Skip to Content

The Worst Cottage Cheese Brands For Your Health

The Worst Cottage Cheese Brands For Your Health

Sharing is caring!

As much as I love exploring cottage cheese, many store-bought options aren’t as healthy as they seem. Packed with added sugars, sodium, and preservatives, they can lead to bloating, high blood pressure, and digestive issues.

While it’s a decent source of protein, low-fat versions often contain artificial additives that aren’t exactly good for you.

So, be cautious—what seems healthy may not always be the best choice for your health.

1. Organic Valley Cottage Cheese

Organic Valley Cottage Cheese
© organicvalley

While Organic Valley Cottage Cheese may be creamy and delicious, it’s not without its downsides. Despite its organic ingredients, this cheese is high in sodium and fat, which can contribute to elevated blood pressure and increase the risk of heart disease when consumed in excess.

The rich texture might be tempting, but it’s also calorie-dense, which could lead to weight gain if not enjoyed in moderation. Even though it’s versatile, it’s best to balance it with healthier options for overall well-being.

2. Breakstone’s Cottage Cheese

Breakstone's Cottage Cheese
© itsjakesjourney

While Breakstone’s Cottage Cheese may offer a satisfying bite and creamy texture, it’s not necessarily the healthiest choice. Its high sodium content can contribute to increased blood pressure, while the fat content could be problematic for those watching their cholesterol levels.

Although its mild flavor makes it versatile, overindulgence could lead to unnecessary calorie intake. While it’s familiar and convenient, it’s wise to enjoy it in moderation alongside a balanced diet for better health.

3. Daisy Cottage Cheese

Daisy Cottage Cheese
© tommy_sacfoodie

While Daisy Cottage Cheese may offer simplicity and a creamy texture, it’s important to consider its health drawbacks. High in sodium and fat, it could raise concerns for those monitoring heart health or blood pressure.

While the tangy flavor and versatility make it a popular choice, overindulging in this comfort food can lead to excess calorie consumption. Though it feels like home-cooked comfort, balancing it with lighter options is key for maintaining a healthy diet.

4. Hood Cottage Cheese with Chive

Hood Cottage Cheese with Chive
© hphood

Elevated is the classic cheese experience with Hood Cottage Cheese with Chive, bursting with herbal flavor. The added chives create an aromatic twist, balancing creamy and savory elements. Perfect as a snack or side dish, it invites experimentation with crackers or fresh vegetables.

This cheese is a testament to the power of simple, fresh ingredients coming together in perfect unity. However, its high sodium and fat content may pose health concerns when consumed too frequently.

5. Nancy’s Organic Probiotic Cottage Cheese

Nancy's Organic Probiotic Cottage Cheese
© nancysyogurt

Nancy’s Organic Probiotic Cottage Cheese offers more than just taste; it promises well-being—but even the best things come with a catch.

Packed with live probiotics, it supports digestive health, but it’s also high in sodium and fat, which could contribute to elevated blood pressure and heart issues if consumed in excess. While creamy and tangy, it’s not a free pass for indulgence. As with all things, moderation is key—because even the healthiest cheese can have cheddar consequences!

6. Kemp’s Small Curd Cottage Cheese

Kemp's Small Curd Cottage Cheese
© kempscows

Kemp’s Small Curd Cottage Cheese may charm with its delicate texture, but it’s not without its health concerns. Mild and comforting, it’s still high in sodium, which can contribute to elevated blood pressure and heart problems over time.

The creamy texture comes with a side of saturated fat that could impact cholesterol levels. Perfect for salads and dips, indulging in this cheese too frequently could lead to unwanted health consequences. It curdles your heart but might curdle your health goals if you’re not careful!

7. Trader Joe’s Cottage Cheese

Trader Joe's Cottage Cheese
© bryanblacio

Trader Joe’s Cottage Cheese captures the essence of freshness and quality, but it’s not without its health drawbacks.

Known for its rich texture and slightly tangy flavor, it’s still packed with sodium, which can contribute to elevated blood pressure if consumed too frequently. The creamy consistency may satisfy your taste buds, but that also means it’s higher in fat, which can impact heart health over time.

