At Jimmy John’s, choosing the right sandwich can make all the difference between a meal that’s sheer delight and one that’s a bit of a letdown. Whether you’re a seasoned fan or a curious newcomer, knowing which options shine and which fall flat is essential.
Let’s explore the 12 best and 4 worst sandwiches to order at this beloved sandwich chain.
1. The Italian Night Club
If you’re seeking a sandwich experience that transports you to the streets of Italy, the Italian Night Club is your ticket.
Layers of salami, capicola, and ham create a symphony of flavors. The crisp lettuce and juicy tomatoes add a refreshing crunch.
2. The Beach Club
How about a taste of summer in every bite? The Beach Club combines turkey and creamy avocado spread for a light, refreshing meal.
It’s served on soft 9-grain bread that evokes the carefree feel of a beach day. Crisp lettuce and juicy tomatoes enhance this creation.
3. The Bootlegger Club
Where roast beef meets turkey, the Bootlegger Club offers a timeless combination. Lettuce, tomatoes, and mayo provide a classic accompaniment.
This sandwich is a safe bet for those who enjoy a fusion of savory flavors. It’s straightforward yet satisfying.
4. The Veggie
However, for those preferring a meatless option, The Veggie stands out with its layers of provolone cheese and avocado spread. Cucumber, lettuce, and tomato add a garden-fresh crunch.
It’s a colorful sandwich that doesn’t skimp on flavor. Perfect for a lighter meal.
5. The Jimmy Cubano
Though not always the first choice, the Jimmy Cubano offers a unique twist with its Cuban-style fillings. Ham, bacon, and cheese come together with crisp pickle slices.
A balanced and savory delight. It’s grilled to perfection, bringing out all the flavors in a warm, satisfying bite.
6. Club Lulu
If turkey and bacon sound like a dream team, Club Lulu delivers just that. Fresh lettuce and tomato round out this hearty combination.
Served on a soft French roll, this sandwich is both comforting and flavorful. It’s a straightforward choice that satisfies without fuss.
7. The Billy Club
For those who enjoy a robust flavor profile, the Billy Club combines roast beef and ham with a touch of Dijon mustard. Lettuce and tomato balance the richness, while cheese adds a creamy texture.
Served on French bread, this sandwich is hearty and fulfilling. Perfect for meat lovers.
8. The Vegetarian Sub
If simplicity is your preference, the Vegetarian Sub might seem appealing. However, with just lettuce, tomato, and cucumber, it lacks excitement and flavor.
It’s a minimalist choice that may leave you wanting more. Ideal for those who love simplicity, but perhaps not the best for a flavorful experience.
9. The Slim 6 – Double Provolone
Where simplicity meets plainness, the Slim 6 – Double Provolone offers double provolone cheese on bread. It lacks additional ingredients or flair, making it a rather uneventful choice.
If cheese is your sole craving, it might suffice, but it doesn’t deliver on variety or excitement.
10. The Tuna Club
Though tuna lovers might be tempted, the Tuna Club doesn’t quite hit the mark. With mayo, lettuce, and tomato, it falls short of delivering the vibrant flavors expected from a seafood dish.
It’s a decent choice for a basic tuna sandwich. It doesn’t stand out in the lineup.
11. The Plain Slim 3 – Tuna Salad
If you’re after simplicity, the Plain Slim 3 – Tuna Salad provides just that. However, with minimal ingredients, it offers an uninspired experience.
It’s a straightforward choice for tuna salad lovers, but lacks the creativity or zest of other options. A passable option for a simple meal.
12. Vito
The quintessential Italian sub that brings authentic deli flavors to your palate. Stacked with salami, capicola, and provolone.
A sandwich that sings with the addition of oil, vinegar, and oregano. Each bite is reminiscent of a charming Italian bistro.
13. Slim 5 – Italian
For those who appreciate simplicity, the Slim 5 – Italian provides a no-frills yet flavorful option. This sandwich combines a select mix of Italian meats and provolone cheese.
All wrapped up in fresh bread. Despite its simplicity, Slim 5 offers a burst of flavor that speaks volumes.
14. JJ’s BLT
If you’re a fan of classic flavors, JJ’s BLT is the way to go. This sandwich features crispy bacon that crumbles like autumn leaves, partnered with fresh, crunchy lettuce and juicy, ripe tomatoes.
What makes JJ’s BLT a standout is its balance. The ingredients complement each other perfectly.
15. Slim 4 – Turkey Breast
Slim 4 – Turkey Breast is the definition of simplicity done right. Featuring only fresh, hand-sliced turkey breast within its soft bread, it caters to those who prefer a lean, protein-packed mea.
The turkey’s natural flavor is the star of the show, offering a clean and satisfying taste with every bite.
16. Gargantuan Sub
It’s not for the faint of heart. Loaded with a variety of meats including salami, capicola, and roast beef, this sandwich is a carnivore’s dream.
Its sheer size and bold flavors make it one of the best picks for those who love a hearty meal. An unforgettable choice for any sandwich lover.