Who doesn’t love Girl Scout cookie season?
Those iconic boxes bring joy to millions each year, with flavors that spark childhood memories and fierce debates about which ones reign supreme.
We embarked on the ultimate taste test, sampling every single variety to settle the age-old question: which Girl Scout cookie truly deserves the crown?
1. Thin Mints: The Undisputed Champion
Crisp chocolate wafers coated in minty chocolate goodness? Yes, please! The refreshing coolness paired with rich chocolate creates an irresistible combination that keeps fans coming back year after year.
What makes these little wonders truly special is their versatility. Straight from the box? Delicious. Frozen? Even better! No wonder they’re consistently the top-selling Girl Scout cookie nationwide.
2. Samoas/Caramel deLites: Tropical Paradise
Have you ever bitten into something so perfect you momentarily forgot your troubles? That’s the Samoa experience! Ring-shaped cookies draped in caramel, sprinkled with toasted coconut, and striped with chocolate.
Though divisive (coconut haters need not apply), these complex treats offer an intricate flavor journey. Sweet, chewy caramel meets crunchy cookie while coconut adds tropical flair.
3. Tagalongs/Peanut Butter Patties: Nutty Bliss
Holy peanut butter heaven! These circular shortbread cookies layered with creamy peanut butter and encased in chocolate create an explosion of flavor that rivals any candy bar on the market.
Unlike other peanut butter treats, Tagalongs nail the perfect ratio of cookie-to-peanut butter-to-chocolate. The crisp cookie base provides structure while the smooth peanut butter center melts gloriously with each bite.
4. Do-Si-Dos/Peanut Butter Sandwich: Nostalgic Comfort
Remember those childhood peanut butter sandwiches? Do-si-dos capture that nostalgic essence but elevate it to cookie perfection! Crunchy oatmeal cookies embrace creamy peanut butter filling in a delightful sandwich format.
Where these beauties truly shine is in their textural contrast. The slightly gritty oatmeal exterior gives way to smooth, rich peanut butter that coats your mouth with each bite. Pair them with milk for an unbeatable combo!
5. Trefoils/Shortbread: Simple Sophistication
Sometimes less truly is more! These delicate shortbread cookies shaped like the Girl Scout trefoil emblem deliver buttery perfection without overwhelming your taste buds.
Unlike their flashier cookie cousins, Trefoils don’t need fancy toppings or fillings to impress. Their simple, buttery flavor makes them ideal for dunking in tea or coffee. Ever tried them as a cheesecake crust? Absolute game-changer!
6. Lemon-Ups: Zesty Surprise
These bright lemon-flavored cookies deliver a citrusy punch that wakes up your taste buds like nothing else in the Girl Scout lineup. Each cookie features an inspiring message baked right into the crisp surface.
What truly sets Lemon-Ups apart is their balanced sweetness and tartness. Unlike some lemon treats that overwhelm with artificial flavor, these cookies capture genuine citrus essence. The crisp texture complements the zingy taste perfectly.
7. Adventurefuls: Brownie-Cookie Hybrid
Chocolate lovers rejoice! These newcomers feature a brownie-inspired base with caramel-flavored crème and a hint of sea salt. The indulgent combination delivers a sophisticated flavor profile that appeals to grown-up palates.
Adventurefuls succeed where many cookies fail – balancing sweetness with complexity. The subtle sea salt elevates the caramel notes while the chocolate base provides rich depth. They’re like the fancy chocolate shop of Girl Scout cookies!
8. Girl Scout S’mores: Campfire In A Cookie
Could anything capture campfire magic better? These graham sandwich cookies filled with chocolate and marshmallow-flavored cream brilliantly translate the classic outdoor treat into portable form.
While they can’t replicate the experience of roasting marshmallows under starry skies, these cookies deliver impressive s’mores flavor without the sticky fingers. The graham cookies provide that distinctive honey-cinnamon base that makes s’mores so beloved.
9. Toffee-tastic: Gluten-Free Goodness
Huzzah for inclusivity! These buttery cookies studded with golden toffee bits prove that gluten-free doesn’t mean flavor-free. Their rich, butterscotch-adjacent taste profile offers something unique in the Girl Scout cookie universe.
What’s particularly impressive about Toffee-tastic cookies is their texture – crunchy yet slightly tender, avoiding the grittiness that plagues many gluten-free options. The toffee bits add delightful caramelized sweetness and satisfying chew.
10. Caramel Chocolate Chip: Underdog Contender
Move over, famous chocolate chip brands! These gluten-free wonders pack rich caramel notes and semi-sweet chocolate chips into a surprisingly satisfying package. Each bite delivers a chewy texture that keeps you coming back for more.
Though relatively new to the Girl Scout lineup, these cookies deserve recognition for solving the gluten-free texture challenge so admirably. The caramel undertones elevate them beyond standard chocolate chip fare, creating a unique flavor signature.
11. Lemonades: Sunshine Circles
Ah, the underrated gems of the lemon cookie world! These shortbread rounds topped with tangy lemon icing deliver brightness in cookie form. The contrast between buttery base and zingy topping creates perfect harmony.
Unlike their cousin Lemon-Ups, Lemonades offer a more subtle citrus experience. The creamy shortbread provides the perfect canvas for the lemon icing to shine. Wondering what to pair them with? Try a cup of Earl Grey tea for an exceptional flavor combination!
12. Toast-Yay!: French Toast Flop
Despite the cute toast-shaped design and promising maple flavor concept, these cookies miss the mark. The cinnamon-sugar notes fall flat, and the texture leans toward dry rather than delightful.
Perhaps the biggest disappointment is how these cookies fail to capture authentic French toast flavor. The maple icing lacks depth, and the cookie base doesn’t evoke that eggy, custardy quality that makes real French toast so crave-worthy. Sorry, Toast-Yay!, you’re at the bottom of our list.