We Discovered The 15 Healthiest Mayonnaise Brands Of 2025
Mayonnaise doesn’t have to be a guilty pleasure. Some brands now offer rich, creamy flavor without the extra junk.
Whether you want fewer calories, better oils, or no eggs at all, there’s a smarter mayo for your fridge. These 15 picks balance taste with nutrition—perfect for spreads, dips, and dressings.
1. Sir Kensington’s Avocado Oil Mayonnaise
Made with avocado oil and cage-free eggs, this mayo feels luxuriously thick. It skips the sugar and keeps the ingredients clean.
The flavor is light and slightly tangy, ideal for BLTs or homemade aioli. Its smooth consistency spreads like a dream on sandwiches.
2. Chosen Foods Classic Avocado Mayo
This mayo keeps it simple with avocado oil, organic eggs, and vinegar. There’s no canola, soy, or added sugar inside.
Its texture is silky and the taste leans savory, not sweet. It holds up beautifully in coleslaw and potato salad.
3. Primal Kitchen Real Mayonnaise
This keto-friendly favorite uses organic eggs and avocado oil to deliver rich flavor with zero added sugar. It’s also paleo-approved.
Whipped to a thick, firm texture, it doesn’t separate in heat. It’s perfect for chicken salad or deviled eggs with a clean twist.
4. JUST Mayo (Egg-Free)
Made from pea protein instead of eggs, this vegan mayo is smooth, spreadable, and surprisingly rich. There’s no cholesterol, but full flavor.
It works wonders in wraps and dressings. A great pick for anyone with allergies or looking to cut back on animal products.
5. BetterBody Foods Avocado Oil Mayo
This light and creamy spread features non-GMO avocado oil and cage-free eggs. It ditches soy, dairy, and refined sugar.
It’s got a mellow taste and soft, whipped texture. Use it in tuna salad or on grilled sandwiches for a cleaner bite.
6. Whole Foods 365 Organic Mayonnaise
Simple and affordable, this mayo uses organic ingredients and sunflower oil for a neutral, gentle flavor. No high-fructose corn syrup here.
Its mild taste won’t overpower other flavors. Ideal for everyday sandwiches, dressings, and dips without added fuss.
7. Blue Plate Light Mayonnaise With Olive Oil
This lighter version cuts fat and calories while keeping the creamy body Blue Plate fans expect. Olive oil takes the lead here.
It’s a bit tangier than regular mayo, which adds brightness to pasta salads. A solid balance of flavor and function.
8. Hellmann’s Organic Mayonnaise
Made with organic eggs and expeller-pressed oils, this mayo offers the familiar Hellmann’s taste with better sourcing. It’s non-GMO and rich.
The texture is thick, the flavor classic, and the ingredients reassuring. It’s the upgrade fans of the original will love.
9. Good & Gather Avocado Oil Mayo
Target’s house brand uses avocado oil and cage-free eggs in this creamy, clean-tasting spread. It’s free from artificial flavors.
The flavor is mild but smooth, with just enough tang. Great for mixing into egg salad or spooning onto burgers.
10. Vegenaise Original
This vegan classic is made with soy protein and non-GMO oils. Creamy and thick, it rivals traditional mayo in both flavor and feel.
It’s a hit for plant-based eaters and holds up well in slaws or sandwiches. No eggs, but plenty of richness.
11. Follow Your Heart Soy-Free Vegenaise
This soy-free version swaps in grape seed oil and still delivers a smooth, neutral flavor. It’s dairy-free, egg-free, and gluten-free.
It doesn’t curdle or break under heat. Use it in warm dips or creamy vegan sauces without worry.
12. Spectrum Organic Mayonnaise
Crafted with organic cage-free eggs and soybean oil, this mayo offers a traditional taste with certified organic quality. It’s thick and glossy.
The flavor is balanced and classic. A smart pantry staple for mayo purists who want better ingredients.
13. Tessemae’s Organic Mayonnaise
Tessemae’s uses sunflower oil and organic vinegar for a light, tart bite. It’s paleo, Whole30-approved, and made with simple ingredients.
Its clean profile makes it ideal for health-conscious kitchens. It blends smoothly into sauces and works well in marinades.
14. Hellmann’s Carefully Crafted Vegan Dressing
Egg-free but still rich, this version mirrors Hellmann’s signature taste with a plant-based twist. The base uses modified food starch for texture.
It spreads well and has a bold tang. Great on veggie sandwiches or mixed into creamy dressings without the eggs.
15. Trader Joe’s Organic Mayonnaise
This mayo uses organic soybean oil and eggs for a smooth, mild flavor that doesn’t overwhelm. It’s slightly sweet and well-balanced.
The texture is thick without being stiff. A reliable pick for everyday use in everything from burgers to baked dips.
