Skip to Content

12 Store-Bought English Muffin Brands, Ranked From Best To Worst

12 Store-Bought English Muffin Brands, Ranked From Best To Worst

Sharing is caring!

When it comes to breakfast, English muffins have a special place in my heart. Their versatility and deliciousness make them a morning staple for many.

Today, we’re diving into the world of store-bought English muffins, ranking twelve popular brands to help you make the best choice. From exceptional to not-so-great, here’s a comprehensive guide to satisfy your muffin cravings.

1. Thomas’ Original English Muffins

Thomas' Original English Muffins
© thomasbreakfast

Thomas’ Original English Muffins have long been a household name. Their signature texture, with perfect nooks and crannies, holds spreads wonderfully. You can truly enjoy your toppings with every bite.

They offer a slightly tangy flavor that sets them apart, making mornings delightful. Whether toasted or plain, they never disappoint.

Many consider them the gold standard, and it’s easy to see why. Their consistent quality and taste have earned them a top spot in many kitchens.

2. Trader Joe’s Gluten-Free British Muffins

Trader Joe's Gluten-Free British Muffins
© traderjoes

Trader Joe’s Gluten-Free British Muffins are a breakfast lover’s dream. The texture is fluffy, yet robust, providing the ideal base for any topping.

Their mild, slightly sweet flavor complements both savory and sweet accompaniments beautifully. Toast them to perfection, and you’ll be greeted with a satisfying crunch.

These muffins are beloved for their affordable price and high quality, making them a favorite among savvy shoppers. Morning routines never tasted so good.

3. Bays Original English Muffins

Bays Original English Muffins
© baysmuffins

Bays Original English Muffins offer a delightful eating experience. Airy, soft interior contrasts nicely with a slightly crisp exterior.

The subtle, rich flavor makes them a versatile choice for various toppings, from fruity jams to creamy spreads. Every bite is a treat.

Widely available, they’ve gained popularity for delivering consistent taste and texture. Whether for breakfast or a snack, they remain a solid choice.

4. Whole Foods Market English Muffins

Whole Foods Market English Muffins
© feastingathome

Whole Foods Market English Muffins bring a gourmet touch to the breakfast table. Hearty texture and wholesome ingredients stand out.

Packed with flavor, they transform simple meals into extraordinary treats. Enjoy them with your favorite toppings, and the experience is sublime.

Praised for using quality ingredients, these muffins cater to the discerning palate. Elevate your mornings with their unique appeal.

5. Pepperidge Farm Stone Ground Whole Wheat English Muffins

Pepperidge Farm Stone Ground Whole Wheat English Muffins
© birchhillenglishmuffins

Pepperidge Farm Stone Ground Whole Wheat Muffins are a healthier alternative without sacrificing taste. Their nutty, earthy flavors appeal to the health-conscious.

These muffins offer a hearty bite, with a satisfying density that fills you up. Toasting enhances their natural sweetness, creating a delightful treat.

For those seeking a nutritious start, these muffins provide the perfect solution. Enjoy them guilt-free, knowing you’re making a wholesome choice.

6. 365 by Whole Foods Market Classic English Muffins

365 by Whole Foods Market Classic English Muffins
© abillion

365 by Whole Foods Market Classic English Muffins are a celebration of goodness. Their soft, chewy texture is inviting, making breakfast an enjoyable occasion.

Each bite offers a delicate balance of flavors, perfect for those seeking something natural. Pair with organic butter or jam for a truly organic meal.

Loved for their commitment to quality, these muffins are a testament to Whole Foods’ dedication to healthy living. Start your day with nature’s best.

7. Walmart Great Value English Muffins

Walmart Great Value English Muffins
© eatatovereasy

Walmart Great Value English Muffins, despite their low price, fall short in flavor and texture. They tend to be dense and lack the characteristic nooks and crannies.

Many find them disappointing, as they don’t toast as evenly as others. The flavor is bland, making them less appealing for breakfast enthusiasts.

While budget-friendly, they might not satisfy those looking for quality. Consider exploring other brands for a more satisfying breakfast experience.

8. Aldi’s L’oven Fresh English Muffins

Aldi's L'oven Fresh English Muffins
© Aldi Reviewer

Aldi’s L’oven Fresh English Muffins often miss the mark in terms of taste and texture. Their doughy consistency can be off-putting when toasted.

The lack of distinct flavor leaves much to be desired, especially for those who enjoy vibrant breakfast options. They can be forgettable in comparison.

Despite the attractive price, these muffins may not deliver the delightful experience expected. You might want to try other options for a better bite.

9. Best Yet English Muffins

Best Yet English Muffins
© kenjilopezalt

Best Yet English Muffins might not live up to their name for some. Texture is often criticized for being too chewy, without the desired crispness.

The bland flavor fails to excite the palate, leaving breakfast lovers yearning for more. Toasting may not improve the situation much.

Although affordable, they may not be the best investment for those seeking quality. Exploring alternatives could lead to a more enjoyable meal.

10. Birch Hill Original English Muffins

Birch Hill Original English Muffins
© birchhillenglishmuffins

Birch Hill Original English Muffins may not impress with their texture or taste. Spongy consistency often leaves breakfast enthusiasts underwhelmed.

The lack of strong flavor can make them a less desirable option, especially when compared to more robust competitors. They seem to fall flat.

For those prioritizing taste, exploring other offerings might prove more rewarding. Better options await those willing to search beyond this brand.

11. Pillsbury Grands! Frozen English Muffins

Pillsbury Grands! Frozen English Muffins
© Amazon.com

Pillsbury Grands! Frozen English Muffins face challenges in texture and freshness. Frozen nature sometimes leads to a less chewy, more rigid bite.

The taste can be underwhelming, failing to capture the essence of a fresh muffin. Even with preparation, they might still fall short of greatness.

While convenient, they may not satisfy those seeking a truly fresh experience. Consider trying freshly baked options for a superior breakfast.

12. Sara Lee Original English Muffins

Sara Lee Original English Muffins
© Calorie Counter and Diet Tracker for Weight Loss – FatSecret

Sara Lee Original English Muffins struggle to stand out. Their lackluster texture and flavor don’t quite match up to competitors.

Many find them too dense, lacking the lightness and airiness associated with traditional muffins. Toasting might not offer much improvement.

Although they come from a well-known brand, the overall experience may leave you wanting more. Exploring other brands could lead to a more satisfying breakfast.