Skip to Content

21 Beloved $2 Butter Cookies I’m Bringing To Every Holiday Party I’m Invited To

21 Beloved $2 Butter Cookies I’m Bringing To Every Holiday Party I’m Invited To

Sharing is caring!

Every holiday season, the aroma of freshly baked butter cookies fills homes with warmth and joy. This year, I’ve curated a list of 21 beloved butter cookies that will be accompanying me to every holiday party. Each cookie has its own unique charm and flavor, ensuring that there’s something for everyone to enjoy. From classic recipes to innovative twists, these cookies are bound to spread cheer and delight.

1. Classic Danish Butter Cookies

Classic Danish Butter Cookies
© Honey Blonde

If you’ve ever enjoyed a holiday tin, you know these. Classic Danish Butter Cookies are crispy, buttery delights that melt in your mouth. Their rich texture and balanced sweetness make them a nostalgic favorite.

Though simple in ingredients, their flavor is unparalleled, with each bite reminding you of cozy holiday memories. Often, they come in a variety of shapes, from pretzels to rings, adding visual appeal.

Additionally, these cookies are perfect for gift-giving. They travel well and maintain their freshness, making them a go-to choice for any party.

2. Lemon Zest Butter Cookies

Lemon Zest Butter Cookies
© Food & Wine

Bright and citrusy, Lemon Zest Butter Cookies bring a fresh twist to the traditional butter cookie profile. Their zesty aroma invites you to indulge.

The addition of lemon zest and glaze enhances their flavor, making them especially refreshing. If you’re a fan of citrus, these cookies will surely win you over.

Moreover, they pair beautifully with tea or coffee, adding a touch of elegance to any gathering. These cookies are always a hit, leaving guests craving more with their tangy sweetness.

3. Chocolate-Dipped Butter Cookies

Chocolate-Dipped Butter Cookies
© Persnickety Plates

Chocolate and butter—a match made in heaven! Chocolate-Dipped Butter Cookies offer a luxurious experience for chocolate lovers.

By dipping each cookie in dark chocolate, they gain a layer of richness that enhances their buttery base. The contrast of flavors is delightful.

Wherever you serve them, they’re sure to stand out. These cookies also make for a beautiful display on any dessert table. Their elegant appearance and indulgent taste leave a lasting impression.

4. Spiced Cinnamon Butter Cookies

Spiced Cinnamon Butter Cookies
© Recipe Tale

Warm and inviting, Spiced Cinnamon Butter Cookies bring a touch of holiday spice to the table. Infused with cinnamon, their aroma is reminiscent of festive cheer.

These cookies are perfect for those who love a hint of spice balanced with buttery goodness. Their texture is both soft and crisp.

Hence, they’re a delightful treat for cold winter nights, pairing well with hot cocoa or spiced cider. They add a cozy element to any party.

5. Vanilla Almond Butter Cookies

Vanilla Almond Butter Cookies
© The Lindsay Ann

Vanilla Almond Butter Cookies combine delicate vanilla notes with the crunch of almonds, creating a truly delightful snack. Their subtle sweetness and nutty texture are captivating.

However, it’s the almond topping that sets them apart, adding both visual appeal and flavor. These cookies are often the first to disappear at gatherings.

Do consider them for your next holiday party. They offer a sophisticated touch that guests appreciate. Their combination of flavors is both unique and familiar.

6. Coconut Butter Cookies

Coconut Butter Cookies
© BAKE WITH PAWS

Transport your taste buds to a tropical paradise with Coconut Butter Cookies. Their distinct coconut flavor and chewy texture make them a standout choice.

Each bite brings a hint of the tropics, a clever departure from traditional holiday flavors. They’re ideal for those who enjoy a bit of adventure.

Additionally, they complement other cookies perfectly, offering a refreshing change of pace. Their tropical flair adds diversity to any cookie assortment.

7. Hazelnut Butter Cookies

Hazelnut Butter Cookies
© Buttermilk by Sam

Nutty and rich, Hazelnut Butter Cookies offer a delightful combination of flavors. The addition of hazelnuts brings a unique twist to the classic butter cookie.

These cookies have a satisfying crunch and a deep, nutty aroma that appeals to the senses. They’re perfect for nut lovers.

Moreover, they pair wonderfully with coffee or a nice dessert wine, making them a versatile choice for any occasion. Their flavor profile is both robust and comforting.

8. Espresso Butter Cookies

Espresso Butter Cookies
© Family Cookie Recipes

For coffee enthusiasts, Espresso Butter Cookies are a dream come true. Infused with espresso, these cookies offer a bold, coffee-forward flavor.

The hint of caffeine adds an invigorating touch, while their buttery base keeps them balanced. They’re a perfect afternoon pick-me-up.

Additionally, these cookies are ideal for pairing with a freshly brewed cup of coffee or espresso. Their rich aroma and flavor complement any coffee break.

9. Maple Pecan Butter Cookies

Maple Pecan Butter Cookies
© The Conscious Plant Kitchen

Maple Pecan Butter Cookies bring the warmth of maple syrup combined with crunchy pecans. Their sweet, nutty flavor is truly comforting.

The combination of maple and pecan creates a delectable balance, making them a cozy choice for holiday gatherings. They’re perfect for those who enjoy rich, autumnal flavors.

Though they shine on their own, pairing them with a glass of milk or a cup of tea enhances their comforting qualities. These cookies evoke a sense of home.

10. Gingerbread Butter Cookies

Gingerbread Butter Cookies
© Baker by Nature

Gingerbread Butter Cookies offer a festive twist on the traditional butter cookie. Infused with ginger and spices, they bring holiday cheer with every bite.

