Fish sandwiches at fast food chains—some are a delicious catch, and others, well… not so much. We’ve gone deep into the sea of fast food to rank 23 fish sandwiches, from the crispy, golden ones that will have you hooked to the soggy disappointments that leave you regretting your order.
Whether you’re a seafood lover or just looking to mix up your fast food routine, we’ve got the ultimate guide to what’s worth trying and what’s better left untouched. Let’s dive in!
1. McDonald’s Filet-O-Fish
If you’ve ever craved a classic, McDonald’s Filet-O-Fish stands as an iconic choice. This sandwich features a crispy fish fillet topped with creamy tartar sauce, nestled in a soft, steamed bun. It offers a perfect balance of flavors that many have loved for decades.
The simplicity of this sandwich delivers a consistent taste that keeps people coming back. However, some might find it a bit plain, so it’s ideal for those who enjoy straightforward flavors.
2. Burger King Big Fish
Though Burger King is known for its burgers, the Big Fish sandwich is surprisingly satisfying. This sandwich features a crunchy fish fillet paired with fresh lettuce and tartar sauce, all enclosed in a sesame seed bun. It offers a delightful crunch with every bite.
However, the fillet’s size might not satisfy those with bigger appetites. It’s a dependable option when you’re in the mood for something familiar yet fulfilling.
3. Wendy’s North Pacific Cod
Interestingly, Wendy’s brings a wild-caught touch with its North Pacific Cod sandwich. This option boasts a flaky, wild-caught cod fillet dressed with dill tartar sauce, resting on a toasted bun. The combination brings a fresh taste that stands out among others.
While the dill tartar sauce adds a unique flair, it may not appeal to everyone. It’s perfect for those who appreciate a gourmet twist on their fast-food fish sandwich.
4. Arby’s King’s Hawaiian Fish Deluxe
Arby’s offers a taste of paradise with the King’s Hawaiian Fish Deluxe. Featuring a crispy fish fillet, fresh lettuce, and tomato, topped with cheese, all in a sweet King’s Hawaiian bun, this sandwich is a delightful escape.
The sweet bun contrasts beautifully with the savory ingredients. However, some might find the sweetness overwhelming. It’s a treat for those who love a mix of sweet and savory in a sandwich.
5. Popeyes Cajun Flounder Sandwich
Imagine a sandwich that packs a punch – Popeyes Cajun Flounder Sandwich delivers just that. With a spicy flounder fillet, paired with pickles and tartar sauce, all served on a toasted brioche bun, this sandwich is a flavor explosion.
The spicy kick is perfect for those who crave a bit of heat. However, it may be too intense for those with milder tastes. It’s a bold choice that stands out in the world of fast food fish sandwiches.
6. Carl’s Jr. Beer Battered Fish Sandwich
Ever wondered if beer-battered goodness could be captured in a sandwich? Carl’s Jr. delivers with its Beer Battered Fish Sandwich. Featuring a beer-battered fish fillet, accompanied by lettuce and tartar sauce in a sesame seed bun, it offers a unique taste experience.
The beer batter adds a distinct flavor, though it may not suit everyone’s palate. It’s the right choice for those who enjoy a bit of culinary adventure.
7. Culver’s North Atlantic Cod Fillet Sandwich
Culver’s takes pride in its North Atlantic Cod Fillet Sandwich, offering quality and taste in every bite. It features a tender cod fillet, topped with shredded cheese and lettuce, enclosed in a buttered bun. This sandwich promises freshness with a touch of indulgence.
It’s a deliciously rich option, perfect for when you’re craving something indulgent, though it might be a bit too heavy for those looking for a lighter bite.
8. Long John Silver’s Fish Sandwich
Where fast food meets the sea, Long John Silver’s Fish Sandwich brings maritime flavors to your taste buds. With a crispy fish fillet, fresh lettuce, and tartar sauce on a soft bun, it pays homage to classic fish and chips.
Though the sandwich is packed with flavor, it might be too greasy for some. It’s a hearty option for those who adore traditional fish dishes in a convenient form.
9. Jack in the Box Fish Sandwich
Interestingly, Jack in the Box serves a straightforward Fish Sandwich that doesn’t disappoint. Featuring a crispy fish fillet, lettuce, and tartar sauce, all in a classic bun, it sticks to traditional flavors. The sandwich offers a no-frills option for those who enjoy simplicity.
However, it might lack the wow factor some seek in a fish sandwich. It’s a solid choice for anyone craving a quick, delicious meal without unnecessary fuss.
10. Checkers Crispy Fish Sandwich
Though Checkers is famous for its burgers, the Crispy Fish Sandwich is a tasty option. It features a crispy fish fillet, fresh lettuce, and tartar sauce, all in a classic bun. The sandwich provides a satisfying crunch that’s appealing to many.
However, the simplicity might leave some wanting more. It’s a great pick for those who value a straightforward, no-nonsense fish sandwich.
11. Sonic Fish Sandwich
How does Sonic come into play in the realm of fish sandwiches? Their Fish Sandwich offers a simple yet delightful experience. Featuring a breaded fish fillet, lettuce, and tartar sauce on a toasted bun, it sticks to familiar flavors.
