Skip to Content

15 Must-Buy Costco Foods For First-Timers, Plus 4 Secret Deals You’ll Brag About

15 Must-Buy Costco Foods For First-Timers, Plus 4 Secret Deals You’ll Brag About

Sharing is caring!

Walking into Costco for the first time can feel like entering a magical wonderland of bulk bargains and unexpected treasures. Those massive aisles packed with everything from electronics to groceries can be overwhelming if you don’t know where to start.

Fear not, fellow shopper! I’ve compiled the ultimate list of Costco food finds that’ll make your membership worth every penny from day one.

1. Kirkland Signature Rotisserie Chicken

Kirkland Signature Rotisserie Chicken
© The Independent

Forget everything you thought you knew about grocery store rotisserie chickens. This three-pound miracle of culinary engineering costs just $4.99 and puts every other ready-made bird to shame.

Juicy on the inside with skin that somehow stays crispy during its journey home, this chicken is the ultimate weeknight dinner hack. Shred it for tacos, slice it for sandwiches, or devour it straight off the bone while standing in your kitchen (no judgment here).

2. Costco Hot Dog + Soda Combo

Costco Hot Dog + Soda Combo
© Fortune

$1.50 for a quarter-pound all-beef hot dog AND a refillable soda? This isn’t just lunch—it’s an economic miracle that’s remained the same price since 1985. The Costco food court legend is so sacred that co-founder Jim Sinegal once famously threatened to kill the CEO if he raised the price.

Nestled in a steamed bun with free condiments at your disposal, this hot dog has fueled countless shopping trips and budget-friendly family outings. The cult following is so intense that some people get Costco memberships specifically for food court access.

3. Garlic Parmesan Butter Dinner Rolls

Garlic Parmesan Butter Dinner Rolls
© Snarkle-Sauce on Wry

Holy carbohydrates! These pillowy clouds of buttery bliss will ruin regular dinner rolls for you forever. Found in Costco’s bakery section, these pull-apart beauties come 36 to a package—perfect for feeding a crowd or, let’s be honest, just yourself over several glorious days.

Already slathered with garlic parmesan butter that melts into every nook when warmed, they require zero effort beyond popping them in the oven. The exterior develops a slight crispness while the inside remains soft and fluffy.

4. Kirkland Signature Shredded Mexican‑Style Cheese

Kirkland Signature Shredded Mexican‑Style Cheese
© Yahoo

Cheese fanatics, rejoice! This five-pound bag of melty magnificence is about to transform your taco Tuesdays, nacho nights, and midnight quesadilla cravings. The perfect blend of monterey jack, cheddar, queso quesadilla, and asadero cheeses creates a harmonious melt that puts those skimpy grocery store bags to shame.

Smart packaging divides it into two resealable sections, so half stays fresh while you work through the other portion. No weird anti-caking agents or suspicious ingredients here—just pure dairy goodness.

5. Honey Smoked Salmon Stackers

Honey Smoked Salmon Stackers
© Yahoo

Salmon skeptics, prepare to be converted! These bite-sized flavor bombs combine premium smoked salmon with a touch of honey for a sweet-savory profile that’s downright addictive. Perfectly portioned and individually wrapped, they’re the ultimate grab-and-go protein fix.

Toss them on bagels with cream cheese, chop them into pasta, or—as many Costco veterans do—eat them straight from the package while hiding in your pantry. The subtle smokiness pairs beautifully with the hint of sweetness, creating a balanced flavor that even fish-hesitant folks love.

6. Kirkland Signature Salted Sweet Cream Butter

Kirkland Signature Salted Sweet Cream Butter
© Fig App

Butter lovers, brace yourselves. This isn’t your average supermarket spread—it’s four one-pound blocks of creamy, European-style magnificence that will elevate everything from morning toast to fancy baking projects. Each golden bar contains 82% butterfat (higher than standard American butter), creating a richer flavor and smoother texture.

