Welcome to the ultimate Walmart Bakery Pie Showdown, where the crust is flaky, the filling’s fantastic… or not! From timeless flavors that’ll have you singing “Pie, oh my!” to those that make you wonder if they got lost on the way to the bakery, we’re about to see which pies take the crown and which ones get left out in the cold, on the shelf. Let the sweet, flaky battle begin!
15. Lemon Meringue Pie
Walmart’s Lemon Meringue Pie should deliver a tangy zing, but it often disappoints with an overly sweet filling. The lack of tartness fails to balance the sugar, making it less refreshing than expected.
The meringue topping, though fluffy, can’t save the pie from being underwhelming.
14. Cherry Pie
Because the filling in Walmart’s Cherry Pie tastes too sweet and fake, it falls short. The flavor is lackluster since the cherries don’t have the necessary tartness for balance.
It tastes more like candy than pie because of the syrupy consistency, which drowns out any flavors of fresh fruit.
13. Chocolate Cream Pie
This pie offers a sweet overload, with the chocolate flavor failing to impress. The lack of texture contrast makes each bite monotonous and overly sugary.
For chocolate lovers, it doesn’t quite satisfy the craving for a deep cocoa experience.
12. Coconut Cream Pie
Despite its creamy texture, Walmart’s Coconut Cream Pie feels bland and unsatisfying. The coconut flavor barely comes through, overshadowed by the overly sweet filling.
Unfortunately, the soggy crust detracts from the overall experience, leaving pie enthusiasts wanting more zest.
11. Pumpkin Pie
Walmart’s Pumpkin Pie attempts to capture fall’s essence, but falls short with its bland filling. Lacking the bold spices that characterize a good pumpkin pie, it doesn’t leave a lasting impression.
A touch more spice could elevate this seasonal classic to memorable heights.
10. Pecan Pie
After a few bites, Walmart’s Pecan Pie becomes cloying despite its rich flavor due to its heavy reliance on sugar.
The nuts’ inherent nuttiness is overpowered by the syrupy filling, leaving a sweet aftertaste. This pie may stand out with a little more balance.
9. Apple Pie
The soft, shallow filling in Walmart’s version of the traditional apple pie dish detracts from its appeal. Each bite is less enjoyable since the apples lack the desired crispness and taste depth.
Still, its nostalgic aroma might make it worth a try for some.
8. Peach Pie
Although Walmart’s Peach Pie has a sweet, fruity appeal, it frequently lacks the texture and color of fresh peaches.
Those looking for a peachy joy will find the experience less fulfilling because of the inconsistent texture.
7. Blueberry Pie
The Blueberry Pie from Walmart has a sweet and tart taste, but the natural tastes are overpowered by the thick, gelatinous filling.
It is muted rather than energetic because it lacks the fine balance required to highlight the blueberries’ natural acidity.
6. Sweet Potato Pie
Surprisingly delightful, Walmart’s Sweet Potato Pie offers a spiced filling that’s smooth and inviting. However, some might find it under-seasoned, craving a richer taste.
It’s a comforting choice, though a touch more spice could elevate its appeal for spice lovers.
5. Banana Cream Pie
With its creamy custard and fresh bananas, Walmart’s Banana Cream Pie offers a pleasing texture and flavor.
But other people may find it too sweet, which would take away from the appeal of the fresh fruit. Even with its high sugar content, this pie is nevertheless a delicious treat for banana lovers.
4. Key Lime Pie
Refreshing and well-balanced, Walmart’s Key Lime Pie hits the spot with its perfect mix of tart and sweet. The graham cracker crust complements the citrus filling, making it a standout choice for those seeking a tangy treat.
Its bright flavor profile makes it a refreshing delight.
3. Coconut Custard Pie
This pie stands out with its creamy, rich filling and pronounced coconut flavor. Unlike other coconut offerings, it strikes a perfect balance.
Walmart’s Coconut Custard Pie is a delicious treat that pleases without being overpowering, making it a great option for dessert fans who enjoy coconut.
2. Southern Pecan Pie
An improved version of the classic, Walmart’s Southern Pecan Pie offers a rich, nutty filling that’s well-balanced with sweetness.
It delivers a buttery, crunchy texture, providing a delightful contrast with the smooth filling, making it a must-try for pecan pie enthusiasts.
1. Patti LaBelle’s Sweet Potato Pie
The best among Walmart’s offerings, Patti LaBelle’s Sweet Potato Pie delivers a perfectly spiced and smooth filling.
With every bite, its well-balanced sweetness wins hearts. Pie fans should definitely try it; it’s the bakery aisle’s biggest winner.