Ben & Jerry’s has been pushing boundaries since day one, and I’ve been on a delicious journey tasting every wild and wonderful flavor they’ve offered. Some flavors are pure, timeless indulgence, while others… well, they leave you scratching your head.
Here’s my honest, flavor-packed ranking of 28 Ben & Jerry’s creations—from those that make you weep with joy to those that might be better left in the freezer. Every scoop is an adventure, and I’m here to spill the scoop.
Some flavors hit all the right notes, blending texture and taste in ways that make your brain light up with dopamine. Others, despite their ambition, just don’t quite cut it. Buckle up and get ready for a roller coaster of sweet, surprising, and sometimes outrageous ice cream trivia!
1. Half Baked
Half Baked is the ultimate comfort food dream—a glorious medley of chocolate chip cookie dough and fudgy brownie chunks. It’s a texture explosion and a nostalgia trip all in one.
This flavor’s addictive nature comes from its perfect balance of crunchy cookie pieces and rich, melty brownie that keeps you coming back for more.
2. Cherry Garcia
A true classic, Cherry Garcia delivers a harmonious blend of tart cherries and smooth chocolate. Every bite is a perfect balance of fruity brightness and deep cocoa richness.
The magic lies in its simplicity—flavors that have stood the test of time, turning a simple ice cream into an iconic masterpiece that’s hard to resist.
3. Chocolate Fudge Brownie
Dense, fudgy, and unapologetically chocolatey, this flavor is every chocoholic’s dream. It’s the kind of treat that melts slowly in your mouth, flooding your senses with decadence.
Its addictiveness stems from the intense, pure chocolate flavor that triggers a surge of dopamine, making every bite an indulgent escape.
4. Phish Food
Marshmallow, caramel, and fudge fish—a flavor with a name as wild as its taste. It’s a playful concoction that brings together sweet and savory in unexpected harmony.
The combination of gooey caramel and a hint of marshmallow magic creates an addictive texture that’s both fun and satisfying, challenging your taste buds in the best possible way.
5. Americone Dream
Americone Dream is a symphony of caramel swirls and crunchy waffle cone bits that practically dance on your tongue. Each spoonful feels like a celebration of creativity and comfort.
Its addictive charm comes from the delightful crunch paired with a smooth, sweet base, creating a multi-dimensional flavor that’s simply irresistible.
6. The Tonight Dough
Overflowing with cookie dough, this flavor is an unabashed love letter to sweet indulgence. It’s like biting into a dessert that never ends—each bite more decadent than the last.
The addictive appeal lies in its unabashed over-the-top nature. The creamy cookie dough pieces mixed with ice cream ignite a rush of nostalgic joy that’s hard to beat.
7. Strawberry Cheesecake
Smooth, creamy cheesecake meets fresh, vibrant strawberry chunks and crunchy graham cracker bits in this dreamy flavor. It’s like dessert in a cup, perfect for any occasion.
The appeal is in its perfect balance of tangy and sweet—a burst of flavors that meld into one irresistible, melt-in-your-mouth experience.
8. Chunky Monkey
Chunky Monkey is a love-it-or-hate-it flavor—a bold mix of banana ice cream, walnuts, and chocolate chunks. Its robust, tropical taste is unforgettable.
The blend of sweet banana with crunchy walnuts creates an addictive texture that speaks directly to your inner rebel. Not everyone’s cup of tea, but if you’re a fan, it’s pure magic.
9. Peanut Butter Cup
For those who live for peanut butter, this flavor is a must. It offers a creamy peanut butter center that dreams are made of.
The velvety, nutty goodness triggers a deep sense of satisfaction. Yet, I sometimes wish it had a bit more mix-in magic to match its creamy allure.
10. Salted Caramel Core
Imagine biting into a donut-like ice cream with a glorious, gooey caramel core that’s simply divine.
While that caramel burst is undeniably addictive, the base can sometimes fall flat. It’s a reminder that even great ideas need a solid foundation.
11. Cinnamon Buns
Cinnamon Buns brings the warm, comforting flavors of a freshly baked pastry into ice cream form. It’s sweet, spicy, and draped in a rich, buttery glaze.
However, it leans a bit too sweet for my taste sometimes—an overindulgence that leaves you longing for balance. Still, the cinnamon kick is enough to keep you intrigued.
12. Netflix & Chilll’d
A quirky mix of pretzels, peanut butter, and fudge, this flavor promised a party in every bite. It’s playful, if not a bit overambitious.
The idea is brilliant, but the execution doesn’t quite hit the mark. It’s fun to try, though I can’t say it ever stole the spotlight.
13. Pistachio Pistachio
A niche flavor that’s as bold as its name suggests—packed with real pistachio goodness. It’s nutty, slightly salty, and has a distinctive crunch.
