15 Iconic Florida Key Lime Pies You Have To Try
Florida sunshine tastes like citrus, and no dessert proves it better than key lime pie. Born in the Keys, this pie balances tart lime juice with velvety filling, creating a flavor that lingers like a beach sunset.
Every bakery and café has its own spin, from pillowy meringue peaks to decadent whipped cream swirls. Some keep it classic, others add flair, but each one captures the state’s most famous fruit in its purest form.
Whether you’re road-tripping through coastal towns or ducking into Miami cafés, these are the key lime pies worth every bite.
1. Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe (Key West)
Few places embody key lime culture like Kermit’s. The shop is packed with pies, candies, and even sauces infused with the citrusy star. Their pie strikes a balance between tang and cream, with a crust that crumbles just enough.
Tourists and locals line up for whole pies, slices, or even frozen chocolate-dipped wedges. It’s the kind of stop that defines a Key West visit.
2. Blue Heaven (Key West)
At Blue Heaven, the pie arrives crowned with a mountain of meringue that practically touches the ceiling. The filling leans tart, delivering a citrus punch against the sweetness of the topping. The crust is flaky and buttery, holding everything together in harmony.
It’s served in a funky courtyard with roosters wandering around, adding to the playful island atmosphere. This pie is a performance as much as a dessert.
3. Pepe’s Café (Key West)
Florida’s oldest eatery offers a pie that reflects its timeless charm. The filling is rich and custardy, with a deeper yellow hue from egg yolks. A simple graham cracker crust gives it the rustic edge that fits the café’s century-old style.
Pepe’s pie doesn’t chase trends, it leans into tradition. For many visitors, that first bite feels like a history lesson in dessert form.
4. Mattheessen’s Homemade Ice Cream (Key West)
Known for ice cream and oversized cookies, Mattheessen’s also delivers a pie that stands tall and generous. The filling is creamy, smooth, and decidedly sweet, appealing to those who prefer a softer tartness.
With its Key West location, the atmosphere matches the indulgence. A slice here feels like a vacation within a vacation.
5. The Green Turtle Inn (Islamorada)
Once a 1940s roadside stop, the Green Turtle remains a Keys landmark. Their pie layers a firm lime base under a cloud of whipped cream. The tartness is bold, cutting through sweetness with perfect balance.
Locals swear by its consistency, and travelers often return year after year. It’s a pie that feels like home, even to strangers.
6. Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen (Key Largo)
This quirky roadside café is covered in license plates, but the menu stars key lime pie. Their version is bold, tangy, and unapologetically lime-forward. The graham crust holds steady, and whipped cream is the favored topping.
With decades of history, Mrs. Mac’s pie has become a road trip legend. Ask anyone driving through Key Largo, it’s a mandatory stop.
7. Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar (Islamorada)
Lorelei pairs its pie with stunning sunset views over the water. The filling is silky and rich, contrasted with fresh whipped cream and a crumbly crust. Every bite feels indulgent, yet refreshing.
The experience of eating it outside by the marina is half the charm. Dessert here becomes an evening ritual.
8. Joe’s Stone Crab (Miami Beach)
Joe’s Stone Crab is synonymous with Miami Beach culinary excellence, and their key lime pie is no exception. This sophisticated dessert is served on elegant dinnerware, reflecting the restaurant’s refined ambiance. The pie’s smooth, tangy filling is expertly balanced with a sweet graham crust, making it a perfect finale to any meal. Known for its top-notch seafood, Joe’s also excels in delivering a key lime pie that captures the essence of Miami’s vibrant dining scene. Each slice is a tribute to the art of dessert making.
9. Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop (Miami)
This bakery makes pies that are bold and over-the-top. The key lime version is no exception, featuring a thick, custardy filling and rich graham crust. Whipped cream is piped generously, creating a decadent finish.
Fireman Derek’s has become a local favorite for creative desserts, but the key lime pie stays true to tradition. It’s comfort food done with flair.
10. Icebox Café (Miami)
Icebox Café is known for its innovative desserts, and their mini key lime pies are a testament to culinary creativity. Each pie is a compact delight, featuring a rich topping that enhances the creamy lime filling. Served in a modern, chic setting, these pies are perfect for those looking to indulge in a sophisticated treat. The café’s contemporary vibe complements the pie’s elegance, making it a popular destination for dessert lovers. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Icebox Café offers a taste of Miami’s dynamic dessert scene.
11. Yoder’s Restaurant & Amish Village (Sarasota)
Amish tradition meets Florida citrus in Yoder’s pie. The filling is bright and creamy, sitting atop a thick graham crust. It’s topped with whipped cream swirls, giving a rustic but comforting presentation.
Generous slices make it a family-style treat. For many visitors, it’s proof that key lime pie belongs outside the Keys too.
12. The Bubble Room (Captiva Island)
Famous for its whimsical décor and colorful cakes, the Bubble Room adds flair to key lime pie. Their version leans sweet and creamy, paired with playful presentation. The crust is golden and flaky, balancing the citrusy bite.
Eating dessert here feels like stepping into a fantasy. The pie may be classic, but the setting makes it unforgettable.
13. Old Key Lime House (Lantana)
Dating back to 1889, this spot claims to be Florida’s oldest waterfront restaurant. Their pie reflects that heritage with a firm lime filling and simple whipped topping. It’s no-frills but deeply satisfying.
The view over the Intracoastal adds an extra layer of flavor. History, scenery, and dessert combine into one memorable slice.
14. Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory (Key Largo)
This shop specializes in one thing and does it exceptionally well. Their pie is extra creamy, with a tangy bite that lingers. Chocolate-dipped frozen slices have also become a signature.
Tourists pack the shop daily, but locals defend it as one of the best. A visit here is a rite of passage for pie lovers.
15. Publix Super Market Bakery (Statewide)
No Florida dessert list feels complete without mentioning Publix. The supermarket chain has perfected a pie that’s both affordable and reliable. The filling is sweet but balanced, with a graham crust that never disappoints.
For many Floridians, this is the pie brought to family gatherings and cookouts. Publix proves sometimes the most ordinary choice is the most beloved.
