Skip to Content

12 Sandwiches To Order & 12 To Avoid At Restaurants

12 Sandwiches To Order & 12 To Avoid At Restaurants

Sharing is caring!

When you’re out dining, the vast array of sandwich options can be overwhelming. How does one decide what to indulge in and what to skip?

Here’s a fresh perspective on which sandwiches you should order and which ones might be best to leave off your plate.

1. Classic Reuben Sandwich

Where can you find a sandwich piled high with satisfaction? The Classic Reuben stands out. If you’re a fan of hearty flavors, this combination of corned beef, Swiss cheese, tangy sauerkraut, and Russian dressing on rye might be your go-to.

Though it might be a bit messy, each bite transports you to a warm, bustling New York deli. However, moderation is key, as the richness can be overwhelming if you’re not prepared. Nevertheless, this sandwich certainly packs a punch worth savoring.

2. Tuna Salad Sandwich

Not every sandwich is worth the calories. The Tuna Salad Sandwich often disappoints. If you’ve ever bitten into one with too much mayonnaise and soggy bread, you know the struggle. Though some places get it right, many miss the mark with a bland and uninspired mix.

Where’s the crunch? The freshness? It feels like a missed opportunity. Ultimately, unless you’re in a trusted spot known for their exceptional tuna, you might want to steer clear. Saving your appetite for something more exciting could be the better choice.

3. Spaghetti And Meatball Sub

A spaghetti and meatball sub may sound like a carb overload, but it’s a culinary marvel. Imagine your favorite spaghetti dinner packed inside a sandwich, complete with meatballs, marinara sauce, and a hint of parmesan.

The contrast between the soft bread and the savory pasta creates a texture that’s strangely satisfying. Beware of potential messiness as this sub often requires a fork and knife. Consider this option if you’re in the mood for a comfort meal with a twist.

4. Peanut Butter And Pickle Sandwich

The peanut butter and pickle sandwich is a polarizing yet intriguing choice. The creamy texture of peanut butter meets the sharp tang of pickles, creating a flavor combination that defies expectations. This sandwich is often seen as an acquired taste.

Don’t let skepticism deter you from trying it. The contrasting flavors meld surprisingly well, offering a refreshing crunch with every bite. If you’re feeling bold and ready to step out of your culinary comfort zone, this sandwich awaits you.

5. Fried Green Tomato BLT

A Southern twist on the classic BLT, this sandwich combines the tangy crunch of fried green tomatoes with the salty crispiness of bacon. Fresh lettuce adds a refreshing touch, while a smear of creamy aioli ties everything together. The toasted sourdough provides a sturdy base for these flavors.

This sandwich is the perfect balance of textures and tastes, making it a must-try for those who enjoy Southern cuisine. Paired with sweet potato fries and a cold glass of iced tea, it’s a meal for any time of the day.

6. Chocolate And Blue Cheese Panini

This daring combination might not be for everyone, but adventurous eaters could find it intriguing. The rich, creamy texture of melted chocolate contrasts with the sharp, tangy notes of blue cheese. Grilled to perfection, the panini bread holds these bold flavors together.

Each bite offers an unexpected mix of sweet and savory, challenging traditional sandwich norms. While this is an exciting choice for those eager to explore new tastes, it’s not recommended for those who prefer classic sandwich flavors.

7. The Jellyfish Delight

This sandwich is a bold culinary experiment. It features jellyfish, known for its unique texture and subtle flavor, paired with fresh seaweed. Served on a crispy baguette, the sandwich includes thinly sliced cucumbers for added crunch.

It might not be on every menu, but when available, it offers a rare taste adventure. Be prepared for a salty sea essence, reminiscent of an ocean breeze. If you’re at a seaside restaurant known for pushing culinary boundaries, consider trying this daring sandwich.

8. The Dessert Burger

The Dessert Burger

© westvillagecurated

Taking inspiration from both desserts and burgers, this sandwich features a donut as the bun. Filled with rich vanilla ice cream, it offers a sweet twist on a savory classic. The addition of a caramel drizzle enhances the sweetness.