While a favorite among health-conscious consumers, enjoying it in moderation is key to avoid compromising your wellness goals. Every bite may be satisfying, but too many could leave you feeling less than cheddar.

8. Good Culture Cottage Cheese

Good Culture Cottage Cheese
© macroswithem

Deliciously indulgent, Good Culture Cottage Cheese redefines healthy eating, but it’s not a guilt-free pass. It offers a rich, creamy texture with lower fat, yet it’s still packed with sodium, which can affect blood pressure over time.

The clean, tangy taste might tempt you to go for second helpings, leading to overconsumption of calories and fat. Enhancing salads and snacks, it still requires moderation, as too much of even the best cheese can curdle your health goals. Indulge wisely, as healthful doesn’t always mean harm-less!

9. Friendship Dairies Cottage Cheese

Friendship Dairies Cottage Cheese
© friendshipdairies

Looking for a cottage cheese that embodies tradition and quality? Friendship Dairies Cottage Cheese fits the bill, offering creamy curds with a mild, satisfying taste that appeals to a wide audience. Ideal for pairing with fresh vegetables or as a topping for baked dishes, it enhances everyday meals with its rich texture.

However, despite its versatility and reliable consistency, it’s still high in sodium and fat, which can impact heart health if consumed in excess. Enjoy in moderation for a balanced, flavorful experience.

10. Lucerne Cottage Cheese

Lucerne Cottage Cheese
© emifoto

Lucerne Cottage Cheese brings an artisanal touch to the table with its creamy curds and delightful taste sensation—though you might feel cheesed out after checking the sodium content! Whether enjoyed alone or as part of a dish, its smooth texture and subtly tangy flavor make it versatile—if you can handle the extra calories.

Sure, it’s great for spreading on fresh bread, but let’s be honest, it might spread a bit too much sodium into your diet. A simple pleasure? Yes. A health hero? Maybe not so much!

11. Horizon Organic Cottage Cheese

Horizon Organic Cottage Cheese
© Whole Foods Market

Horizon Organic Cottage Cheese celebrates purity and taste, but don’t get too comfortable with all that creamy goodness! Made with organic ingredients, it offers a luscious texture that’ll make your taste buds curd with delight.

Its mild flavor pairs well with fresh veggies or stands solo—if you can handle its rich, irresistible charm. Horizon’s commitment to organic practices means it’s green in more ways than one, but don’t let the “organic” label fool you—it still packs a sodium punch. Savor it, but maybe don’t cheese your health away!

12. Muuna Cottage Cheese

Muuna Cottage Cheese
© Nosh.com

What’s creamy, delicious, and might leave you wondering if it’s too good to be true? Muuna Cottage Cheese!

A modern take on a classic favorite, it’s known for its smooth texture and refreshing taste. Blending perfectly with fruit for a sweet treat or standing alone for a savory snack, it’s as versatile as it is tasty. Muuna’s innovative approach ensures a delightful experience with every spoonful—but, like all good things, moderation is key to keeping your health in check!

13. Prairie Farms Cottage Cheese

Prairie Farms Cottage Cheese
© itsjakesjourney

What’s creamy, mild, and might sneak up on your sodium levels? Prairie Farms Cottage Cheese! Offering a smooth texture and a flavor that pleases the palate, it’s made from farm-fresh ingredients—but those “fresh” ingredients come with a hefty dose of sodium and fat.

While it’s versatile for meals and snacks, overindulging can leave you feeling less than healthy. Prairie Farms brings the warmth of home-cooked meals, but moderation is key to avoid turning that warmth into a salt-y situation!

14. Land O’Lakes Cottage Cheese

Land O'Lakes Cottage Cheese
© Instacart

Why did the cottage cheese break up with the salad? Because it found something cheddar! Land O’Lakes Cottage Cheese is synonymous with quality and taste. Its creamy texture and smooth curds offer a delightful eating experience, whether enjoyed alone or paired with other dishes. Known for its reliable consistency, it’s a staple in many households.

