Peanut butter isn’t just a tasty treat—it’s packed with protein, healthy fats, and essential nutrients that can fuel your body.
Finding brands without added sugars, oils, or preservatives can be tricky in grocery store aisles filled with options.
Let’s explore the 15 healthiest peanut butter brands that deliver maximum nutrition without sacrificing that creamy, nutty flavor we all crave!
1. Crazy Richard’s 100% Peanuts
Ever wondered what pure peanut goodness tastes like? Crazy Richard’s contains exactly one ingredient: peanuts. Nothing else!
No salt, sugar, or oils get in the way of this protein-packed spread. Their commitment to simplicity makes this brand a nutritionist’s dream and a health-conscious shopper’s best friend.
2. Smucker’s Natural
What if I told you a household name could actually be good for you? Smucker’s Natural peanut butter contains just peanuts and a dash of salt. Though separation occurs naturally, a quick stir transforms it into creamy perfection. Widely available in most supermarkets, this affordable option proves healthy eating doesn’t require specialty store visits or breaking the bank!
3. 365 Organic Unsweetened
Whole Foods’ house brand delivers serious nutrition without serious cost! Their organic unsweetened peanut butter contains just organic peanuts and nothing else. If you’re watching sodium intake, this salt-free option deserves prime pantry position.
The smooth, rich texture spreads easily on everything from apple slices to whole grain toast. Grab a jar next time you’re shopping!
4. Santa Cruz Organic Dark Roasted
Holy flavor explosion! Santa Cruz’s dark-roasted organic peanuts create a uniquely rich taste profile that regular peanut butter can’t touch. The darker roast brings out natural oils and intensifies the nutty flavor without adding a single calorie.
Available in both crunchy and creamy varieties, this USDA organic certified option uses Spanish peanuts for exceptional quality.
5. Adams 100% Natural
Since 1922, Adams has been keeping it real with their no-nonsense approach to peanut butter. Zero hydrogenated oils, zero preservatives, zero nonsense! The distinctive glass jar packaging protects flavor while reducing plastic waste. Though you’ll need to refrigerate after opening, the extra-fresh taste makes this minor inconvenience worthwhile. Share this classic brand with the next generation!
6. Justin’s Classic Peanut Butter
Whoa! Justin’s revolutionary squeeze packs make healthy eating on-the-go actually possible! Their classic peanut butter contains just dry roasted peanuts and palm oil.
Though slightly pricier than competitors, the convenient packaging and exceptional quality justify the cost. The company’s commitment to sustainable palm oil sourcing also means you can enjoy this creamy treat with a clearer conscience.
7. Trader Joe’s Organic
Hence the cult following! Trader Joe’s organic peanut butter delivers exceptional quality at their famously reasonable prices. Available in both salted and unsalted varieties, this simple spread contains just organic peanuts and optional salt. The store’s Valencia peanut butter option offers a sweeter, more distinctive flavor profile from specialty Valencia peanuts. Try both and pick your favorite!
8. Once Again Organic Creamy
How utterly delightful is the raccoon mascot on Once Again’s jars?
Beyond adorable packaging, this employee-owned company delivers exceptional organic peanut butter. Their commitment to sustainable farming practices and fair trade principles makes each spoonful taste even better. The lightly toasted peanuts create a distinctive flavor profile that stands out from competitors. Can your current peanut butter say all that?
9. MaraNatha Organic No Sugar
Though slightly thicker than other brands, MaraNatha’s double-grinding process creates an unbelievably smooth texture without adding oils or stabilizers. Their distinctive slow-roasting method brings out complex flavor notes you won’t find elsewhere. Made in small batches to ensure quality, this premium option justifies its slightly higher price point with exceptional taste and texture. Would you like to upgrade your PB&J experience?
10. Teddie All Natural
If you’re from New England, you probably grew up with Teddie’s iconic yellow lid!
This regional favorite has been making simple, natural peanut butter since 1925. Their old-school manufacturing process grinds peanuts between traditional granite millstones for authentic texture. Despite its regional roots, Teddie has expanded distribution nationwide, allowing more people to experience this beloved classic. Have you spotted it in your local store?
11. Spread The Love NAKED Organic
Yowza! This small-batch California company takes peanut butter purity to new heights with their appropriately named NAKED variety.
Hand-packed in glass jars with zero preservatives, additives, or salt, this premium option represents the absolute purest form of peanut butter available commercially. Their commitment to freshness means each jar delivers maximum nutritional benefit and clean, unadulterated peanut flavor.
12. Kirkland Signature Organic
Costco’s house brand strikes again with bulk-sized healthy goodness!
Without sacrificing quality, their organic peanut butter is quite affordable. This easy two-ingredient spread (just peanuts and salt) comes in big 28-oz containers and is made using Valencia peanuts for a naturally sweeter flavor. Families or serious peanut butter lovers who go through jars rapidly would love the bigger size.
13. PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter
Brace yourself for a plot twist! PB2 isn’t traditional peanut butter—it’s a powdered version with 90% less fat than regular varieties.
Simply mix with water to create a spreadable consistency, or add directly to smoothies, oatmeal, or baking recipes. While texture differs from traditional peanut butter, the significant calorie reduction makes it popular among fitness enthusiasts and weight-conscious consumers.
14. Wild Friends Classic Creamy
Started by two college friends in their apartment kitchen, Wild Friends has grown into a beloved brand without losing its homemade charm.
Their classic creamy variety contains just peanuts and sea salt, delivering clean nutrition with exceptional flavor. The women-owned company focuses on sustainability and gives back to environmental causes with each purchase. Ready to support positive change with your peanut butter choice?
15. Fix & Fogg Super Crunchy
However did this New Zealand brand develop such a cult following?
Extra-large peanut bits in their award-winning Super Crunchy variant provide a significant amount of texture and enjoyment. Each batch is meticulously prepared by real people, not machines, in a specialized nut butter factory. The superior goods within is hinted at by the unique glass jar and letterpress-style label. Would you like to up your toast game with this global phenomenon?