I willingly subjected myself to a week-long sugar storm, risking cavities and potential diabetes just to bring you the ULTIMATE Crumbl Cookie ranking. From the downright disappointing to the melt-in-your-mouth masterpieces, I’ve judged them all.
So, grab a glass of milk (you’ll need it), and prepare for a wild ride through the sugary landscape that is Crumbl Cookies.
Consider me your carb-fueled Sherpa. You’re welcome. Now, let’s get to the cookies!
1. Chocolate Chip
Starting with a timeless classic, the Chocolate Chip cookie offers a gooey center filled with chunks of rich chocolate.
The edges are perfectly golden, providing a satisfying crunch that contrasts with the soft interior. This cookie stands as a testament to the beauty of simplicity in baking.
2. Peanut Butter
For peanut butter lovers, this cookie delivers a rich, nutty flavor that’s hard to resist. Each bite reveals a smooth, creamy texture.
It’s contrasted by a slightly crisp exterior. The balance of sweet and savory elements makes it an irresistible treat for those craving a peanut-filled delight.
3. Snickerdoodle
A nostalgic nod to childhood, the Snickerdoodle cookie is rolled in cinnamon sugar, providing a sweet and spicy kick.
Its soft texture and warm flavors evoke memories of cozy kitchens and happy moments. It’s balanced and lightly tangy. This cookie captures the essence of comfort food.
4. Oatmeal Raisin
Packed with juicy raisins and a subtle hint of cinnamon, the Oatmeal Raisin cookie is a comforting classic.
Each chewy bite is filled with warmth and nostalgia, making it a favorite choice for those who appreciate a hearty, wholesome treat. This cookie embodies a timeless appeal.
5. Lemon Poppy Seed
A refreshing burst of citrus comes alive in the Lemon Poppy Seed cookie. The zesty glaze enhances its bright flavors, while the poppy seeds add a delightful crunch.
This cookie offers a perfect balance of tart and sweet. An invigorating choice for those seeking something light.
6. Double Chocolate
For those who can’t get enough chocolate, the Double Chocolate cookie is a dream come true. Its deep, fudgy base is packed with chocolate chunks.
Luscious experience in every bite. This indulgent treat is good for satisfying intense chocolate cravings.
7. Coconut Lime
Transport your taste buds to a tropical paradise with the Coconut Lime cookie. The harmonious blend of coconut and lime delivers a refreshing, exotic flavor profile.
Its light texture and zesty finish make it a delightful escape from the ordinary. A unique twist on conventional cookie flavors.
8. Raspberry Cheesecake
Decadence meets fruitiness in the Raspberry Cheesecake cookie. Its creamy center is swirled with tangy raspberry jam, offering a sophisticated balance of flavors.
The graham cracker crumbs add a crunch. This cookie is a must-try for cheesecake and fruit lovers alike.
9. Salted Caramel
Indulgence reaches new heights with the Salted Caramel cookie. Its gooey center is drizzled with rich caramel and finished with a sprinkle of sea salt.
The contrasting flavors create a tantalizing experience that keeps you coming back for more. This cookie is a treat for those who love sweet and salty combinations.
10. Pumpkin Spice
As autumn arrives, the Pumpkin Spice cookie captures the essence of the season. Its warm, spiced flavors evoke feelings of cozy gatherings and crisp fall days.
It’s topped with a sprinkle of cinnamon and nutmeg. A comforting embrace of seasonal goodness.
11. Mint Chocolate
Cool mint meets rich chocolate in the Mint Chocolate cookie. The dark chocolate base is complemented by mint chips.
Refreshing and decadent bite. Its invigorating aroma and balanced flavors make it a popular choice for those seeking a minty twist on a classic treat.
12. Birthday Cake
Celebrate any occasion with the Birthday Cake cookie. Its soft vanilla base is adorned with colorful sprinkles.
It brings the joy of a birthday party to your taste buds. A subtle hint of almond flavor adds a touch of elegance.
13. S’mores
Bring the campfire experience to your kitchen with the S’mores cookie. Its graham cracker base pairs perfectly with a gooey marshmallow center, reminiscent of a classic s’mores treat.
The chocolate drizzle adds an extra layer of indulgence. A favorite for outdoor enthusiasts and sweet lovers.
14. Cinnamon Roll
Embrace the comforting flavors of a classic breakfast treat with the Cinnamon Roll cookie. Swirls of cinnamon are perfectly balanced by a smooth cream cheese glaze.
It offers a deliciously sweet and spicy experience. Its inviting aroma and soft texture make it a good choice for any time of day.
15. Orange Creamsicle
Transport yourself to a summer day with the Orange Creamsicle cookie. Its orange hue and creamy vanilla center bring the beloved popsicle flavor to life.
The zesty citrus notes add a refreshing twist. It’s a true escape from the ordinary cookie experience.
16. Peanut Butter Nutella
Blend decadence and nuttiness with the Peanut Butter Nutella cookie. The rich peanut butter base is swirled with creamy Nutella.
A symphony of flavors. Crunchy peanut toppings add texture and depth, making each bite a luxurious experience.
17. Strawberry Shortcake
Capture the essence of summer with the Strawberry Shortcake cookie. Its creamy center is topped with fresh strawberries and a dollop of whipped cream.
it’s light and refreshing treat. This cookie is a good choice for those who love fruity flavors and summer-inspired desserts.
18. Cookies And Cream
Indulge in the classic combination of cookies and cream with this delightful treat. Chunks of chocolate sandwich cookies are embedded in a creamy base.
It has a delightful texture and rich flavor. This cookie is a must-try for those who love the timeless pairing of chocolate and cream.
