Skip to Content

13 Best Substitutes For Cajun Seasoning

13 Best Substitutes For Cajun Seasoning

Sharing is caring!

One thing is for sure: there is no Louisiana creole cooking without Cajun seasoning. It is a spice mix used by mostly French settlers and even Native Americans and African Americans as well. Now, it’s a famous part of New Orleans cuisine. You can put it in almost any dish: meat, veggies, stews, tacos, soups, and other spicy food.

But what if you don’t have any Cajun spice or a Cajun seasoning recipe? Well, I guess you’ll have to use an equally tasty alternative.

But what is the best substitute for Cajun seasoning? Here’s the list:

What Is The Best Substitute For Cajun Seasoning?

The following spice can replace Cajun seasoning, and most importantly, they won’t lower the taste or quality of your meal:

1. Paprika/smoked paprika

smoked paprika in a spoon on the table

Many people probably don’t know this, but there is a huge difference between paprika and smoked paprika. Paprika is made out of dried, crushed chill peppers.

On the other hand, smoked paprika is not crushed. Instead, it comes in the form of powder and is dried over a fire.

Either way, you can use both regular paprika and smoked paprika as a substitute for Cajun seasoning.

2. Garlic powder

Ground garlic in a plate and cloves on a wooden

Garlic powder is made out of fresh garlic. Of course, you can always crush garlic and turn it into a powder or just put small pieces of it in your food. However, it’s easier to cook with garlic powder, and it also gives your food a better taste.

3. Oregano

fresh and dry oregano

Whether you buy oregano seasoning or use fresh oregano – it’s all up to you. However, please keep one thing in mind: you can’t just put fresh oregano in your meal and expect it to taste similar to a Cajun spice mix.

If you don’t buy the seasoning, you can make it yourself. Just get a small bowl, and add some salt, black pepper, and marjoram powder. For extra taste, add some dried basil and dried rosemary.

Of course, don’t forget to dry the leaves in the sun and put them in a mixer until they turn into a powder.

4. Black pepper

Black pepper in a wooden bowl

Black pepper is a spice that almost the entire world uses. It is known as the king of spices as it is the most traded spice in the world.

It has a strong flavor and can serve as a great substitute for Cajun seasoning. You can use it to spice up vegetables and even authentic New Orleans gumbo and jambalaya. Let’s not forget that it’s also one of the spices that give Mexican food its typical flavor.

5. Creole seasoning

creole seasoning spilled from a teaspoon

Creole seasoning is not only incredibly tasty – it’s also easy to make. You need salt, tablespoon paprika, onion powder, garlic powder, black, white, tablespoon cayenne pepper, and basil.

Once you get all the ingredients, you just need to put them in an airtight container, and you’re good to go!

In fact, creole seasoning has such a similar flavor profile to a Cajun seasoning blend that a lot of people mix the two up and think it’s the same thing.

Well, even though it’s a great substitute for Cajun seasoning, creole has more pepper while Cajun has more ground peppers.

6. Cayenne pepper

Cayenne pepper in a spoon

It’s impossible to think of Mexican cuisine without thinking of cayenne pepper. It is spicy but only moderately, and that’s exactly why a lot of people love it so much.

Besides being used instead of a Cajun seasoning blend, it is also a commonly used spice on pizza. Another important thing is cayenne pepper’s nutritional value. Namely, it is full of vitamins A, B, C, and K.

7. Chili powder

Chili powder on a little plate

Chili powder is used as a substitute for cayenne pepper and for a Cajun spice blend. The name says it all: it contains dried chili peppers. You can add it to vegetables, soups, meat, sauces, and other meals.

To make it at home, you need smoked paprika, regular paprika, onion powder, and cayenne pepper. Mix it all together in an airtight container, and you’ve got yourself a Cajun seasoning substitute.

