Once upon a time, the baking aisle was a wonderland of wild cake mix flavors—until some vanished faster than my willpower at a dessert buffet.
Today, we’re taking a sugary stroll down memory lane, revisiting 23 cake mixes that once ruled our ovens but are now just crumbs in history.
Grab a whisk (or a tissue), because these lost flavors might just bake you emotional!
1. Pillsbury Pink Lemonade Angel Food Cake Mix
When you wanted a light, zesty dessert, this mix was perfect. The refreshing taste of pink lemonade mixed with the airy texture of angel food cake was a match made in heaven.
Though no longer available, its unique flavor continues to be missed by avid bakers everywhere.
2. Betty Crocker Dole Pineapple Cake Mix
Where pineapple upside-down cakes reigned, this mix made baking them simple and delicious. The partnership with Dole brought authentic pineapple flavor right into your kitchen.
However, the tropical delight was short-lived, leaving us to reminisce about those sunny, fruity cakes.
3. Betty Crocker Honey Spice Cake Mix
However, if you cherished warm, spicy flavors with a hint of sweetness, this cake mix was a favorite. The combination of honey and spices offered a cozy cake experience.
Alas, as trends shifted, this comforting flavor was retired but not forgotten.
4. Betty Crocker Chocolate Malt Cake Mix
Betty Crocker once brought the malt shop to your oven with this delightful mix. How it captured the essence of malted milk balls in cake form was nothing short of genius.
Sadly, it was discontinued, leaving malt lovers yearning for its return to the dessert world.
5. Duncan Hines’ Applesauce Raisin Cake Mix
When nostalgia calls, this mix answered with the taste of apples and raisins baked into a moist cake. It evoked memories of autumn days and cozy kitchens.
If only it could have stayed, as its disappearance leaves us longing for those spiced apple notes.
6. Duncan Hines Dutch Topping Cake Mixes
Where crumb toppings are cherished, this mix delivered a cake with a delightful Dutch topping. The crumbly, sweet finish was a perfect complement to the moist cake underneath.
However, it has since disappeared, leaving a crater in the hearts of crumb cake enthusiasts.
7. Betty Crocker Sunkist Orange Cake Mix
If citrusy zest and sweetness are your desires, this cake mix once brought them together splendidly. Partnering with Sunkist ensured a genuine orange flavor that was both refreshing and light.
Sadly, it has disappeared, leaving citrus lovers to seek alternatives.
8. Pillsbury Caramel Swirl Cake Mix
For those who indulged in the rich, buttery taste of caramel, this mix was heavenly.
The swirls of caramel running through a moist cake were irresistible. However, its disappearance has left caramel aficionados craving that luscious blend once more.
9. Betty Crocker Chocolate Cherry Cake Mix
Cherry lovers once delighted in this mix that combined the rich taste of chocolate with tart cherries. The decadent pairing was a hit for many special occasions.
Alas, as time moved on, this flavor was retired, leaving us with sweet memories of its luscious taste.
10. Duncan Hines Lemon Pudding Cake Mix
If light, tangy flavors with a creamy twist were your choice, this cake mix delivered.
The luscious lemon pudding center offered a burst of sunshine in every bite. However, as it became a relic, we are left to recreate its bright flavors in our own kitchens.
11. Pillsbury Banana Nut Cake Mix
When mornings called for a banana-flavored treat, this mix answered. The blend of ripe bananas and crunchy nuts created a flavorful cake perfect for breakfast or dessert.
Though its time has passed, the taste lingers on in our memories, urging us to recreate it.
12. Betty Crocker Coconut Pecan Cake Mix
For tropical flavor enthusiasts, this mix once brought the exotic taste of coconut and pecans together. It was a harmonious blend perfect for island-themed parties.
Unfortunately, it has gone, and we are left to dream of sandy beaches and coconut desserts.
13. Duncan Hines Chocolate Raspberry Cake Mix
When romance was in the air, this mix set the mood with its rich chocolate flavor and tart raspberries. The combination was both indulgent and refreshing.
Alas, it no longer graces the shelves, leaving us to cherish those special moments it once enhanced.
14. Pillsbury Blueberry Coffee Cake Mix
If mornings required a fruity start, this mix offered the perfect solution. The sweet blueberries blended seamlessly with a soft coffee cake, perfect with a morning brew.
Yet, it has vanished, and we’re left with fond memories of berry-filled breakfasts.
15. Betty Crocker Red Velvet Cake Mix
Though red velvet is a classic, this specific mix offered a distinct flavor profile that many adored. The rich red color and velvety texture were unmatched.
However, it’s no longer available, urging us to experiment with our own versions to capture its magic.
16. Duncan Hines Cinnamon Apple Cake Mix
Where autumn flavors reign, this mix was a staple. The warm blend of cinnamon and apple provided a comforting treat during colder months.
Though it’s now gone, its seasonal charm lingers in the hearts of those who once enjoyed its cozy allure.
17. Pillsbury Maple Nut Cake Mix
If you sought the taste of maple syrup in cake form, this mix delivered with finesse. The combination of sweet maple and crunchy nuts was a breakfast favorite.
However, it has since disappeared, leaving us to reminisce about its sweet, nutty charm.
18. Betty Crocker Strawberry Shortcake Cake Mix
For summer afternoons, this mix brought the essence of strawberry shortcake to life. The sweet strawberries and fluffy cake were a refreshing delight.
Yet, it has been retired, leaving us to find other ways to enjoy that classic, fruity combination.
19. Duncan Hines Gingerbread Spice Cake Mix
When holidays arrived, this mix was a must-have. The warm spices and molasses flavor created the perfect cake for festive gatherings.
Sadly, it has been discontinued, leaving gingerbread lovers to craft their own spiced creations for holiday cheer.
20. Betty Crocker Peaches And Cream Cake Mix
When summer’s bounty was plenty, this mix celebrated it with peaches and cream.
The luscious peaches blended beautifully with the soft cake. However, it has since disappeared, leaving us to seek other ways to enjoy those juicy, summer flavors.
21. Duncan Hines Devil’s Food Cake Mix
Though a classic option, this version offered a unique depth of flavor and richness. The deep chocolate taste made it a favorite among chocoholics.
Yet, it has vanished, leaving us to experiment with our own recipes to capture its sinfully sweet essence.
22. Duncan Hines Sour Cream Chocolate Cake Mix
If you ever craved the perfect balance between sour and rich chocolate, this cake mix was your answer. The blend of sour cream and chocolate created a unique, moist cake that many remember fondly.
How this flavor disappeared is a mystery, but its absence leaves a notable void in the baking aisle.
23. Pillsbury Pumpkin Spice Cake Mix
If autumn aromas are your desire, this mix once filled kitchens with the scent of pumpkin and spices. It was the epitome of fall baking.
However, it is no longer available, urging us to recreate its warmth and flavor during the cozy season.