19. Almond Joy
Inspired by the beloved candy bar, the Almond Joy cookie features a chewy coconut base topped with whole almonds.
And of course, a drizzle of chocolate. The combination of nutty and sweet flavors transports you to a tropical paradise.
20. Blueberry Muffin
Start your day with the Blueberry Muffin cookie. It’s inspired by the classic breakfast treat.
Fresh blueberries are baked into a soft, crumbly base, offering a burst of fruity flavor in every bite. A sprinkle of sugar adds a touch of sweetness.
21. Molten Lava
Experience the ultimate chocolate indulgence with the Molten Lava cookie. Its gooey chocolate center oozes with every bite, creating a decadent experience for chocolate enthusiasts.
The dark, rich flavors make it a standout choice. If you’re seeking an intense chocolate fix, this is it!
22. Banana Bread
Bring the comfort of homemade banana bread to your taste buds with this cookie. You’ll love the inviting flavor.
It’s enhanced by a subtle hint of cinnamon. This cookie is perfect for those who appreciate the comforting essence of banana-based treats.
23. Funfetti
Celebrate joy and happiness with the Funfetti cookie. Its soft vanilla base is dotted with rainbow sprinkles.
It’s creating a playful and colorful appearance. Bake them for birthdays or any occasion that calls for a little extra fun and sweetness.
24. Toffee Nut
Delight in the rich flavors of toffee and nuts with this scrumptious cookie. Its buttery base is studded with crunchy toffee bits and roasted nuts.
A satisfying blend of textures and flavors. This cookie is for those who enjoy a sweet and nutty treat.
25. Cherry Garcia
Inspired by the iconic ice cream flavor, the Cherry Garcia cookie features chunks of cherries and dark chocolate. This sweet and fruity delight captures the essence of indulgence.
If you ask me, this one is a must-try. Especially for those who appreciate the combination of fruit and chocolate.
26. Ginger Snap
Embrace the spicy warmth of a classic Ginger Snap cookie. Its golden brown exterior and spicy kick are complemented by a sweet sugar dusting.
It’s a delightful contrast in flavors. Why not add a bit of spice in your sweet treats?
27. Espresso Chip
Wake up your senses with the bold flavors of the Espresso Chip cookie. Its coffee-infused base is dotted with chocolate chips.
A caffeine kick makes is perfect for breakfast. You’ll start your day right! It’s a favorite beverage in cookie form.
28. Red Velvet
Indulge in the rich flavors of the Red Velvet cookie. Its deep red hue is topped with a luscious cream cheese frosting and chocolate chips.
A luxurious experience you need today. This cookie is a favorite for those who enjoy the classic combination of red velvet and cream cheese.
29. Maple Bacon
Experience the unique combination of sweet and savory with the Maple Bacon cookie. Its maple-infused base is topped with crispy bacon bits.
Who can say no to this contrast of flavors. I know I can’t! I appreciate a good unconventional treat.
30. White Chocolate Macadamia Nut
Indulge in the creamy and nutty flavors of the White Chocolate Macadamia Nut cookie. Its creamy white chocolate chunks and crunchy macadamia nuts create a delightful texture and taste.
This cookie is a classic choice for those who enjoy the rich combination of white chocolate and nuts.
31. Apple Pie
Capture the essence of a classic dessert with the Apple Pie cookie. Its crumbly base is filled with cinnamon-spiced apples.
Who knew apples can be this fun and tasty. It’s offering a warm and comforting flavor. A hint of buttery crust adds to the authentic taste.
32. Limeade
Refresh your palate with the tangy flavors of the Limeade cookie. Its lime base is topped with a sweet lime glaze and lime zest.
This zesty and invigorating experience is something you can bake for any occasion. It’s a citrusy twist on traditional sweets.
33. Brownie Batter
Indulge in the decadent flavors of the Brownie Batter cookie. Its fudgy texture and dark chocolate chips create a rich and satisfying experience.
The gooey center adds an extra layer of indulgence. This cookie is a must-try for chocolate lovers.
34. Lemonade
Experience the refreshing taste of summer with the Lemonade cookie. Its bright lemon flavor is enhanced by a tangy lemon glaze and a sprinkle of sugar.
Invigorating treat that’s easy to make. It gives a citrusy twist on classic sweets.
35. Rocky Road
You can have the classic flavors of Rocky Road with this tasty cookie. Its chocolate base is topped with toasted marshmallows and crunchy almonds.
It’s a satisfying blend of textures and tastes. A timeless combination of chocolate, nuts, and marshmallows is my go-to!
36. Savory Bacon & Pineapple Fusion
Imagine the boldness of a tropical island meeting a rustic breakfast plate in cookie form. It combines crispy bacon bits with juicy pineapple chunks, drizzled with sweet maple glaze.
This unusual mix creates a beautiful harmony of sweet, salty, and savory. The first bite surprises with its contrasting textures.
37. Mango Tango
Bursting with tropical flavor, this cookie is a fresh take on fruity desserts. The mango-infused dough is soft and flavorful, topped with a swirl of mango frosting.
A tropical getaway in cookie form. Pair it with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
38. Toasted Marshmallow
Evoking memories of campfires and s’mores, this cookie features a perfectly toasted marshmallow atop a soft cookie base.
A hint of chocolate and graham cracker crumbs complete the nostalgic treat. It’s an ideal companion for a cozy night in.
39. Cotton Candy Carnival
Step right up for the Cotton Candy Carnival cookie! This treat transports you to a bustling fairground with its colors and sugary aroma.
Each bite melts in your mouth, reminiscent of fluffy cotton candy spun fresh at the fair. The playful pastel swirls hint at the sweet surprises within.