Skip to Content

25 Secret Canned Ingredients To Upgrade Your Pot Pie (Plus 5 Surprising Ones)

25 Secret Canned Ingredients To Upgrade Your Pot Pie (Plus 5 Surprising Ones)

Sharing is caring!

Are you prepared to transform your “meh” pot pie into something spectacular?

With aromas that will make your taste buds dance, canned ingredients are your hidden treasure trove of culinary enchantment.

Learn how to make your pot pie the talk of the table with these 30 hidden jewels, each of which adds a unique touch of taste and flare. You’ll be left wondering what flavor explosion you’ll try next after every bite.

1. Canned Artichoke Hearts

Canned Artichoke Hearts
© lowsaltfoodie

How about adding a touch of sophistication with canned artichoke hearts? These tender morsels, packed in a subtle brine, provide a delightful tang and texture to your pot pie.

Layer them between your classic filling for a surprise that captivates the senses. If you’re feeling adventurous, blend them with herbs for an added dimension.

2. Canned Chipotle Peppers

Canned Chipotle Peppers
© H-E-B

Chipotle peppers, with their smoky allure, transform pot pies into a culinary masterpiece. Opening a can unveils a depth of flavor that infuses a subtle heat.

Incorporate these into the sauce for a robust kick. However, balance is key; too much can overpower. Begin with a small amount, tasting as you go.

3. Canned Coconut Milk

Canned Coconut Milk
© marinmamacooks

Where traditional cream might go, try canned coconut milk for a creamy twist. This velvety liquid adds an exotic flair, complementing robust ingredients like chicken or seafood.

Its subtle sweetness pairs well with spicy elements, creating a harmonious balance. If you’ve never ventured into coconut territory, now’s the perfect time.

4. Canned Black Beans

Canned Black Beans
© palacesuperstores

Black beans introduce a hearty, protein-rich element to any pot pie. Their earthiness melds beautifully with spices and vegetables, providing a satisfying bite. If you’re crafting a vegetarian version, they serve as a robust substitute for meat.

Consider mixing them with corn and peppers for a southwestern twist.

5. Canned Water Chestnuts

Canned Water Chestnuts
© legbootlegit

You should use water chestnuts for a surprising yet delicious crunch. The soft filling is contrasted with these mildly flavored, crisp disks.

Add them to veggies or creamy sauces to create a distinctive texture. Even though they are modest, their crunch is unforgettable, making every mouthful of your pot pie stand out.

6. Canned Pumpkin Puree

Canned Pumpkin Puree
© cozmojordan

Though often reserved for pies, pumpkin puree’s rich flavor finds a home in savory dishes too. Its creamy consistency imparts a velvety texture that enriches sauces.

Mix it with sage or nutmeg for a warm, comforting aroma that fills the kitchen. If you’re in the mood for seasonal flair, this is a must-try.

7. Canned Green Chiles

Canned Green Chiles
© hatchchileco

If you desire a hint of spice, look no further than canned green chiles. These mild yet flavorful peppers add zest without overwhelming. Stir them into your filling for a lively, aromatic twist.

They pair exceptionally well with cheese, creating a delightful fusion. Experimenting with these can lead to surprising culinary discoveries.

8. Canned Diced Tomatoes

Canned Diced Tomatoes
© redgoldtomatoes

With their luscious burst, diced tomatoes infuse hearty meals like pot pie with freshness. Their acidity lifts the taste overall by balancing rich tastes.

To get a Mediterranean flair, pair them with feta and olives. A classic is transformed into a colorful, sun-kissed masterpiece with this addition. Investigate the countless opportunities they provide.

9. Canned Pineapple Chunks

Canned Pineapple Chunks
© traderjoeslist

Pineapple chunks might sound unconventional, but they offer a sweet and tangy surprise. Infuse your pot pie with a tropical essence that complements salty and spicy flavors.

These chunks work wonders with ham or pork, making each bite a delightful contrast. If bold is your game, this ingredient won’t disappoint.

10. Canned Sardines

Canned Sardines
© tinned_fish_gazette

Sardines’ deep umami may enhance any pot pie, no matter how bold it seems. These little fish enhance tomato-based recipes by adding a delicious depth.

This may become your new favorite twist if you enjoy fish. Don’t be afraid to make this daring addition; you could be surprised.

11. Canned Sweet Corn

Canned Sweet Corn
© suritrading

The golden color of sweet corn gives your pot pie a pop of color and flavor. It has a slight crunch and texture from its juicy kernels. Combine it with bell peppers to create a vibrant blend.

Sweet corn readily accomplishes simplicity, which enhances the visual appeal and flavor of any food.

12. Canned Lentils

Canned Lentils
© koshertraderjoes

Lentils, often overlooked, provide a protein pack punch. These tiny legumes absorb flavors well, making them excellent carriers of spices and herbs.

If you’re aiming for a vegetarian pot pie, lentils serve as a hearty base. They blend seamlessly with root vegetables, offering a filling yet balanced meal.

13. Canned Tomatoes With Basil

Canned Tomatoes With Basil
© trader_joes_treasure_hunt

Tomatoes infused with basil present a fragrant twist to your pot pie. The aromatic notes of basil enhance the dish, giving it a Mediterranean flair.

Mix them into your sauce for a burst of fresh flavor. If you’re looking to impress, this simple yet effective addition will certainly do the trick.

14. Canned Chickpeas

Canned Chickpeas
© piloncilloyvainilla

Chickpeas have a buttery, nutty texture that adds depth to your pot pie. Common in Mediterranean cooking, these beans go nicely with vegetables and spices.

If you want protein, chickpeas are a good option. Without drowning out other flavors, they turn your food into a filling experience.

