Girl Scout Cookie season brings joy to millions of Americans every year. As a professional baker, I’ve developed some strong opinions about these iconic treats. I’ve carefully evaluated each cookie based on flavor, texture, and that special nostalgic quality that keeps us coming back for more.
Here’s my ranking of all 15 Girl Scout Cookie varieties!
1. Thin Mints
Crisp chocolate wafers dipped in minty chocolate coating create pure magic in your mouth. The cooling sensation pairs perfectly with the rich chocolate undertones.
Store them in the freezer for an extra refreshing treat! Nothing beats the satisfying snap when you bite into a frozen Thin Mint.
2. Samoas/Caramel DeLites
Rings of shortbread covered with caramel, sprinkled with toasted coconut, and striped with chocolate create a symphony of textures. Each bite delivers a perfect balance of chewy, crunchy, and smooth.
The complex flavor profile makes these cookies absolutely irresistible.
3. Tagalongs/Peanut Butter Patties
Crispy cookies topped with creamy peanut butter and completely enrobed in chocolate create an addictive treat. The combination hits all the right flavor notes for peanut butter cup enthusiasts.
The slight salt from the peanut butter balances the sweet chocolate coating perfectly. Simply heavenly!
4. Do-Si-Dos/Peanut Butter Sandwich
Hearty oatmeal cookies sandwiching real peanut butter filling offer the perfect sweet-salty combo. The textured cookie exterior provides a satisfying contrast to the creamy center.
Peanut butter fans rejoice! These cookies deliver authentic peanut flavor without being overly sweet.
5. Trefoils/Shortbread
Simple, buttery perfection in the shape of the Girl Scout trefoil logo. These traditional shortbread cookies showcase how beautiful basic ingredients can be when done right.
The subtle vanilla notes and melt-in-your-mouth texture make these cookies perfect for dunking in tea or coffee. Sometimes less truly is more!
6. Lemon-Ups
Crisp, tangy lemon cookies with inspiring messages baked right into each one. The bright citrus flavor wakes up your taste buds instantly!
Not too sweet and not too tart – these cookies hit the perfect balance. Each bite delivers a sunshine burst of authentic lemon that’s refreshingly different from the chocolate-heavy options.
7. Toffee-tastic
Buttery cookies with golden toffee bits offer a delightful crunch and caramelized flavor. These gluten-free treats prove dietary restrictions don’t mean sacrificing taste!
The rich, butterscotch notes make these cookies stand out from the crowd.
8. Lemonades
Shortbread cookies topped with tangy lemon icing create a perfect balance of sweet and sour. The bright yellow icing adds a cheerful pop of color to your cookie plate.
Unlike other lemon cookies, these have a wonderful buttery base that complements the zingy topping.
9. Girl Scout S’mores
Graham sandwich cookies with chocolate and marshmallow filling bring campfire flavors indoors. No fire required for these clever cookies that capture the essence of a classic summer treat!
The chocolate-marshmallow ratio is spot-on, and the graham cookies provide the perfect crunchy vehicle.
10. Toast-Yay!
French toast-inspired cookies dipped in icing bring breakfast vibes to dessert time. Shaped like adorable tiny toast slices, these cinnamon-forward treats are relatively new to the lineup.
The cinnamon-sugar flavor profile offers a cozy, warm taste experience. These unique cookies deserve more recognition!
11. Caramel Chocolate Chip
Chewy cookies loaded with caramel and chocolate chips offer gluten-free goodness for all. The slight salt in the caramel elevates the overall flavor profile substantially.
Rich semi-sweet chocolate chunks melt beautifully against the caramel pieces. Gluten-free options can be just as indulgent as traditional varieties!
12. Adventurefuls
Brownie-inspired cookies with caramel filling topped with a chocolate drizzle deliver indulgent richness. These newer additions to the Girl Scout lineup pack serious chocolate intensity!
The chewy, fudgy texture mimics a fresh-baked brownie edge. That caramel center adds a gooey surprise that takes these already decadent cookies to the next level.
13. Thanks-A-Lot
Shortbread cookies with fudge bottoms and “Thank You” messages in multiple languages spread gratitude worldwide. The contrast between the simple shortbread and rich chocolate creates a balanced treat.
Sadly discontinued in 2021, these cookies hold a special place in many hearts.
14. Raspberry Rally
Thin, crispy raspberry-flavored cookies dipped in chocolate create a fruity twist on the classic Thin Mint structure. The berry flavor pairs surprisingly well with the rich chocolate coating.
Initially sold exclusively online, these cookies became instant collector’s items. The beautiful pink interior creates an Instagram-worthy cookie.
15. Savannah Smiles
Lemon-flavored crescent cookies dusted with powdered sugar deliver a bright, refreshing taste experience. The cute half-moon shape makes them stand.
Named after the birthplace of Girl Scout founder Juliette Gordon Low, these discontinued favorites were lemon perfection. The powdered sugar coating created a sweet-tart contrast that many fans still miss today!