Sprinkles add a playful touch. Found at quirky cafes, this treat is perfect for those with a sweet tooth. Though unconventional, the Dessert Burger can surprise even the most seasoned foodies. If you’re dining at a place known for creative desserts, don’t hesitate to savor this unique concoction.

9. The Viking Feast

The Viking Feast

© johansjoe

This sandwich is a bold creation, bringing together the hearty flavors of Scandinavia in a single bite. This unique sandwich features tender slices of venison, perfectly complemented by a tangy cranberry chutney. Each bite is accentuated with the sharpness of aged cheddar, providing a rich taste experience.

Served on a robust rye bread, this sandwich pays homage to traditional Viking cuisine. Its rustic presentation, often on a wooden plate, adds authenticity to the dining experience. It’s a perfect choice for those seeking culinary adventure.

10. The Garden Bloom

The Garden Bloom sandwich is a feast for both the eyes and the palate. It features an array of colorful edible flowers nestled alongside creamy avocado slices, creating a harmonious blend of flavors. The inclusion of sprouted grains adds a wholesome crunch.

This sandwich is as much about aesthetics as it is about taste, often presented on a garden-themed table adorned with fresh herbs. It’s perfect for those who appreciate the beauty of nature in their food.

11. Bacon, Banana, And Honey Sandwich

This unusual combination creates a surprisingly delightful taste experience. The salty crunch of bacon pairs beautifully with the creamy sweetness of ripe bananas. Drizzling honey adds a touch of floral sweetness that ties everything together.

Served on toasted multigrain bread, this sandwich is bound to intrigue those with adventurous taste buds. It’s reminiscent of an elevated childhood treat, offering a playful twist. However, it might not appeal to everyone, especially those averse to mixing fruit with savory elements.

12. Pickled Onion And Sardine Sandwich

This sandwich is not for the faint-hearted. With bold flavors, it showcases the tang of pickled onions alongside the briny taste of sardines. The rye bread adds a hearty backdrop to this seafood-centric creation.

It’s a sandwich that demands attention and is likely to divide opinions. Ideal for those who appreciate strong, pungent flavors and are seeking something out of the ordinary. While it might be an acquired taste for some, others may find it an adventure in each bite

13. The Maple Bacon Waffle Sandwiche

Looking for an indulgent twist to your brunch? The Maple Bacon Waffle Sandwich might just hit the spot. Imagine crunchy bacon paired with gooey melted cheese, all sandwiched between two fluffy waffles. A light drizzle of maple syrup ties everything together.

This sandwich balances sweet and savory flavors, making it a treat for those who aren’t afraid to indulge. The waffles add a fun texture, and the bacon provides a satisfying crunch. If you’re feeling adventurous, this sandwich is worth a try.

14. The Cactus Club

The Cactus Club is definitely a unique entry in the sandwich world. Featuring grilled cactus paddles, this sandwich is topped with spicy aioli, fresh lettuce, and juicy tomatoes, all inside a whole grain bun.

The cactus paddles have a slightly tangy taste, which pairs well with the creamy aioli. While intriguing, this sandwich might not suit everyone’s palate. The texture of the cactus can be unexpected for those unfamiliar with it.

15. The Octopus Roll

This unique sandwich features tender, marinated octopus tentacles nestled in a crusty roll. A tangy garlic aioli complements the seafood, while fresh parsley adds a pop of color. Spritz some lemon juice for balance, and you have a culinary masterpiece that transports you seaside.

Perfect for seafood lovers craving something different. Be prepared for curious stares and envious glances as you savor each bite. It’s a conversation starter and a delight for the taste buds, showcasing the chef’s creativity and skill.

16. The Ice Cream Sub

Avoid the Ice Cream Sub unless you have a serious sweet tooth. This dessert sandwich combines the unexpected—scoops of your favorite ice cream flavors packed into a soft, sugary bun. The addition of chocolate chips and rainbow sprinkles might seem fun, but the result is overly sweet and messy.

