Cherry pie is a timeless classic, but with these 17 recipes, you’ll discover new ways to make it even more irresistible. The sweet, tart flavor of cherries pairs beautifully with buttery crusts, and each recipe adds its own unique twist to keep things exciting.
In addition to the traditional favorites, five surprising twists will elevate your cherry pie game and surprise even the most seasoned bakers. Get ready to wow your taste buds and impress your guests with every slice!
1. Macaroon Cherry Pie
Imagine a pie crust topped with a luscious cherry filling. Toasted coconut macaroon crowns this delicious pie, adding a tropical twist.
This delightful variation provides a unique texture that complements the cherries’ natural juiciness. You won’t believe how this combination elevates a classic dessert to a whole new level of flavor and satisfaction.
2. Michigan Cherry Pie
Michigan cherries, known for their rich flavor, make this pie unforgettable. A golden lattice crust encases the juicy filling, offering a tempting contrast.
Baking this pie brings a taste of the Great Lakes’ charm to your table. It’s perfect for those who cherish traditional flavors with a touch of regional pride.
3. Cherry Almond Mousse Pie
Silky almond mousse pairs with cherry glaze to create a sophisticated treat. Slivered almonds introduce a satisfying crunch.
This pie is perfect for special occasions or to indulge in a moment of luxury. The combination of flavors and textures will captivate both almond and cherry lovers, offering a refined dessert experience.
4. Cherry-Almond Streusel Tart
A buttery crust supports a vibrant cherry filling, topped with almond streusel. The crumbly topping enhances every bite with its nutty sweetness.
Ideal for brunch or afternoon tea, this tart brings a bit of elegance to any gathering. Experience the harmonious blend of cherries and almonds in every delightful slice.
5. Cherry Chocolate Pecan Pie
Decadence is key in this pie, where cherry meets chocolate and pecan. Each bite reveals a rich, glossy filling that tantalizes the taste buds.
Great choice for those who crave a dessert with depth and complexity. This pie promises a memorable ending to any meal, especially during the holiday season.
6. Rhubarb Cherry Pie
The tartness of rhubarb perfectly balances with the sweetness of cherries, creating a flavorful pie. Encased in a rustic, flaky crust, the filling is both vibrant and comforting.
Served warm with a scoop of ice cream or on its own, this pie is a true treat. It captures the essence of seasonal bounty, delighting both traditional pie lovers and those craving a new twist.
7. Quick Cherry Turnovers
For those short on time, these turnovers offer a quick yet satisfying cherry dessert. Flaky pastry envelopes the sweet and tart cherry filling.
Ideal for breakfast or a snack, they are both portable and delicious. Enjoy these turnovers fresh from the oven, dusted with powdered sugar, for a delightful treat.
8. Black Forest Tart
Here, we have a rich tart that combines dark chocolate with cherries for a classic flavor combination. Chocolate shavings and whipped cream adorn the top, adding elegance.
This tart is a tantalizing choice for those who appreciate depth in their desserts. Every bite is a luxurious experience, perfect for special occasions.
9. Cherry Pear Pie
Sweet pears and cherries make a delightful duo in this pie. A lattice crust adds a charming touch, complementing the juicy filling inside.
Serve this pie warm, and enjoy the combination of flavors that brings a taste of the countryside to your table. It’s a comforting choice for both family gatherings and solo indulgence.
10. Cherry-Chocolate Pudgy Pie
This pie brings the spirit of camping to life with its gooey marshmallow, cherry, and chocolate filling. Made over a crackling campfire, it’s as fun to prepare as it is to eat.
Perfect for adventurous souls, it offers a sweet, comforting treat under the stars. The combination of flavors makes it a memorable dessert for any outdoor gathering.
11. Apple-Cherry Cream Cheese Pie
Creamy and fruity, this pie combines apples, cherries, and cream cheese for a luscious dessert. A smooth filling creates a harmonious blend of flavors, making it a decadent treat.
Ideal for family gatherings or casual get-togethers, it’s sure to delight. With its indulgent taste and texture, this pie is a favorite for those who crave a rich dessert.
12. Sour Cherry Pie
Sour cherries shine in this classic pie, providing a tangy contrast to the buttery crust. Each slice transports you into the heart of traditional American baking, especially when paired with a scoop of ice cream.
Great for summer days or festive occasions, this pie always leaves a lasting impression. Its timeless appeal makes it a favorite for any dessert lover.
13. Cherry Cheesecake Pie
Indulge in the rich, creamy texture of cheesecake paired with a luscious cherry topping. This delightful pie offers a fusion of tangy and sweet that is irresistible.
Must-try for cheesecake lovers, it brings an elegant touch to any dessert table. Enjoy a slice with a cup of tea for a moment of pure bliss.
14. Cherry Lime Pie
A zesty lime glaze enhances the natural sweetness of cherries in this refreshing pie. The combination of tart and sweet makes it a delightful choice for warm days.
Chill this pie before serving to enhance the refreshing burst of citrus and cherry flavors. It’s the perfect treat to enjoy on any occasion.
15. Cherry Coffee Cake Pie
Morning routines become special with this pie, where cherry meets a crumbly cinnamon topping. Ideal for breakfast or brunch, it pairs wonderfully with a cup of coffee.
The combination of textures and flavors creates a comforting start to the day. It’s a favorite among those who love a touch of sweetness in the morning.
16. Cherry Pineapple Pie
This pie takes you to a tropical paradise with its blend of sweet pineapples and cherries. Encased in a golden crust, the filling offers a perfect fusion of exotic and comforting flavors.
Ideal for those longing for an island escape, it brings a sunny vibe to your table. Each bite offers a delightful taste of tropical warmth.
17. Spiced Cherry Pie
Infuse your cherry pie with aromatic spices like cinnamon and cloves for added warmth. The spiced crust deepens the flavor, making it an ideal choice for cooler days.
Enjoying this pie by the fire, the spices elevate the cherries’ natural sweetness. It’s a comforting and flavorful treat that brings cozy vibes to any occasion.
18. Cherry Ricotta Pie
The creamy texture of ricotta pairs beautifully with the tartness of cherries in this delightful pie. Its smooth filling offers a refreshing taste, reminiscent of Mediterranean desserts.
Best for those who prefer a lighter, creamier dessert, this pie adds sophistication to any occasion. With a touch of Italy in every bite, it’s a refined treat that will impress any guest.
19. Cherry Custard Pie
Combining a smooth custard filling with cherries, this pie is both elegant and delicious. A glossy surface beckons you to indulge in a slice of this timeless treat.
Great choice for formal gatherings or afternoon tea, it brings a classic flavor combination to the table. The refined taste of this pie ensures it never goes out of style.
20. Cherry Cranberry Pie
Cranberries join cherries to create a pie perfect for the holiday season. The tartness of cranberries enhances the sweetness of cherries, offering a delightful balance.
A rustic lattice crust adds charm, making it a lovely addition to festive tables. Enjoy this pie with loved ones, as its flavors evoke warmth and celebration.
21. Cherry Bourbon Pie
Bourbon brings depth to this cherry pie, offering a rich, robust flavor. The golden crust encases a filling that delights the palate with its complexity.
This pie offers a spirited twist on classic desserts, delivering a luxurious experience. It’s the perfect choice for adult gatherings or a special treat.
22. Cherry Nutella Pie
Chocolate lovers rejoice with this pie, where creamy Nutella meets juicy cherries. The combination creates a luscious dessert that satisfies both sweet and nutty cravings.
This pie adds a touch of urban sophistication to your table, perfect for modern palates. It offers a slice of indulgence, making it ideal for any occasion.