8. Cumin powder

cumin seeds and cumin powder in a spoon

Cumin is typically used in Latin American, African, and Middle Eastern cuisine, but it can also be used in Cajun cuisine. At first, you might think these two seasonings have nothing in common, but that’s where you are mistaken.

If you look at things closely, you’ll notice that cumin is actually the basis of Cajun seasosing, so it won’t come as a surprise that you can use it as an alternative.

9. White pepper

White Pepper on rustic wooden table

Trust me: you can never get enough of pepper! White pepper is no less tasty than all the other options we’ve already mentioned.

The main difference between black and white pepper is in the intensity. Unlike what you may think, white pepper is even spicier than black pepper.

So, which one should you use as a substitute for Cajun seasoning? Well, it all depends on your taste. If you’re not a big fan of spicy food, I’d suggest black pepper.

10. Adobo seasoning

dry organic adobo pork seasoning in a bowl

Adobo seasoning is made of black pepper, onion powder, salt, dried oregano, and paprika. It can be found in Latin American, Indian, and Caribbean cuisine.

It has a similar taste to Cajun seasoning, and that’s what makes it one of the best Cajun seasoning substitutes. You can add it to almost any dish to make it tastier!

11. Old Bay seasoning

Old Bay seasoning on the table

Old Bay seasoning is made of allspice, cardamom, paprika, salt, ginger, pepper, and lemon. Therefore, it shouldn’t come as a surprise that you can use it as a substitute for Cajun seasoning – they both have similar flavor profiles.

12. Dried basil

Dried basil in little white spoon

If you want to make a dried basil seasoning, you can dry some basil leaves and then put them in the microwave a couple of times for less than a minute every time. Let them cool, so they can become crispy. Just crumble them into tiny pieces, and there you have it: your own homemade seasoning.

13. Celery salt

healthy dry organic celery salt in a bowl

I think the name says it all: the difference between table salt and celery salt is in the celery. You just put dried celery into regular salt, and you have a whole new spice than can be used instead of homemade Cajun seasoning.

What Is Cajun Seasoning Made Of?

Cajun seasoning contains oregano, pepper, garlic powder, paprika, cayenne, dried thyme, turmeric powder,

Besides it being so tasteful, its nutrition information shows us that it is also quite healthy. It has a lot of potassium and vitamin A, with just the right amount of carbohydrates.

It’s actually quite easy to make your own Cajun seasoning. For homemade Cajun seasoning, you need all of the ingredients mentioned above.

You don’t need a special Cajun seasoning recipe – it’s enough to put all of these herbs and ingredients together.

What about the measurements? Well, it all depends on your taste. Most people add 2–3 tablespoons paprika, 2 tablespoons salt, and a tablespoon of everything else.

The total time it takes to make it is a couple of minutes, and it’s safe to keep for a year.

Chili Flakes Vs Red Pepper Flakes: The Ultimate Comparison

Tuesday 20th of September 2022

[…] powder is a great substitute for popular cajun seasoning and many others as […]

The Best Substitute For Italian Seasoning: 13 Ideas

Monday 12th of September 2022

[…] substitute for Italian seasoning is cayenne seasoning or pepper. Cayenne pepper is known for its spicy nature, but it also has a sweet and tangy taste. […]

What To Substitute For Sweet Chili Sauce: 11 Ideal Options

Thursday 1st of September 2022

[…] sauce can be made from ancho chiles, Cajun peppers, chili paste, red chili peppers, and […]

7 Secret Ingredients In Accent Seasoning You Need To Know

Tuesday 16th of August 2022

[…] addition, you can add Cajun seasoning, red pepper powder, turmeric, glutamic acid, and MSG to your mix, in the measure of up to 1 […]

Is There A Substitute For Rosemary? 16 Alternative Ideas

Saturday 13th of August 2022

[…] just love this oriental spice, and it goes perfectly with Cajun seasoning and its substitutes. They have a similar flavor and can be used in the same way to add hints of flavor to your […]