However, like all good things, too much of this classic cheese can add unnecessary sodium and fat to your diet—so enjoy it in moderation, or you might find yourself curdling your health goals!

15. Philadelphia Cottage Cheese

Philadelphia Cottage Cheese
© odakgida



Philadelphia Cottage Cheese may bring a touch of luxury to your meal, but with that indulgence comes a price. Its rich, creamy texture might tempt you to overindulge, and it’s packed with sodium and fat that can sneak up on your health goals.

While it’s great paired with fresh berries or used as a creamy base for desserts, that luxurious feeling might quickly turn into a salty situation for your blood pressure and waistline. Treat it as an occasional indulgence rather than a daily delight!

16. Eden Creamery Cottage Cheese

Eden Creamery Cottage Cheese
© edencreamery

Don’t let Eden Creamery Cottage Cheese cheese you into thinking it’s all indulgence without consequences. With its lush texture and mild flavor, it might tempt you to dive in, but its high sodium and fat content could sneak up on your health.

Whether used in cooking or as a snack, overindulgence can curdle your health goals. So, enjoy it in moderation, or you might find yourself in a cheesy predicament!

17. Alta Dena Cottage Cheese

Alta Dena Cottage Cheese
© altadenadairy

Alta Dena Cottage Cheese offers a harmonious balance of texture and flavor, but don’t let its creamy curds and mild taste lull you into thinking it’s all good for your health.

Its smooth consistency may make it a versatile addition to any meal, but with high sodium and fat content, it’s more of a health curd than a culinary blessing. Whether mixed into salads or enjoyed on its own, overindulgence might leave you with more than just a satisfying taste—*it could salt your health goals!

18. Knudsen Cottage Cheese

Knudsen Cottage Cheese
© shespeaksup

A classic choice, Knudsen Cottage Cheese is, but don’t let its creamy texture and slightly tangy taste fool you into thinking it’s all good for your health. Perfect for pairing with garden-fresh vegetables, it may be, yet high in sodium and fat, it remains.

A staple for culinary simplicity, it might be, but overindulgence could curdle your health goals. Reliable for flavor, it is, but too much may cheese you into a health hiccup!

19. Darigold Cottage Cheese

Darigold Cottage Cheese
© darigoldnw

It’s Darigold Cottage Cheese that delights with its rich, creamy texture and mild taste, but don’t let that fool you into thinking it’s all good for your health. With its high sodium and fat content, it could quickly derail your health goals.

Suitable for adding to recipes or enjoying as a snack, it may be, but overindulgence could lead to high cholesterol or other health issues. While it may satisfy your taste buds, moderation is key to avoid curdling your wellness plans!

20. Sierra Nevada Cheese Cottage Cheese

Sierra Nevada Cheese Cottage Cheese
© Sierra Nevada Cheese Company

Sierra Nevada Cheese Cottage Cheese embodies artisanal craftsmanship, but it’s not all smooth sailing for your health.

With its creamy, rich texture and gourmet vibe, you might be singing praises, but beware of the high sodium and fat content that might have your health goals feeling flat. “I love the tang,” you might say, but if you indulge too much, that tang might sting your waistline and curdle your wellness plans! While it stands out in flavor, moderation is key to avoid turning a cheese delight into a health fright.

21. Crowley Cottage Cheese

Crowley Cottage Cheese
© Instacart

What Crowley Cottage Cheese may lack in health-consciousness, it more than makes up for in creamy curds and a mild, pleasing flavor—too bad it’s packed with sodium and fat! Ideal for adding to meals or pairing with fresh herbs, it might seem like a comforting choice, but don’t let that fool you; its high fat content could curdle your waistline.

Though it may satisfy your taste buds, Crowley’s dedication to quality doesn’t seem to include looking out for your health—too much indulgence might leave your diet cheesed off!