The individually wrapped pounds stay fresh longer, and you can freeze what you don’t need immediately. Bakers swear by its consistent quality and clean taste that doesn’t overpower delicate pastries.

7. Kirkland Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Kirkland Extra Virgin Olive Oil
© Kalyn’s Kitchen

Certified by the International Olive Oil Council and cold-pressed from Italian olives, this liquid gold consistently outperforms fancy boutique brands in blind taste tests. The two-liter bottle might seem excessive until you discover how quickly good olive oil disappears when you’re not rationing it like liquid diamonds.

With a perfect balance of peppery finish and fruity notes, it works beautifully for everything from high-heat cooking to delicate salad dressings. Unlike many supermarket “extra virgin” imposters that fail purity tests, Kirkland’s version is the real deal.

8. Kirkland Organic Pure Maple Syrup

Kirkland Organic Pure Maple Syrup
© Daily Meal

Aunt Jemima who? Once you’ve poured this amber nectar of the gods over your pancakes, there’s no going back to corn syrup imitations. Harvested from organic maple trees and packaged in a massive jug that seems to last forever, this Grade A syrup delivers rich, complex sweetness that puts the fake stuff to shame.

Beyond breakfast, adventurous cooks use it to glaze salmon, sweeten cocktails, or drizzle over roasted vegetables. The robust flavor means you actually use less, making the price-per-serving surprisingly economical.

9. Nuts & Seeds

Nuts & Seeds
© costgoer

Sticker shock at regular grocery store nut prices? Costco’s massive bags of premium nuts and seeds will have you doing a double-take at the register—in a good way! From heart-healthy almonds to protein-packed walnuts and everything in between, these bulk beauties cost a fraction of what you’d pay elsewhere.

Raw, roasted, salted, or unsalted—the variety is impressive. Smart shoppers portion them into smaller containers and freeze what they won’t use within a month to preserve freshness. Perfect for snacking, baking, or creating your own trail mix.

10. Pot Stickers (Frozen)

Pot Stickers (Frozen)
© Reddit

Takeout cravings at midnight? These frozen flavor bombs will save your wallet and satisfy your dumpling desires in just minutes. Packed with a savory pork and vegetable filling wrapped in perfectly chewy dough, they’re shockingly close to restaurant quality.

The massive bag contains dozens of individually quick-frozen potstickers that won’t clump together, so you can cook exactly what you need. Pan-fry them for that perfect crispy bottom, or steam them for a softer texture—either way, they’re ready in under 10 minutes.

11. Frozen Fruit & Veggies

Frozen Fruit & Veggies
© The Kitchn

Smoothie enthusiasts and busy home cooks, prepare for your freezer to be transformed! Costco’s frozen produce section offers enormous bags of flash-frozen fruits and vegetables that are often better quality than the “fresh” stuff sitting for days in regular grocery stores.

The mixed berries bag alone—a treasure trove of plump strawberries, blueberries, and blackberries—will revolutionize your breakfast routine. Meanwhile, the stir-fry vegetable medleys make weeknight dinners practically effortless.

12. Kirkland Canned Tuna & Wild Salmon Burgers

Kirkland Canned Tuna & Wild Salmon Burgers
© Besties with Biceps

Protein powerhouses that won’t break the bank! Kirkland’s wild-caught albacore tuna puts those tiny grocery store cans to shame with its firm texture and clean flavor. Packed in water with no funky additives, it’s perfect for everything from classic tuna salad to fancy niçoise.

Even more impressive are the wild salmon burgers—individually flash-frozen patties made from whole cuts of Alaskan salmon (not the mysterious pink mush you find elsewhere). They cook straight from frozen in minutes, delivering restaurant-quality meals on a Tuesday night.

13. Cotton Candy Grapes

Cotton Candy Grapes
© Kids Activities Blog

No, you’re not hallucinating—these grapes genuinely taste like cotton candy! Through the miracle of natural cross-breeding (no artificial flavors here), these green grapes deliver an uncanny carnival-like sweetness that will blow your mind and convert even the most stubborn fruit-avoiders.

