados

Avocados on a clean kitchen table
Source: Chef Standards

This one is a little complicated for people who do not know how avocados work. Namely, unripe avocados are stubborn because they refuse to ripen in the fridge so it is not a good idea to put them there. 

Instead, they need room temperature to soften up and develop their creamy texture. Only move them to the fridge after they’re ripe to keep them fresh for a few extra days.

7. Bananas

Bananas on a kitchen counter
Source: Chef Standards

When it comes to bananas, it is the similar situation as with avocados, but not the same. Cold air interrupts the ripening process and causes banana peels to turn black. The fruit inside might still be fine, but it’ll lose some of its natural sweetness. 

That’s why it is best to leave bananas out at room temperature and let them ripen in peace.

8. Whole Melons

Watermelon on a wooden table
Source: Chef Standards

Whole melons, like watermelon and cantaloupe, lose flavor and antioxidants when refrigerated. It is best to let them sit on your counter to retain their sweetness and health benefits. 

Only when they are cut, melons should be refrigerated in an airtight container.

9. Honey

Honey in jar
Source: Chef Standards

Ever scooped out crystallized honey and wondered what went wrong? The fridge is the culprit. Honey is naturally antibacterial and preservative, so it doesn’t need cold storage. 

Instead, keep it in a sealed jar at room temperature for a smooth, golden consistency.

10. Coffee

Coffee beans
Source: Chef Standards

Storing coffee in the fridge might seem like a good idea, but it actually invites moisture, which dulls the flavor. Coffee also absorbs odors, so it might end up tasting like your leftovers. 

If you want to continue enjoying all the delights of your favorite morning drink, keep coffee beans or grounds in an airtight container in a cool, dark cabinet.

11. Oils

Bottle of olive oil with rosemary in it
Source: Chef Standards

It is never a good idea to store oils in the fridge. Cold temperatures make oils like olive oil go cloudy and solidify. While they’ll return to normal at room temperature, the repeated change can affect flavor. 

Store your oils in a pantry away from heat and sunlight for the best taste, as well as nutrition. 

12. Peanut Butter

Peanut butter in a jar
Source: Chef Standards

Nobody likes struggling to spread rock-hard peanut butter. Refrigeration makes processed peanut butter too firm and dulls its flavor which is not something we want to happen. 

So, for natural peanut butter, refrigerate only if you want to prevent the oil from separating—otherwise, a cool, dry pantry works best.

13. Stone Fruits

Stone fruits in a fruit bowl
Source: Chef Standards

Peaches, plums, and nectarines need warmth to ripen and develop their natural sweetness. The fridge slows this process, leaving you with hard, flavorless fruit. 

Considering that, it is best to let them ripen on the counter, then refrigerate if you need to prolong their life.

14. Basil

Basil on a wooden table
Source: Chef Standards

Basil is a more delicate herb than it looks as it is quite sensitive to low temperatures. Refrigeration causes it to wilt and darken almost instantly. 

Because of that, treat it like a bouquet of flowers: trim the stems and place them in a glass of water at room temperature. You’ll enjoy fresh, fragrant basil for much longer.

15. Winter Squash

Butternut squash
Source: Chef Standards

Last on this list is winter squash. Winter squash varieties, like butternut and acorn, are built to last—but not in the fridge. Cold temperatures encourage rotting. 

Instead, keep them in a cool, dry spot like a pantry, where they’ll stay fresh for months.