Skip to Content

15 Mistakes When Making Homemade French Fries

15 Mistakes When Making Homemade French Fries

Sharing is caring!

Ever wonder why diner fries always hit the spot, while your homemade batch falls flat? It might be time to dig into the greasy truth behind your french fry flops.

From limp, soggy spuds to bland, uninspired bites, we’re breaking down 15 common mistakes that can derail your path to crispy perfection. Get ready for a lighthearted look at the little missteps that could be sabotaging your golden, glorious fries.

1. Skipping The Soak

Skipping The Soak
© Simple Joy

What if I told you that soaking sliced potatoes in water is not just a myth? Indeed, letting them bathe removes excess starch, preventing them from sticking together.

Without this step, you might as well call them ‘potato clumps.’ Hence, give your spuds a spa-like experience before the big fry. Remember, a little soak makes a big splash in taste!

2. Too Thick, Too Thin

Too Thick, Too Thin
© Spend With Pennies

Ever wondered why some fries feel like chunky logs while others vanish like whispers? It’s all about getting the thickness just right.

If your fries are too thick, they might end up raw inside, while too thin will make them crispier than a wafer. So, how thick should they be? Aim for about a quarter of an inch, and you’ll be in the golden zone.

3. Ignoring The Oil Temperature

Ignoring The Oil Temperature
© Allrecipes

Oh, the perils of frying with cold oil! How can you expect your fries to get that golden tan without a hot oil beach? Frying at the wrong temperature is like trying to sunbathe in the rain.

Keep your oil at a sizzling 325°F for the first fry, and 375°F for the second, to avoid ending up with soggy sticks. This is not the time to play it cool—keep that oil hot!

4. Rushing The Process

Rushing The Process
© Foodle Club

Feeling rushed? Fries aren’t meant to be a fast-food fantasy but a slow-cooked reality. Frying too quickly can lead to burnt outsides and raw insides. Where’s the patience?

Fry in two stages: first, cook through, then crisp them up. So next time you’re tempted to speed up, remember, slow and steady wins the crispy race!

5. Skipping The Seasoning

Skipping The Seasoning
© The Recipe Critic

How can fries be fabulous without a sprinkle of flavor magic? Skipping seasoning is like watching a movie without popcorn. Once they’re out of the fryer, don’t hesitate—season them while they’re hot and oily, ensuring those flavors stick.

You wouldn’t leave a cake unfrosted, so why spare the fries the seasoning? Go creative with spices, and watch your fries become the life of the party.

6. Overcrowding The Fryer

Overcrowding The Fryer
© Restaurant Technologies

Ever packed a suitcase so full it wouldn’t zip? Overcrowding your fryer leads to similar chaos. Stuffing too many fries in the oil drops the temperature, causing soggy results.

Let your fries have some space to breathe, and they’ll crisp up like they’re on a vacation. Fry in batches, and your patience will surely reward you with golden perfection.

7. Skipping The Drying Process

Skipping The Drying Process
© These Old Cookbooks

What if I told you that drying your potatoes is the secret to crunch? Delve into this often ignored step. Moisture is the enemy of crispiness, leading to oil splatters and soft fries.

Dry them thoroughly before frying to ensure they come out as crispy as your favorite song’s beat. A paper towel is your best friend here, so press away and let them dry!

8. Using The Wrong Potato

Using The Wrong Potato
© Food & Wine

Choosing the wrong potato is like casting the wrong actor in a blockbuster hit. Not every potato is meant for frying. Russet potatoes are the stars here, with their high starch content ensuring that desired crispiness.

Other potatoes might lead to mushy results. Choose wisely, and your fries will shine brighter than a Hollywood starlet on the red carpet.

9. Neglecting Oil Quality

Neglecting Oil Quality
© Well Plated

How important is the oil’s reputation in frying success? Turns out, quite a lot! Using old or low-quality oil is like cooking with a bad attitude—results will show it.

Fresh, high smoke point oils like peanut or vegetable oil ensure your fries remain the crispy highlight of your meal. Dispose of old oil regularly, and let freshness reign supreme in your frying endeavors.

10. Frying Too Cold

Frying Too Cold
© Mashed

Ever tried frying in lukewarm oil? It’s like trying to dance without music—utterly disappointing. The right temperature activates the Maillard reaction, that magical browning process.

Keep the oil hot and steady to achieve those crispy exteriors. Avoid the cold fry blues by monitoring your temperature like a hawk. A thermometer is your trusty sidekick here.

11. Not Double Frying

Not Double Frying
© Garlic & Zest

What if I told you that double frying is the secret handshake of perfect fries? One fry cooks them, but the second gives them that irresistible crunch. It’s a two-step dance, like the tango, but with potatoes.

So, fry them once to cook, rest them, and then fry again to crisp. This method turns your kitchen into a gourmet fry haven.

12. Using Unsuitable Tools

Using Unsuitable Tools
© Tastes Better From Scratch

How can you expect to make magic without the right wand? Using unsuitable tools is a recipe for disaster. A deep fryer, thermometer, and strainer are essentials in your fry arsenal.

Without them, you might end up with more mess than meal. Equip yourself properly, and watch your fries transform into golden spears of delight. Tools matter, so choose wisely!

13. Ignoring The Resting Period

Ignoring The Resting Period
© My Food Story

Have you heard of the post-fry nap? It’s when fries get their groove back. Ignoring the resting period is like skipping sleep—you’ll end up with tired results.

Let your fries rest on a cooling rack to drain excess oil. Just like you, fries need a moment to relax and rejuvenate after the hot bath. This little break makes them crispier and more delicious.

14. Choosing The Wrong Salt

Choosing The Wrong Salt
© RecipeTin Eats

Ever tried seasoning your fries with table salt? It’s like using a pencil to paint—a missed opportunity. Opt for kosher or sea salt for an even, delightful spread.

The right salt enhances flavor without overpowering, making each bite an adventure. Think of it as the cherry on top, except it’s salt on fries. Choose the right salt and let the flavor dance.

15. Neglecting The Frying Vessel

Neglecting The Frying Vessel
© Allrecipes

If your frying vessel isn’t up to scratch, your fries won’t be either. Using a shallow pan is like trying to catch a wave with a teacup. A deep, heavy-bottomed pot ensures even frying and temperature stability.

Choose your vessel wisely, and your fries will ride the wave of deliciousness every time. It’s all about giving those fries the royal treatment!