Skip to Content

20 Restaurant Menu Items You Should Ignore

20 Restaurant Menu Items You Should Ignore

Sharing is caring!

Not every dish on the menu is a winner. Some are overpriced, underwhelming, and downright tragic. Others? Let’s just say they’ve seen better days.

Maybe they’ve been sitting under a heat lamp for hours, drowning in sauce to hide their dryness, or made with ingredients that should’ve been retired yesterday.

Before you order, check this list. You’ll thank me later!

1. Lobster Mac and Cheese

Lobster Mac and Cheese sounds fancy, right? But that gourmet vibe often comes with a price tag that leaves you feeling scammed. Chances are, the lobster chunks are small and overcooked, making them rubbery rather than luxurious.

The cheese might be a bland blend instead of the rich, creamy sauce you dreamt of. And let’s be real, it’s probably not the freshest catch but something that’s been sitting in the kitchen for a while.

2. The Volcano Burger

The Volcano Burger promises an eruption of flavors, but what you really get is a culinary disaster. With toppings stacked sky-high, it’s an impossible mouthful that falls apart before you even take a bite.

The spicy sauce is often more about heat than flavor, drowning out the taste of the actual beef patty. You’ll find yourself needing a mountain of napkins just to survive the mess.

3. Frozen Seafood Platter

Ordering a seafood platter might seem like a luxury, but when it’s frozen, you’re in for disappointment. The promise of fresh and succulent seafood falls flat when you realize it’s been thawed from the depths of the freezer.

Rubbery textures and bland flavors replace the vibrant taste of fresh catch, a lackluster dining experience. Not to mention, it’s usually overpriced for what you actually get.

4. The Mega Nacho Tower

Sure, the Mega Nacho Tower looks Instagram-ready (although I am not that sure), but its charm ends there. The first few bites might be delicious, but soon you’re left with a mountainous mess of soggy chips.

Inconsistently spread toppings mean some bites are all cheese, while others are dry as a bone. Plus, the bottom layer is often a swamp of mush that’s been sitting too long.

5. Creamy Truffle Risotto

Truffle Risotto should be the epitome of elegance, but often it’s anything but. Too much cream and not enough truffle make it a heavy, one-note dish that loses its allure quickly.

The truffle, meant to be the star, gets lost amidst the overpowering richness and leaves you craving something more balanced. And at this price, it should be a masterpiece, not a letdown.

6. Overloaded Chili Cheese Fries

Chili Cheese Fries are supposed to be a guilty pleasure, but when overloaded, they’re just guilty. The fries become a soggy, greasy mess that’s hard to enjoy.

Too much chili and cheese overwhelms the dish. What you have left is a plate that’s more slop than snack. You’ll end up picking around the edges for a semi-crispy bite.

7. Giant Stuffed Pasta Shells

A hearty meal is promised with Giant Stuffed Pasta Shells, but they often deliver more pasta than filling. Overcooked shells become gummy, while the stuffing is sparse and bland.

Plus, the large size makes them awkward to eat, and you’re left battling with fork and knife to enjoy a bite. To mask the shortcomings, they usually drown it in sauce. Choose a pasta dish where quality, not quantity, shines.

8. Overly Creamy Alfredo

The allure of Alfredo is its creamy and smooth texture, but when overdone, it becomes a heavy, creamy nightmare. Swamped in sauce, the pasta loses its charm, becoming a gloopy, overwhelming dish.

With flavors that lean more towards cream than cheese, it’s a one-note meal that doesn’t excite the palate. You’ll find yourself halfway through, wishing for something lighter. I have a trick: to enjoy this classic without the overload, ask for sauce on the side.

9. The Quintuple Layer Cake

A Quintuple Layer Cake sounds like dessert heaven, but more often, it’s a sugar overload. With five layers of cake and frosting, it feels more like a chore than a treat.

The excessive sweetness masks the cake’s actual flavors, leaving you with a sugar rush rather than satisfaction. It’s a battle of determination to finish a slice. Go for a simpler dessert that highlights quality.

