Skip to Content

The Best Meatballs In America, According To Chefs

The Best Meatballs In America, According To Chefs

Sharing is caring!

Who would’ve thought the humble meatball could spark such an intense culinary debate? Like a well-kept secret, these spherical wonders are a testament to the artistry of American chefs, hidden in bustling kitchens across the nation.

Buckle up and loosen that belt as we embark on a flavorful journey through America’s best meatballs, curated by top chefs who know their way around these succulent spheres of delight.

1. Lincoln Tavern’s Spicy Pork Meatballs

Lincoln Tavern's Spicy Pork Meatballs
© Boston Magazine

Boston’s Lincoln Tavern throws down the gauntlet with its spicy pork meatballs, an audacious blend of heat and flavor. These feisty spheres are crafted from prime pork, kissed with fiery spices, and then bathed in a tangy tomato sauce.

The result? A culinary explosion on the tongue.

2. Rao’s Famous Meatballs

Rao's Famous Meatballs
© Italian Sons and Daughters of America

In the heart of New York City, Rao’s serves up meatballs that are nothing short of legendary. Made with a secret blend of beef, veal, and pork, these meatballs have a melt-in-your-mouth texture that is unforgettable.

Rao’s meatballs have a reputation as big as the city itself.

3. Mamma Maria’s Veal Meatballs

Mamma Maria's Veal Meatballs
© Boston Magazine

Nestled in Boston’s North End, Mamma Maria’s veal meatballs offer a taste of Italy with a New England twist. These tender morsels are crafted from premium veal and simmered slowly in a robust tomato sauce.

The flavors are deep, rich, and comforting, reminiscent of a cozy Italian trattoria.

4. Ippolito’s Italian Kitchen’s Beef And Ricotta Meatballs

Ippolito's Italian Kitchen's Beef And Ricotta Meatballs
© City Lifestyle

Atlanta’s Ippolito’s Italian Kitchen knows how to create a meatball that sings. Combining succulent beef with creamy ricotta, these meatballs offer a luxurious texture that’s both airy and satisfying.

The secret lies in the balance of flavors, where the richness of the beef meets the subtle creaminess of the ricotta.

5. Tony’s Spaghetti House Lamb Meatballs

Tony's Spaghetti House Lamb Meatballs
© Yelp

They introduce a unique twist with their lamb meatballs, a flavorful departure from the traditional beef or pork. These meatballs are infused with aromatic herbs and spices, then cooked to perfection.

The subtle gamey flavor of the lamb is enhanced by a zesty sauce, creating a dish that’s both exotic and comforting.

6. L’Artusi’s Chicken Meatballs

L'Artusi's Chicken Meatballs
© TODAY.com

In the bustling food scene of New York, L’Artusi stands out with its chicken meatballs, a lighter, yet equally delicious alternative to traditional recipes. These meatballs are crafted with care.

They are a blend of tender chicken with fresh herbs and spices, then simmered in a light tomato sauce. The result is a dish that’s both flavorful and refreshing.

7. Kachka’s Siberian Pelmeni Meatballs

Kachka's Siberian Pelmeni Meatballs
© kachkapdx

Portland’s Kachka brings a taste of Russia with their Siberian Pelmeni meatballs, a dish that combines tradition with innovation. These meatballs are made from a blend of meats, wrapped in delicate dough, and served with a dollop of sour cream.

The flavors are rich, evoking the warmth of a Siberian kitchen.

8. The Meatball Shop’s Classic Beef Meatballs

The Meatball Shop's Classic Beef Meatballs
© Plain Chicken

New York’s The Meatball Shop is all about the classics, and their beef meatballs are a testament to timeless culinary traditions. Made with quality beef and seasoned to perfection, these meatballs are served with a tangy marinara sauce.

It highlights their rich flavor. The simplicity of the dish is its strength.

9. Red Sauce Meatballs At The Pink Door

Red Sauce Meatballs At The Pink Door
© infatuation_seattle

A meatball that dances on the palate, enveloped in a luscious red sauce. They are crafted with love, combining beef, pork, and veal into a harmonious blend that’s simmered to perfection.

The sauce is rich, tangy, and infused with herbs, elevating the dish to new heights.

10. Osteria Morini’s Polpette Alla Romana

Osteria Morini's Polpette Alla Romana
© allie_eats_world

In Washington D.C., Osteria Morini presents Polpette alla Romana, a sophisticated take on the classic meatball. Made from a blend of meats and seasonings, these meatballs are served with creamy polenta.

The flavors are well-balanced, with a touch of spice that tantalizes the taste buds..

11. Chef Matt’s Smoky Lamb Meatballs

Chef Matt's Smoky Lamb Meatballs
© SFGATE

San Francisco’s culinary scene is graced by Chef Matt’s smoky lamb meatballs. A dish that combines bold flavors with an innovative twist.

These meatballs are made from succulent lamb, infused with smoky spices that add depth to every bite. Chef Matt’s creation is a testament to his culinary prowess.

12. Diavola’s Spicy Beef Meatballs

Diavola's Spicy Beef Meatballs
© wine_rendezvous

In Napa Valley, Diavola offers a fiery twist on the classic beef meatball. These spicy beef meatballs are infused with chili and spices, creating a dish that’s both bold and exciting.

The heat is balanced by a rich tomato sauce, making each bite a delightful dance of flavors. Diavola’s meatballs are an experience.

13. Barbuzzo’s House-Made Meatballs

Barbuzzo's House-Made Meatballs
© Virtual Restaurant Concierge

House-made meatballs that are a true labor of love. These meatballs are crafted with a blend of meats, herbs, and spices, then served with a sprinkle of cheese and fresh herbs.

The flavors are rich and comforting, offering a taste that’s both familiar and exciting.

14. Chef John’s Italian Meatballs

Chef John's Italian Meatballs
© CookUnity

Los Angeles boasts Chef John’s Italian meatballs, a dish that pays homage to traditional Italian cooking. The flavors are rich and satisfying, offering a taste that’s both comforting and authentic.

Chef John’s creation is a culinary nod to the old country, delivering a dish that’s both timeless and delightful.

15. Flour + Water’s Ricotta Meatballs

Flour + Water's Ricotta Meatballs
© SFGATE

San Francisco’s Flour + Water offers ricotta meatballs that are a revelation for the senses. These meatballs combine beef and creamy ricotta, creating a texture that’s both light and satisfying.

The flavors are enhanced by a rich sauce, adding depth to each bite.

16. Truffle Meatballs at The Modern

Truffle Meatballs at The Modern
© meatballbar.com

Located in the artistic hub of San Francisco, The Modern offers a contemporary culinary experience like no other. Their Truffle Meatballs are a sophisticated delight that captures the essence of luxury dining.

Infused with the earthy aroma of truffles, these meatballs are tender and full of flavor. The addition of microgreens adds a fresh touch.

17. Firefly’s Meatballs at Firefly

Firefly's Meatballs at Firefly
© OpenTable

Down in the southern charm of New Orleans, Firefly serves up a dish that is as fiery as its name. Firefly’s Meatballs are a testament to bold flavors and creative culinary techniques.

These spicy meatballs are not for the faint-hearted, with a zest that will keep your taste buds dancing.