Their warm, spicy aroma is irresistible, making them a favorite at any holiday party. They’re especially popular with children, thanks to their fun shapes.

Moreover, these cookies pair wonderfully with warm drinks, enhancing their spicy notes. They’re a must-have for any festive gathering.

11. Orange Blossom Butter Cookies

Orange Blossom Butter Cookies
© NYT Cooking – The New York Times

Infused with the essence of orange blossoms, these cookies are a fragrant delight. Their delicate flavor is both refreshing and unique.

Orange Blossom Butter Cookies bring a touch of elegance to any platter, with their subtle citrus notes tantalizing the palate. They are perfect for spring-themed parties.

In addition, they pair beautifully with herbal teas or sparkling beverages. Their light, floral aroma adds a sophisticated touch to any gathering.

12. Brown Sugar Butter Cookies

Brown Sugar Butter Cookies
© Hey, Snickerdoodle!

With a deep, caramel-like flavor, Brown Sugar Butter Cookies offer a richer alternative to traditional recipes. Their soft texture is comforting.

These cookies are a favorite among those who appreciate a deeper sweetness. The brown sugar imparts a unique taste that leaves a lasting impression.

Additionally, they work well with a variety of drinks, from coffee to hot chocolate. Their inviting aroma and flavor make them irresistible.

13. Peanut Butter Butter Cookies

Peanut Butter Butter Cookies
© Allrecipes

Peanut Butter Butter Cookies combine two beloved flavors into one delightful treat. The rich peanut butter taste is complemented by the buttery base.

These cookies are especially popular with children, thanks to their familiar, comforting flavor. They’re perfect for casual gatherings.

Moreover, they can be easily personalized with toppings like chocolate chips or a drizzle of honey. Their versatility and flavor make them a staple at any party.

14. Lavender Butter Cookies

Lavender Butter Cookies
© Jill Silverman Hough

Lavender Butter Cookies bring a touch of floral sophistication to any event. Their subtle lavender flavor is both calming and intriguing.

These cookies are ideal for afternoon teas or elegant gatherings where a gentle, aromatic treat is appreciated. They offer a unique taste experience.

Additionally, they are visually appealing, with a hint of purple and delicate floral adornments. Their charm and flavor make them a standout choice.

15. Rosemary Butter Cookies

Rosemary Butter Cookies
© Cupcakes & Cashmere

For a savory twist, Rosemary Butter Cookies offer a delightful surprise. The infusion of rosemary adds an herbal note that complements their buttery base.

These cookies are perfect for those who enjoy savory flavors with a hint of sweetness. They’re a unique addition to any cookie platter.

Moreover, they pair well with cheese and wine, making them ideal for sophisticated parties. Their distinctive flavor profile sets them apart.

16. Caramel Butter Cookies

Caramel Butter Cookies
© Mindee’s Cooking Obsession

Caramel Butter Cookies deliver a rich, buttery experience enhanced by caramel’s sweetness. Their melt-in-the-mouth texture is a delight.

The caramel drizzle adds a touch of elegance, making them ideal for special occasions. They appeal to those with a sweet tooth.

Additionally, they pair well with coffee or tea, offering a sweet counterpoint. Their luxurious flavor makes them a crowd favorite.

17. Matcha Green Tea Butter Cookies

Matcha Green Tea Butter Cookies
© Takes Two Eggs

For a taste of Japan, Matcha Green Tea Butter Cookies offer a unique, earthy flavor. The matcha imparts a vibrant green color, making them visually striking.

These cookies appeal to those who enjoy the distinctive taste of green tea. They’re perfect for tea lovers and adventurous eaters.

Additionally, they pair beautifully with traditional Japanese teas, enhancing their flavor. Their exotic taste sets them apart from conventional choices.

18. Rum Raisin Butter Cookies

Rum Raisin Butter Cookies
© Okonomi Kitchen

Rum Raisin Butter Cookies offer a delightful mix of rum’s warmth and sweet raisins. Their flavor is both comforting and festive.

These cookies are ideal for holiday parties, where their unique taste can be fully appreciated. They bring a touch of sophistication.

Moreover, they pair well with dessert wines or eggnog, enhancing their festive qualities. Their distinctive taste is sure to impress guests.

19. Pumpkin Spice Butter Cookies

Pumpkin Spice Butter Cookies
© I Am Baker

Pumpkin Spice Butter Cookies capture the essence of autumn in every bite. Their spicy, sweet flavor is reminiscent of cozy fall days.

These cookies are perfect for seasonal gatherings, where their warm spices can be enjoyed. They’re a favorite during Halloween and Thanksgiving.

Additionally, they pair beautifully with spiced lattes or hot apple cider. Their seasonal charm makes them a popular choice.

20. Pistachio Butter Cookies

Pistachio Butter Cookies
© Simply Recipes

Pistachio Butter Cookies add a nutty elegance to any dessert table. Their vibrant green color and delightful crunch are captivating.

These cookies are ideal for those who appreciate the subtle flavor of pistachios. They’re perfect for sophisticated gatherings.

Moreover, they pair well with a variety of teas, complementing their nutty notes. Their unique color and flavor make them a standout choice.

21. Honey Lavender Butter Cookies

Honey Lavender Butter Cookies
© Sweet Kitchen Cravings

Finally, Honey Lavender Butter Cookies offer a sweet, floral experience. The combination of honey and lavender creates a harmonious flavor.

These cookies are ideal for elegant afternoon teas, where their delicate taste can be fully appreciated. They provide a calming culinary experience.

Additionally, their beautiful presentation, with floral toppings, makes them as visually appealing as they are tasty. They’re a delightful addition to any gathering.