Ever wondered which Italian sub rises above the rest? Get ready to embark on a flavorful journey through layers of savory meats, melted cheeses, and zesty condiments! From crispy toasted rolls to perfectly seasoned fillings, every bite reminds us why we’re obsessed with these iconic sandwiches.
Whether you crave bold flavors, delightful textures, or hearty satisfaction, you’ve found your haven. But which one truly stands out? Let’s rank the top Italian subs from popular sandwich chains and find out which one reigns supreme!
1. Potbelly’s Italian
Craving a sub that hits all the right notes? Potbelly’s Italian brings the perfect blend of capicola, mortadella, and pepperoni, creating a flavor explosion that’s both bold and comforting.
Provolone cheese melts beautifully into the mix, adding a velvety richness that perfectly complements the savory meats. Topped with fresh lettuce and tomato, it strikes the perfect balance between light and satisfying.
When you ask, “What should an Italian sub taste like?” Potbelly’s Italian answers with flair and flavor!
2. Jersey Mike’s Original Italian
Jersey Mike’s Original Italian is packed with a perfect mix of deli meats and provolone, offering a taste that’s as authentic as it gets.
The layers of flavorful meats, combined with fresh veggies, create a delightful crunch in every bite. It’s a feast for both the taste buds and the senses.
Wherever you’re searching for your next great sub, Jersey Mike’s guarantees a taste worth savoring.
3. Subway’s Italian B.M.T.
The Italian B.M.T. is a fan favorite for many, making it a go-to choice for those who crave a classic Italian sub experience.. Packed with Genoa salami, spicy pepperoni, and Black Forest ham, each bite bursts with flavor. The blend of meats creates a savory experience that’s hard to beat.
Layered with crisp lettuce, ripe tomatoes, onions, and green peppers, it’s as fresh as it is delicious. Topped with your choice of sauces, the sub transforms into a personal masterpiece.
If crafting the perfect sandwich is your thing, the B.M.T. offers unlimited possibilities.
4. Jimmy John’s Italian Night Club
At Jimmy John’s, the Italian Night Club is a star player. Filled with Genoa salami, Italian capicola, and smoked ham, it delivers a hearty punch.
The savory meats, paired with crispy lettuce and fresh tomatoes, create a perfect harmony of flavors. Add mayonnaise, and you have an indulgent treat. If sandwiches are your passion, the Italian Night Club is an undeniable choice.
5. Quiznos Classic Italian
Quiznos offers the Classic Italian, loaded with pepperoni, salami, and ham, all perfectly toasted. The warmth of the sandwich enhances its rich flavors.
Melted mozzarella adds a creamy touch, while the fresh vegetables contribute a refreshing bite. Though options are many, the toasted perfection of Quiznos’ Classic Italian makes it a top contender.
6. Penn Station’s Italian
Looking for a sandwich that’s bursting with flavor? Penn Station’s Italian sandwich is a bold combination of smoked ham, capicola, and pepperoni, creating a mouthwatering explosion in every bite.
When you add provolone cheese, it turns into a gooey, melty delight. Banana peppers and onions add a spicy kick, while a drizzle of oil brings it all together. No matter how many choices you have, Penn Station’s Italian is always a reliable, flavorful pick!
7. Lenny’s Original Italian
Lenny’s Original Italian is a masterpiece of ham, prosciutto, and capicola. These meats come together in an exquisite harmony.
Provolone cheese adds a creamy dimension, while the lettuce and tomato provide a refreshing backdrop. Onion rounds out the flavor profile. If you’re in search of a balanced and flavorful sub, Lenny’s Original Italian more than satisfies.
8. Cousins Subs’ Italian Special
Cousins Subs’ Italian Special boasts Genoa salami and Italian ham, promising a savory experience. The combination is enhanced with provolone cheese’s creaminess.
The lettuce and onion offer a delightful crunch and freshness, while a touch of oregano brings a zesty finish to round out the flavors. Despite its solid foundation, Cousins’ sub doesn’t quite push the boundaries of creativity.
It’s a dependable classic, but it doesn’t offer the boldness or excitement that other Italian subs bring to the table.
9. Hungry Howie’s Italian Sub
Bite into Hungry Howie’s Italian Sub and experience a symphony of pepperoni and ham, each layer bursting with bold, savory flavor. The rich, melted mozzarella cheese seamlessly melts into the mix, elevating the taste to a whole new level.
Packed with flavor, Hungry Howie’s Italian Sub offers a perfect blend of lettuce and tomato for a crunchy freshness, with a tangy drizzle of Italian dressing tying it all together.
While Hungry Howie’s Italian Sub has its moments, it doesn’t quite hit the mark for an irresistible experience.
10. Togo’s Italian
Togo’s Italian is a delightful blend of dry salami, capicola, and mortadella. The meats create a robust, flavorful profile.
Provolone cheese melds seamlessly, adding richness. With crisp lettuce and tomato, you get the perfect crunch, while the zesty vinaigrette pulls everything together, adding just the right tang to balance the richness. It’s a good choice, but not one that leaves you craving more.
11. DiBella’s Old Fashioned
DiBella’s Old Fashioned sub combines salami, capicola, and ham with provolone cheese for a savory, slightly spicy bite. Fresh lettuce, tomatoes, and onions add crunch, while the freshly baked bread provides a satisfying texture.
Though it’s a solid option, the flavors feel a bit predictable compared to other Italian subs. Topped with oil and vinegar, it delivers classic deli taste, but it may not stand out for those craving something more unique.
12. Capriotti’s Italian Sub
Capriotti’s Italian Sub brings a hearty mix of Genoa salami, capicola, and prosciuttini, delivering rich, savory bites with every mouthful. The creamy provolone cheese melts into the meats, while the fresh veggies add a nice crunch to balance out the richness.
It might seem as flavorful and satisfying, Capriotti’s Italian Sub doesn’t quite rise to the top of the list. While it delivers on heartiness and taste, it lacks the bold wow factor or unique twist that sets some of the best Italian subs apart. Still, it’s a solid and delicious choice if you’re craving a traditional, hearty sandwich!
13. Tony’s Gourmet Italian Sub
Tony’s Gourmet Italian Sub blends salami, capicola, and provolone cheese into a classic combo that delivers solid, reliable flavor. The lettuce and tomatoes bring freshness, while oregano and olive oil elevate the taste.
Though it’s enjoyable, it falls short of being extraordinary. It’s a safe, familiar option but lacks the standout elements or bold twists that make other Italian subs truly unforgettable.
14. Sub Station II’s Italian Super Sub
Sub Station II’s Italian Super Sub delivers a straightforward mix of traditional meats and cheeses, creating a solid but unremarkable experience. The Genoa salami, capicola, and smoked ham combine well, but the flavor doesn’t pack the punch that other Italian subs do.
While the provolone cheese adds richness and the veggies bring a crisp contrast, the sub feels a bit one-dimensional compared to more exciting and bold options. It’s reliable, but lacks the unique twist or standout ingredients that would make it rise above the rest.