Though it may not be the most groundbreaking option, it delivers consistency. It’s a reliable choice when you’re seeking something familiar yet satisfying.
12. White Castle Fish Slider
If you’re seeking a bite-sized delight, the White Castle Fish Slider is a perfect choice. With a fish fillet, cheese, and tartar sauce nestled in a small slider bun, it offers a quick, flavorful snack. The slider’s petite size makes it ideal for those on the go.
However, it may not fill you up if you’re especially hungry. It’s a charming option for those who love smaller, more manageable portions.
13. Bojangles Bojangler
Interestingly, Bojangles enters the fish sandwich arena with the Bojangler. This sandwich features a crispy fish fillet, American cheese, and tartar sauce, all in a sesame seed bun. It delivers a satisfying crunch paired with a touch of cheese.
The flavors can be a bit intense for some, but it’s the perfect choice for those who love a hearty, bold sandwich full of rich, flavor-packed goodness.
14. Hardee’s Fish Sandwich
Though Hardee’s may not be famous for seafood, their Fish Sandwich is a pleasant surprise. It features a breaded fish fillet, lettuce, and tartar sauce on a toasted bun.
The sandwich offers a balanced flavor profile, providing a reliable choice for fish enthusiasts. However, it may not be the most innovative option. It’s perfect for those seeking a simple, dependable meal without any surprises.
15. Dairy Queen Wild Alaskan Fish Sandwich
Interestingly, Dairy Queen brings a touch of the wild with its Wild Alaskan Fish Sandwich. Featuring a wild Alaskan fish fillet, fresh lettuce, and tartar sauce, all on a toasted bun, it offers a refreshing taste.
The wild-caught fish offers a unique, bold flavor that sets it apart. It may not be for everyone, but it’s perfect for those craving something a bit more adventurous.
16. Captain D’s Giant Fish Sandwich
For those with a giant appetite, Captain D’s Giant Fish Sandwich is a perfect fit. Featuring a large fish fillet, fresh lettuce, and tartar sauce on a toasted bun, this sandwich promises satisfaction.
The size makes it ideal for those who love a hearty meal. However, it might be too much for those seeking a lighter snack. It’s a fantastic choice for anyone wanting a substantial, satisfying sandwich.
17. A&W Hand-Breaded Cod Sandwich
If hand-breaded delights are what you seek, A&W’s Hand-Breaded Cod Sandwich delivers. Featuring a hand-breaded cod fillet, lettuce, and tartar sauce, all on a soft bun, it offers a homemade feel. The hand-breading process provides a unique texture and flavor.
It may not be for those who prefer simplicity, but it’s a perfect pick for those who love a dish with character and a little extra flair.
18. Church’s Fish Sandwich
Interestingly, Church’s takes a straightforward approach with their Fish Sandwich. Featuring a crispy fish fillet, lettuce, and tartar sauce on a toasted bun, it keeps things simple.
It’s a dependable choice for those who prefer a straightforward, no-fuss meal that gets the job done without any surprises. Perfect for anyone who enjoys a classic, unpretentious fish sandwich without all the bells and whistles.
19. Freddy’s Fish Sandwich
How does Freddy’s approach the fish sandwich game? With a flaky fish fillet, lettuce, and tartar sauce on a toasted bun, their Fish Sandwich offers a delightful experience.
The flakiness of the fillet provides a unique texture. However, the simplicity might not satisfy those looking for more excitement. It’s a solid choice for anyone who values a straightforward, enjoyable meal.
20. Shake Shack Fish Sandwich
Imagine a fish sandwich with a gourmet twist – Shake Shack delivers just that. Featuring a crispy fish fillet, lettuce, pickles, and tartar sauce on a potato bun, it offers a refined taste.
The mix of ingredients creates a satisfying contrast of flavors, though its more refined approach may not be to everyone’s taste. For those seeking a higher-end fast food experience, this option truly stands out.
21. Krystal Fish Sandwich
If you’re looking for a quick bite, Krystal’s Fish Sandwich is a tempting choice. Featuring a fish fillet, cheese, and tartar sauce on a small bun, it offers a convenient, flavorful snack.
With its petite size, this sandwich is perfect for a quick bite, though it may leave those with bigger appetites wanting more. It’s an excellent choice for anyone looking for a convenient, on-the-go meal.
22. Subway Fish Sub
How about a fish sandwich in a sub form? Subway’s Fish Sub offers a unique twist on the classic. Featuring a fish fillet, fresh lettuce, tomatoes, and tartar sauce in a sub roll, it delivers a refreshing taste experience.
The sub format offers a twist on the usual sandwich, but the roll may not have the best texture for everyone. It’s a choice for those looking to try something different, though it may not quite hit the mark.
23. Whataburger Fish Sandwich
Ever considered Whataburger for a fishy delight? Their Fish Sandwich features a crispy fish fillet, fresh lettuce, and tartar sauce on a classic bun. It offers a traditional yet satisfying experience.
The sandwich’s simplicity offers a reliable taste, but it may lack excitement for those seeking something more adventurous. Plus, it’s not always available on the menu, making it a hit or miss option when you’re craving something straightforward.