While some might find charm in its novelty, the combination might be better suited for a sundae than a sandwich. It’s a sugar overload that could overshadow your meal, leaving you craving something savory to reset your palate.

17. The Sushi Roll Sandwich

Imagine a fusion of Japanese and Western cuisine, where the elegance of sushi meets the hearty nature of a sandwich. This creation combines fresh sashimi-grade fish, crisp seaweed, and pickled ginger, all nestled within a perfectly baked baguette.

It’s a symphony of textures and flavors that dance on the palate. Paired with wasabi and soy sauce, it challenges the conventional sandwich norms. A daring choice for anyone seeking a bold culinary adventure.

18. The Mac ‘N’ Cheese Melt

This sandwich is a comfort food lover’s dream. The Mac ‘n’ Cheese Melt takes creamy, decadent macaroni and cheese and sandwiches it between slices of perfectly toasted bread.

The outer crust is crisp while the inside remains gooey and rich, creating a delightful contrast with every bite. Sprinkled with crispy bacon bits, it offers a smoky, savory crunch that complements the creamy interior. This melt is a warm, cheesy escape from the ordinary that invites indulgence and satisfaction.

19. The Tempura Crunch

Ever considered a shrimp sandwich with a twist? The Tempura Crunch offers a delightful mix of textures and flavors. Crispy tempura shrimp is the star, complemented by a rainbow of fresh veggies that provide a refreshing contrast.

Served on a toasted brioche bun, it’s finished with a sweet chili drizzle that adds an unexpected zing. This sandwich promises a satisfying bite with each mouthful. Just be cautious of the chili if you prefer milder flavors.

20. The Midnight Special

In the mood for something a bit magical? The Midnight Special is not your typical sandwich. Featuring slices of midnight-black bread, it’s filled with luminescent cheese that lights up the meal. An array of glowing vegetables adds an extra touch of mystery and whimsy.

Served in a dimly lit, magical-themed restaurant, this sandwich is perfect for those who enjoy a side of intrigue with their meal. It’s as much a feast for the eyes as it is for the palate. Just remember, it might be more about the experience than the taste.

21. The Cheesy Meteor

The Cheesy Meteor is a sight to behold on any menu. With its cosmic-themed presentation, this sandwich layers various exotic cheeses such as Comté, Taleggio, and Roquefort, creating a flavor explosion. The edible glitter adds a whimsical touch, making it resemble a celestial body.

The sandwich’s plush, freshly baked bread complements the rich cheese textures. While its appearance might seem otherworldly, its taste remains grounded in creamy, cheesy goodness. Eat this sandwich in a space-themed restaurant.

22. The Green Tornado

Packed with kale, avocado, and cucumber, this sandwich offers a refreshing crispy texture. Spirulina is sprinkled throughout, adding a unique twist and a vibrant green hue. The sandwich is served on whole grain bread.

The eco-friendly café setting where it’s served emphasizes sustainability, mirroring the sandwich’s fresh and earth-friendly ingredients. For those seeking an invigorating, green-filled culinary experience, The Green Tornado stands as an exciting choice to savor.

23. The BBQ Pulled Jackfruit Sandwich

If you’re looking to spice up your sandwich game, the BBQ Pulled Jackfruit Sandwich might just be your next go-to. This plant-based delight is an excellent alternative for those seeking something meatless yet flavorful.

The texture is reminiscent of pulled pork, but with a unique twist. Pair it with tangy pickled onions and creamy coleslaw for an explosion of textures and flavors. This sandwich offers a guilt-free indulgence with each bite.

24. The Spicy Chocolate Chili Chicken Sandwich

The Spicy Chocolate Chili Chicken Sandwich

© originalnathans

Embark on a flavor journey with the Spicy Chocolate Chili Chicken Sandwich. This bold creation combines savory and sweet in a way that’s sure to tantalize adventurous palates. Picture succulent chicken breast, marinated in a blend of dark chocolate and fiery chili spices.

The richness of the chocolate is perfectly balanced by the heat of the chilies, offering a complex taste profile. Nestled in a toasted ciabatta roll, it’s topped with fresh arugula for a peppery finish.