Jersey Mike’s might seem like just another sandwich stop, but there’s a lot more going on than fresh bread and deli meat. With a few insider tips, your next visit can turn into something seriously satisfying.
From their signature toppings to surprising customizations, knowing what’s what helps you order like a pro.
These 15 facts will make your sub experience even better.
1. The Meat Is Always Freshly Sliced
Each order starts with meat sliced right in front of you. This isn’t pre-cut stuff sitting in a bin all day.
That’s part of what makes the subs taste extra juicy and full of bold deli flavor from the very first bite.
2. “Mike’s Way” Is A Game-Changer
Asking for your sub “Mike’s Way” means adding onions, lettuce, tomatoes, oregano, salt, and that tangy vinegar-oil combo.
It gives every bite a fresh crunch and a zing of acidity that balances the richness of the meats and cheese perfectly.
3. You Can Ask For Extra Juice
Fans of bold flavors should know they can always ask for more vinegar and oil. It’s not on the board, but it’s allowed.
The extra splash soaks into the bread and adds even more flavor without overpowering the other ingredients.
4. They Offer Sub-In-A-Tub For Low-Carb Fans
Looking to skip the bread? Jersey Mike’s will toss your favorite sub fillings into a container like a deli-style salad.
It’s a smart option for keto eaters or anyone who wants something lighter without missing the signature toppings.
5. Secret Menu? It Exists
Jersey Mike’s has off-the-menu options known by regulars and online fans. Think creative combos or twists on classics.
These specials vary by location, but asking nicely might unlock something totally unexpected and delicious.
6. They Bake The Bread Fresh Daily
The sub rolls are made fresh every single day. That’s why they’re so soft inside and golden-crisp on the outside.
Good bread makes a big difference—and here, it’s treated with the same care as the meats and toppings.
7. Some Locations Deliver Through Apps
While not every shop offers delivery, many locations partner with apps like DoorDash and Uber Eats.
It’s worth checking your local options when you’re craving a Mike’s Way fix without leaving the house.
8. You Can Earn Rewards Through Their App
The Jersey Mike’s app tracks your visits and rewards you with points toward free food. It’s a simple system with tasty benefits.
Loyalty perks rack up fast, especially if you’re a regular, and some locations send out extra deals just for app users.
9. Cold Subs Are Their Specialty
Jersey Mike’s built its name on cold sandwiches, and those classic combos still shine the brightest.
From turkey and provolone to the signature Italian, cold subs bring out the best in fresh-sliced ingredients.
10. Toasting Isn’t The Default
Unlike some sandwich chains, Jersey Mike’s doesn’t toast unless you ask. The default is a soft, room-temp sub.
But if you want your bread warm or your cheese melty, just speak up and they’ll make it happen.
11. The Tuna Is Wild-Caught
Their tuna salad uses wild-caught tuna and a simple mix with mayo. No extras, no fillers, just clean flavor.
It’s one of the most popular cold options, and fans swear by its creamy texture and subtle sea-kissed taste.
12. You Can Order A Giant Sub For Parties
Feeding a group? The giant subs stretch over two feet long and make for an impressive party platter.
You can even mix and match meats and cheeses to create something that satisfies every kind of eater.
13. They’re Serious About Fundraising
Jersey Mike’s puts big effort into charity events, especially their Month of Giving campaign every March.
Buying a sandwich can often support local schools, hospitals, or food banks—so your lunch might help someone else, too.
14. Not Every Location Is The Same
Each shop is a little different, especially when it comes to staff, atmosphere, and even menu quirks.
While the basics stay consistent, a great team or a locally run store can elevate the whole experience.
15. Custom Orders Are Totally Welcome
Want extra pickles or no tomato? They’re happy to build your sub exactly the way you like it.
Whether you’re a minimalist or load-it-all type, customization is part of what makes every visit feel personal.