10. Shrimp Cocktail Surprise

Unfortunately this ‘Surprise’ is often more of a surprise in its mediocrity. What should be a fresh, zesty appetizer is instead bland and uninspired.

Shrimps might be small and lacking the expected firm texture, with cocktail sauce that barely adds a zing. It’s a dull start to any meal. If it’s seafood you’re after, check for freshness or pick an appetizer with a bit more flair.

11. Faux-Gourmet Flatbread

Flatbreads try to be the sophisticated cousin of pizza, but most of the time end up being a pretentious flop. Toppings can be uninspired and greasy, making it more of a letdown than a delight.

The thin crust, meant to be crispy, might arrive soggy, and the balance of flavors is often off. It’s not the gourmet experience you signed up for. Why not stick to a well-made pizza or a flatbread that’s crafted with care.

12. Oversized Brunch Pancakes

I don’t understand this obsession with size. These pancakes might seem like the ultimate treat, but they’re often more style than substance. Huge portions can lead to soggy, flavorless bites drowned in syrup.

The batter, meant to be fluffy and light is usually dense and uninspiring. You’re left with a sugar high and a sense of brunch regret. Why not order a smaller, thoughtfully made stack that delivers on taste.

13. Brownie Sundae Overload

The Brownie Sundae Overload tries to impress with abundance but ends up overwhelming. Too many toppings drown the brownie, turning it into a sugary, sticky mess.

The ice cream melts too quickly under the weight, and you’re left with a puddle of sweet chaos rather than a harmonious dessert. A well-balanced sundae will bring joy with every bite, not exhaustion.

14. Pre-Made Caesar Salad

The Pre-Made Caesar Salad is convenience disguised as freshness. Wilted lettuce and minimal dressing make for a sad, uninspiring salad option.

Croutons might be stale, and the Parmesan more dust than cheese. It’s a far cry from the crisp, zingy salad you hoped for. For a salad that satisfies, insist on something freshly tossed. Fresh ingredients make all the difference.

15. The Giant Pretzel

We return again to the food giants – The Giant Pretzel. Although it might catch your eye with its size, oftentimes it’s more tough and chewy than soft and delightful.

The outer crust might be too hard, leaving you chewing endlessly without getting much flavor. It’s a snack that promises a lot but delivers little satisfaction.

16. Mystery Meatloaf

Ah, the Mystery Meatloaf, a staple of mediocrity. It promises comfort but most of the time delivers a grey, flavorless slab of meat.

The texture can be questionable, and the seasoning might be non-existent, leaving you with a bite that’s more meh than mouthwatering. It’s a gamble not worth taking. Your dining experience deserves better than a mystery.

17. Undercooked Paella

Paella should be a celebration of flavors, but undercooked rice can ruin the party. Instead of a harmonious dish, you have crunchy bits that miss the mark.

And this is what oftentimes happens in the kitchen: the seafood gets overcooked in the attempt to fix the rice, leaving the dish unbalanced and unsatisfying. This isn’t as much about the dish as it is about who prepares it. Seek out places known for their expertise in paella.

18. Overdressed Cobb Salad

Looking for something fresh? The Cobb Salad is supposed to be a fresh, balanced meal, but when overdressed, it’s anything but. Drenched in dressing, the ingredients lose their individual flavors and turn into NOTHING.

Too much dressing turns what should be a healthy option into a calorie-laden regret. You’re left picking through wilted lettuce and lost flavors. Again, the trick is to ask for your dressing on the side to keep your salad crisp and enjoyable.

19. Dry Chicken Parmesan

Chicken Parmesan can be a delight, but when dry, it’s a disappointment. Overcooked chicken turns tough, and you’ve got yourself more work than pleasure.

Also, the sauce might be sparse, failing to provide the moisture and flavor that makes this dish wonderful. It’s an exercise in chewing without much reward. Seek out a place that prides itself on juicy, flavorful chicken dishes. Your taste buds will appreciate the attention to detail.