I walked into this taste test expecting sugar overload and maybe a regret or two—but instead, I found myself strangely invested in marshmallow science. Peeps has rolled out a fresh batch of flavors this year, and they’re not playing it safe.
Some were surprisingly good, others were borderline questionable, but all of them had me thinking way too hard about squishy, sugar-coated chicks. If you’re filling baskets or just curious about which ones are worth grabbing, I’ve got thoughts.
1. Breyers Cookies & Cream
Imagine biting into a fluffy marshmallow kissed with Oreo’s iconic crumbles—I did, and it instantly transported me to the comfort of milk-dipped cookies from childhood. But this one’s got a twist: a surprise swirl of creamy vanilla ice cream richness that takes it to another level.
The way the soft marshmallow melts against the crunch of cookie bits? Pure sensory magic. Honestly, I didn’t expect to fall in love with a Peep, but here we are—this one’s pure, edible joy.
2. Tropical Punch
Pssst… want a taste of the tropics without leaving your backyard? I gave Tropical Punch Peeps a try, and while they didn’t quite sweep me off to paradise, they did offer a fun, fruity escape.
There’s a burst of pineapple, a touch of mango, and maybe a whisper of coconut—nothing too wild, but enough to feel like a candy cabana break. It’s not a flavor I’d chase down, but if you’re craving something summery and sweet, it’s a decent little vacation in marshmallow form.
3. Cinnamon Churro
Hold onto your hats, cinnamon lovers—because I just tried Churro Peeps, and wow, they’re a marshmallowy twist on fairground magic! That first bite really does channel the warm, sugary goodness of a classic churro, but with a pillowy-soft center that melts in your mouth.
The cinnamon-dusted exterior adds just the right bit of crunch, and honestly, it felt like a cozy flavor hug from childhood. I never imagined I’d enjoy them so much, yet here I am, halfway through the pack, grinning the whole time.
4. Chocolate Pudding
Calling all chocoholics—well, maybe not all. I gave the Chocolate Pudding Peeps a shot, hoping for rich, cocoa-drenched bliss, but they didn’t quite deliver. The marshmallow texture is classic, but the chocolate flavor felt more like a whisper than a full-on pudding punch.
It’s sweet, sure, but leans a little too artificial for my taste. I wanted a decadent treat, but instead, it felt like chocolate’s distant cousin trying to play dress-up. Not terrible—but not quite the indulgence I was craving.
5. Rice Krispies Treats
I spotted the Rice Krispies Treats Peeps and couldn’t resist giving them a try—because who doesn’t love a good dose of nostalgia? The flavor does bring back memories of sticky cereal bars from childhood, and the puffed rice adds a fun little crunch.
It’s definitely a clever idea, but the overall taste felt a bit muted for me—more sweet than standout. Not bad by any means, just not the kind of Peep I’d rush to stock up on. Still, if you’re in it for the throwback vibes, it’s a fun little bite down memory lane.
6. Delights Strawberry
Strawberry lovers, rejoice—I wasn’t sure what to expect from Delights Strawberry Peeps, but one bite totally won me over. The flavor is surprisingly vibrant, like juicy strawberries rolled in sugar, and it actually tastes more natural than I imagined.
Each bite feels like a little burst of spring, sweet and cheerful without being overwhelming. I grabbed them on a whim, but now they’re one of my favorite fruity finds—definitely a Peep I’d pick up again.