Available during their seasonal window (typically late summer), these juicy gems command long lines and occasionally minor shopping cart traffic jams in the produce section. They’re perfect for snacking, adding to fruit salads, or freezing for a healthy dessert alternative.

14. Island Way Sorbet

Island Way Sorbet
© Reddit

Dessert doesn’t get more Instagram-worthy than these! Served in their natural fruit shells (think hollowed-out lemons, coconuts, and oranges), these frozen sorbets deliver a theatrical finale to any dinner party. The mixed case includes coconut, mango, orange, and lemon varieties—each more refreshing than the last.

Beyond their obvious aesthetic appeal, the sorbets themselves are creamy yet dairy-free, with intense natural flavors that taste like summer in a spoon. They arrive perfectly portioned and ready to serve, eliminating dessert prep entirely.

15. Kirkland Breakfast Sandwich (Frozen)

Kirkland Breakfast Sandwich (Frozen)
© Costcuisine

Morning meetings and early sports practices just got a whole lot easier! These grab-and-go breakfast miracles feature a perfectly proportioned English muffin, fluffy egg, cheese, and your choice of Canadian bacon or sausage.

Pop one in the microwave for 90 seconds or wrap in foil for a toaster oven revival that’ll make your kitchen smell like a weekend brunch spot. The individually wrapped sandwiches can go straight from freezer to microwave, making them perfect for chaotic mornings.

16. Strawberry Streusel Cheesecake

Strawberry Streusel Cheesecake
© Southern Living

Weighing in at a whopping 5 pounds, this monster dessert has ended many diet plans and zero regrets. The buttery graham cracker crust cradles a perfectly tangy New York-style cheesecake topped with sweet strawberry glaze and a generous crown of cinnamon streusel.

Despite its massive size, the texture remains consistently creamy throughout—no easy feat for a cheesecake this large. Each slice delivers the perfect balance of creamy, crunchy, and fruity in every bite.

17. Caramel Tres Leches Cake

Caramel Tres Leches Cake
© Delish

Prepare for a religious experience disguised as dessert! This massive sheet cake combines the milk-soaked magic of traditional tres leches with ribbons of rich caramel that should be illegal in at least seven states. The result? A somehow-not-soggy miracle that maintains perfect texture while delivering sweet, creamy decadence in every forkful.

The light vanilla sponge absorbs three types of milk without collapsing, while the caramel adds depth and the whipped topping provides airy contrast. It’s sophisticated enough for special occasions yet dangerously accessible for random Tuesday night cravings.

18. Veggies Made Great Spinach Egg‑White Frittatas

Veggies Made Great Spinach Egg‑White Frittatas
© Easy Lunches

Healthy breakfast in 90 seconds? These mini veggie-packed frittatas are about to become your weekday morning superheroes! Packed with spinach, onions, bell peppers, and cheese in an egg white base, each muffin-shaped miracle delivers 90 calories of actual nutrition when you’re racing out the door.

Unlike most frozen breakfast options that leave you hungry an hour later, these protein-packed bites provide lasting energy without a sugar crash. The vegetables maintain their flavor and texture through the freezing process—no mushy disappointments here.

19. La Terra Fina Smoked Gouda & Peppers Dip

La Terra Fina Smoked Gouda & Peppers Dip
© greentrees1632

Party heroes take note: this refrigerated dip consistently disappears faster than any other appetizer at gatherings. The creamy blend of smoked gouda cheese with colorful bell peppers and jalapeños creates an addictive combination that somehow pairs perfectly with everything—chips, veggies, crackers, or straight off your finger when nobody’s looking.

Unlike those suspicious shelf-stable dips full of unpronounceable ingredients, this refrigerated gem contains real cheese and actual vegetables. The smoky-spicy-creamy trifecta hits all the right flavor notes without overwhelming your palate.