15. Canned Peaches

Canned Peaches
© sunrise_sweet_market

With their rich sweetness, peaches give savory pot pies a surprising touch. When combined with salty or spicy foods, its juiciness creates a pleasing balance.

Try this fruity surprise while making a pie with chicken or pork. It adds a refreshing taste that pleases the palette.

16. Canned Mushrooms

Canned Mushrooms
© indestructiblefood

Your pot pie gains a delicious, earthy depth from the addition of mushrooms. Their meaty texture provides a pleasant bite and is perfect for vegetarian alternatives.

Combine them with cheese or herbs for a tasty concoction. Canned mushrooms add an extra layer of decadence if you’re looking for comfort and richness.

17. Canned Jalapeños

Canned Jalapeños
© rickles.pickles

Jalapeños, with their fiery kick, add excitement to your pot pie. These sliced peppers contribute a vibrant heat that awakens the palate.

If you’re aiming for a spicy treat, incorporate them into your filling sparingly. They pair perfectly with creamy elements, creating a balanced yet bold dish.

18. Canned Apricots

Canned Apricots
© lakeview_fruit

Despite their sweetness, apricots may be a delicious garnish for savory recipes. Their tangy flavor creates contrast with salty items.

For a classy touch, consider pairing them with lamb or fowl if you’re feeling daring. The end product is a flavorful pot pie that piques interest with each mouthful.

19. Canned Tuna

Canned Tuna
© safecatchfoods

Tuna, a pantry staple, finds new life in pot pies. Its firm texture and mild flavor blend well with creamy sauces or vegetables. If seafood is your preference, tuna offers a quick and tasty solution.

Mix it with dill or capers for a refreshing twist that delights every seafood lover.

20. Canned Pimentos

Canned Pimentos
© Roxy’s Kitchen

Pimentos add a splash of color and mild sweetness to your pot pie. These small, red peppers enhance both appearance and taste, making your dish visually appealing.

If you’re seeking to impress, their vibrant hue does the trick. Combine them with cheese for a classic flavor pairing that never fails.

21. Canned Clams

Canned Clams
© carameredithwrites

Clams give your pot pie a beach taste with their saline aroma. These morsels are excellent with fillings that are creamy and chowder-like.

Canned clams offer a genuine flavor if you’re drawn to seaside food. For a filling, substantial meal that conjures sea breezes, pair them with bacon or potatoes.

22. Canned Bamboo Shoots

Canned Bamboo Shoots
© vmartcorpuschristi

The crisp texture of bamboo shoots makes them a welcome addition to pot pies. These thin slices go well with soy-based sauces or veggies and give an Asian flair.

When experimenting with fusion food, bamboo shoots offer a distinctive twist. They provide a wonderful crunch to every bite while balancing soft contents.

23. Canned Mandarin Oranges

Canned Mandarin Oranges
© ambrosiaqualityfoods

Even the heartiest pot pie may benefit from the sweet, zesty flavor that mandarin oranges add. Their juicy sections add a cool touch, particularly when combined with savory or spicy ingredients.

In case you’re craving a tart surprise, these oranges provide a fun twist to your dish.

24. Canned Beets

Canned Beets
© Walmart

Beets, renowned for their earthy sweetness, bring a vibrant color and flavor boost to pot pies. Their deep hue and unique taste create a dish that’s both visually and gastronomically appealing.

If you appreciate bold flavors, beets offer a remarkable addition. Pair them with goat cheese for a sophisticated touch.

25. Canned Pears

Canned Pears
© daysmarketprovo

Pears, often reserved for desserts, introduce a delicate sweetness to savory pot pies. Their tender texture melds beautifully with poultry or pork. If you’re crafting a fall-inspired dish, pears provide a harmonious balance of flavors.

Their subtle sweetness enhances without overpowering, making them a versatile choice.

26. Canned Asparagus

Canned Asparagus
© Amazon.com

Asparagus, with its distinct flavor, adds a touch of elegance to pot pies. These tender spears work well with creamy sauces or alongside seafood.

If spring flavors entice you, asparagus offers a crisp and fresh variant.

Its subtle bitterness complements rich fillings, making each bite intriguing and satisfying.

27. Canned Green Beans

Canned Green Beans
© babyledweanteam

Pot pies benefit from the freshness that green beans add with their vivid color and soft texture. They enhance tastes without overpowering them when combined with onions or garlic. Green beans are a simple and tasty vegetable addition if you’re looking for a classic.

Because of their adaptability, they may easily combine with a variety of components.

28. Canned Leeks

Canned Leeks
© goldfish

The mild onion-like taste that leeks add to pot pies is often overlooked. Their sweet flavor and delicate texture go well with cheesy or creamy components.

Leeks provide elegance if you’re looking for a slight fragrant boost. They add a sophisticated culinary touch and go well with chicken or shellfish.

29. Canned Ham

Canned Ham
© evan_angelastro

Ham makes a substantial addition to pot pies because of its savory flavor. The filling is infused with its smokey taste, making for a substantial and delicious entrée.

Cans of ham are a great way to satisfy your hunger for comfort food. For a timeless combination that uplifts the spirit, use it with cheese or veggies. It’s a classic option for every situation.

30. Canned Lychee

Canned Lychee
© takdirimpex

Canned lychee is an unexpected addition to pot pie, offering a sweet contrast to savory flavors. Its juicy, floral notes pair surprisingly well with earthy ingredients. Picture the sweet burst of lychee amid tender chicken and creamy sauce, creating a refreshing twist.

Consider pairing it with coconut milk or ginger for an Asian-inspired flair that transforms traditional pot pie.