22. Vermont Creamery Cottage Cheese

Vermont Creamery Cottage Cheese
© cabotcreamery

Vermont Creamery Cottage Cheese captures the essence of artisanal excellence, but don’t let its smooth texture and subtle tang fool you into thinking it’s the healthiest option. Ideal for pairing with fresh fruit or topping desserts, it may be, but its high-fat and sodium content could leave your health goals crumbling.

Vermont Creamery’s commitment to quality is clear in flavor, but its indulgent nature might leave your waistline cheesed off. Gourmet in taste, but not so cheesy for your health!

23. Hiland Dairy Cottage Cheese

Hiland Dairy Cottage Cheese
© hilanddairy

Hiland Dairy Cottage Cheese delivers a blend of quality and taste, but its creamy curds and mild flavor might just cheese you right into a health setback.

Paired with fresh vegetables or used in recipes, it may sound like a good idea, but its high sodium and fat content could leave your health goals in the lurch. A reliable choice, perhaps, but too much could make your diet feel like a cheesy mistake!

24. Kalona SuperNatural Cottage Cheese

Kalona SuperNatural Cottage Cheese
© Kalona SuperNatural

Kalona SuperNatural Cottage Cheese embodies simplicity with its organic roots, but while its creamy curds and subtle tang may offer a fresh taste, eating too much can lead to an overload of fat and sodium.

Ideal for those who value organic, it might be, but indulge too often and you’ll find your health goals cheese you into trouble. Kalona’s dedication to pure ingredients is great, but it’s easy to forget that even natural indulgence can leave your waistline suffering from a dairy disaster.

25. Mayfield Cottage Cheese

Mayfield Cottage Cheese
© mayfielddairy

Mayfield Cottage Cheese isn’t inherently bad, but like any food, moderation is key! While it might be a delicious addition to your meals, overindulging in any cheese can lead to overeating or disrupting your balanced diet, especially if you have specific dietary needs.

As long as it’s part of a varied diet, it’s probably fine! It’s more about how often you consume it rather than it being “bad” overall.

26. Western Creamery Cottage Cheese

Western Creamery Cottage Cheese
© Walmart Canada

Western Creamery Cottage Cheese offers a modern twist on a classic favorite, but don’t let those creamy curds and mild, tangy taste trick you—too much and you might find yourself moo-ving away from healthy habits.

It’s great for salads or a snack, but don’t go overboard unless you want to cheese your way into regret. Western Creamery may be innovative, but overindulgence? That’s a moo-ving mistake!

27. Stonyfield Organic Cottage Cheese

Stonyfield Organic Cottage Cheese
© Stonyfield Organic

Stonyfield Organic Cottage Cheese celebrates purity and taste with its organic ingredients, but don’t be fooled—its creamy texture and mild flavor might make you think you’re in a feel-good movie, where everything’s perfect.

However, just like a movie that’s full of cliché plot twists, overindulgence in this cottage cheese can leave you feeling bloated, like the final act dragged on longer than necessary. Sure, it’s healthy and environmentally friendly, but eating too much might have you feeling like you’re stuck in a slow-burn drama of discomfort!

28. Clover Sonoma Cottage Cheese

Clover Sonoma Cottage Cheese
© clover.sonoma

Why did the cottage cheese go to therapy? Because it felt a little “curdy” inside! Clover Sonoma Cottage Cheese might sound like a dairy dream, but don’t get too carried away—it’s the kind of cheese that’s more about looks than lasting appeal.

It’s creamy, but over time, you may realize it doesn’t exactly deliver the same level of excitement as advertised. Eat too much, and you’ll feel like you’re stuck in a dairy déjà vu, where it’s all the same, every spoonful!

29. Dean’s Cottage Cheese

Dean's Cottage Cheese
© Walmart

Why did Dean’s Cottage Cheese become the “Dean” of bad cheese? Because it’s got all the classic problems with none of the class! Sure, it’s creamy and mild, but don’t let that fool you—overindulgence can lead to feeling like you’ve hit a dairy dead-end.

With its bland flavor and questionable ingredients, it’s the textbook example of cheese that’s more about convenience than quality. Too much of this “timeless” cheese might just leave your health in a bit of a rut—maybe even failing the taste test of nutrition!