Addictive for pistachio lovers, but its flavor can be polarizing. If you adore nuts, this one is a hidden treasure; otherwise, it might not be your jam.
14. Gimme S’more!
S’mores in ice cream form? Absolutely genius. This flavor layers marshmallow, graham, and chocolate for a campfire treat that’s both nostalgic and innovative.
The sweet, toasted flavors meld perfectly, sparking a craving for outdoor adventures. Every bite is like sitting around a fire under the stars—pure, addictive bliss.
15. Boom Chocolatta! Cookie Core
Picture a creamy chocolate base with a generous core of crunchy cookie bits. Boom Chocolatta! takes indulgence to a whole new level.
That unexpected crunch amid smooth chocolate sends shockwaves of delight through your taste buds. It’s a texture surprise that keeps you coming back for more.
16. Milk & Cookies
Milk & Cookies captures the essence of childhood—comforting, familiar, and utterly satisfying. The blend of creamy ice cream with chunks of cookie is a true nostalgic delight.
Every bite is a reunion of flavors that feels like a warm hug. It’s the ultimate reminder that sometimes, the simplest combinations are the most addictive.
17. Salted Caramel Almond
A newer addition that has quickly become a favorite, Salted Caramel Almond combines luscious caramel with crunchy almonds.
The salty-sweet harmony is addictive, striking a perfect balance between rich indulgence and a satisfying crunch. It’s a flavor that’s both modern and timeless.
18. Dublin Mudslide
Boozy and bold, Dublin Mudslide mixes hints of Irish cream with a rich, decadent base. It’s a flavor adventure that’s as daring as it is delicious.
Not everyone will be on board with its intense character, but for those who love a spirited twist, it’s an irresistible, liquid indulgence.
19. Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch
Originally promising with its toffee crunch, Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch lost a bit of its magic when Heath bars were swapped in.
It still has its moments—each bite a clash of bitter coffee and sweet toffee—but the overall balance falls short. A potential hit that missed its mark.
20. Urban Bourbon
Urban Bourbon aimed to bring a sophisticated, boozy twist to ice cream but ended up overwhelming the palate.
The bourbon flavor is strong—too strong, in fact—making it a one-note experience that lacks the subtlety needed to truly delight. It’s bold but imbalanced.
21. Everything But The…
This flavor tried to be everything at once, and it became a chaotic mess. Too many mix-ins resulted in a jumble of flavors that never harmonized.
The idea was ambitious, but the execution left me longing for a simpler, more focused profile. It’s a wild experiment that just didn’t deliver.
22. Cherry Crumble
Cherry Crumble was supposed to be a fruity dessert delight, but it fell flat. The promised burst of tart cherry is lost amid a lackluster crumble texture.
I was left disappointed—a flavor that seemed more like an afterthought than a well-crafted treat. It’s a lesson in how not every idea translates into deliciousness.
23. Glampfire Trail Mix
Glampfire Trail Mix had potential with its promise of sweet and salty goodness, but it just didn’t come together.
The mix of ingredients felt disjointed, lacking that essential harmony to keep you coming back. It’s an experiment that, despite its ambition, misses the mark.
24. Schweddy Balls
Schweddy Balls bring a chuckle, courtesy of an SNL reference, but the rum flavor is polarizing. Some swear by it; others find it off-putting.
It’s a bold, risky flavor that pushes the envelope. For some, it’s a playful nod to pop culture; for others, it’s a flavor that’s simply too out there.
25. Peanut Butter & Jelly
Some things belong in a sandwich, not in a pint. Peanut Butter & Jelly in ice cream form attempts to fuse two classics but falls flat.
The iconic combo loses its charm when forced into this medium—what should be a comforting duo becomes a confused mess. It’s a cautionary tale for flavor pairings.
26. Coconuts For Caramel
Too much of a good thing can be overwhelming. Coconuts for Caramel is loaded with coconut flavor, drowning out the delicate sweetness of caramel.
The result is a one-note flavor that feels unbalanced and heavy. It’s a reminder that sometimes, subtlety is key.
27. Candy Bar Pie
Candy Bar Pie tries to bring the indulgence of peanut butter to the forefront, but it overdoes it.
The overwhelming peanut butter flavor masks any nuanced sweetness, making it feel like an excess rather than a treat. It’s a flavor that leaves you wishing for restraint.
28. Jimmy Fallon’s Late Night Snack
Potato chips in ice cream—seriously? Jimmy Fallon’s Late Night Snack is as wild as its name.
This one was an idea that should have stayed in the brainstorming session. The clash of textures and flavors is more confusing than satisfying, proving not every experiment is destined for greatness.